In effect, the volumes and page numbers from the official reporter are anchors in the text -- and are stored that way in other databases (and sometimes included as textual anchors in secondary printed references.)
Most online versions I've seen do include both the citation and page numbers from the official reporters.
> If a court says (in slightly more words) "pages 205 to 207 are overruled" there are often paragraphs that span from pages 204-205 and from 207-208 that are ambiguous
US courts don't generally do that. They cite prior cases using page references, but they don't say "pages X-Y" are overruled. Its not a matter of more or less words, that's just not how they work at all. If they are reversing a lower court decision, they simply state that the decision is reversed (and if it is reversed in part, they describe which effects are reversed, which may not map to specific separable parts of the text). If they are stating a new legal rule overriding a prior precedent, they simply state the new legal rule.
> and it gets even worse when a different book version is paginated so that the range above covers part of page 621 to part of page 624.
Different books aren't the official reporter. Different books (or online sources) that are intended to be legal references will often include, as anchors in the text, the page numbers from the official reporter at the point in the text where the pages break in the official reporter.
As an example in an online source, consider the Findlaw entry for The Amistad [1]. The heading includes the reference to the official reporter (40 U.S. 518) -- 518 is the page number on which the case starts in the official reporter.
Throughout the text on Findlaw, you'll see blue notes like "[40 U.S. 518, 523]" -- these indicate points of page breaks in the official reporter (they follow the style of standard legal citation, so 40 U.S. 518, 523 marks the beginning point of page 523, in the case beginning at page 518, in volume 40 of the United States Reports.)
[1] http://caselaw.lp.findlaw.com/scripts/getcase.pl?court=US&vo...
This leads to page numbers like 247.1151a-iii. Which is then the canonical page number for a block of text.
It's enough to make the Library of Congress filing system seem simple and rational!!
It's a fantastic system (and a wonderful demonstration of the advantages of immutable graph data structures). You can read cases from a century ago and still find every cited reference. Hyperlinking pales in comparison.
The hyperlink equivalent would be "you can find this book at this library in this town, as of the time this was written".
I imagine that in real life lawyers don't need to worry about that sort of instruction because those books are printed and widely distributed across the country, while on the web documents tend to exist in only a single location, maintained by a single person or organization. USENET might be the closest on the internet we have gotten to that sort of distribution model.
The difference is that a citation is a reference to an immutable object. No matter what happens to Roe v. Wade, say it is overruled, the document at 410 U.S. 113 won't change. A URL on the other hand is a reference to a location. Like with the memory address pointed-to by a C pointer, what is at that location can change.
One can imagine a system of hyperlinks that behaved differently. In this system, a URL would uniquely identify an immutable document. A new version of a document would get a new URL, and servers would be required by the protocol to preserve all previous versions of the document. This is essentially the premise of Git: every blob is stored forever and different revisions are stored as deltas such that older versions always remain accessible.
What we need is a technical mechanism for embedding referenced source documents into a document, in a way that is as easy as hyperlinking to add the references and follow them. Probably also a new fair-use provision in copyright law as well.
Agreed on having a way to embed documents. Especially in a way that supported some kind of signing. If I could have a reputable third party (web.archive.org or anybody else) sign an embedded snippet of a page and say "Yes, this was actually posted on X website at Y time" that would be fantastic.
Don't get me wrong, it's better than nothing, but to get any buy-in from existing lawyers these issues need to be addressed. I'm concerned that they haven't on the site.