Let me provide some anecdotal counter-evidence: during my last year of high school, I was in a university class where they taught us programming using Haskell (this was in 2000). I observed a fairly consistent pattern - those who had prior experience with imperative programming (me included), had far more difficulty picking up Haskell than those who hadn't.
The girl I worked with (who had no prior experience) was surprised, since "it's just like maths" :).
I actually graduated from UT's Comp Sci school and I know many of the "elements" courses (super introductory, even for non-majors) are taught in python. That, I think is a good introduction, but for people in the major, I don't think learning Haskell/functional programming is a stretch at all.
If one can wrap their minds around functional programming (which introduced correctly is actually relatively easy to grasp) -- it will be MUCH easier to learn imperative programming. In the end, any good imperative programming seeks to be modular (s/procedures|methods|subroutines/functions/g), and will liken itself to something you would write in functional programming (loosely couple functions that do a specific task well). Yes there are places this gets hairy (side effects, I/O based operations), but computer science is not about writing procedural code, it's really more about algorithms, which is why 4 year universities are NOT trade schools, but do prepare you for the real world (in that you're not COMPLETELY useless). Program syntax is easy to learn (a skilled faker can just repeat it verbatim), efficiency/correctness/proper data-structure usage is difficult.
The INTRO-intro CS class at the time actually used Pascal, and was endlessly confusing to me as a cold beginner.
My next course, however, was taught in Scheme, and immediately I felt more at home. And for the first time, I felt like I might have some actual aptitude for programming.
Without that peek into the elegant heart of computer science, I doubt I'd have stuck with it as long as I did.
For those entering CS, this is probably true. But it's also probably true that that's because of the students' own initiative to investigate a topic that interests them.
I think high schools have gone the opposite direction. In the 80s, most high schools had some sort of computer class (often taught on TRS-80s or C-64s). These were introductions to programming taught in Basic.
Nowadays, most high schools still have a computer class. But now its Word, Powerpoint, Excel, and build a (static) web page. (There are, of course, some high schools with much better programs.)
And good riddance. If you make it to university without exposing yourself to your subject as a matter of passion (and few subjects are more easily approached by hobbyists than programming) you're going to waste your time there.
University is a not a "school" you attend for learning a subject. You can't show up for English Literature if you have never read a novel. You show up at the music department if you don't already play an instrument very well. You can't show up at Zoology if you can't tell a reptile from a mammal. You can't study Economics if you've never heard of Keynes. And you can't study computer science if you can't program a computer.
This was not always the case for programming, but it certainly is today, and I'm not convinced it wasn't too in 2001.
> You can't study Economics if you've never heard of Keynes.
Have you ever even been to a university?
Also, surely the interview will ask you about your background knowledge of economics, and if you didn't know who Keynes was you're unlikely to get an offer.
In the US, a bachelors degree takes 4 years, consists of extensive 'general education' requirements outside of the emphasis area, and generally start with intro courses that are more in depth than what would have been studied in high school. So a background in the particular area is not required.
Knowledge of specific economists is not the norm in the basic college prep curriculum in the US. Students in the IB program (relatively rare, available in major cities so the majority don't have the option) or the AP program will have studied the subjects to a greater depth. At least equivalent to freshman/sophomore college courses in the subject.
For a bachelors degree the students will apply to schools and get in based on: GPA, SAT/ACT scores, extracurricular activities, interview (not used for the average university), and essays. Some schools put all freshmen into the same pot and require them to apply to their major after their freshman year. In that case, it'd be similar to your "Don't know Keynes? Probably won't get an offer." situation. However, that's also not the norm. And once at the school the students can usually change major with ease.
"The Faculty does not have standard requirements for subjects other than Maths: in particular A level Economics, though useful, is not a prerequisite."
http://www.econ.cam.ac.uk/ba/guide.pdf
(FWIW I did mathematics as an undergrad but I considered CS and spoke to CS faculty at various university open days, from what I remember they all considered maths to be the only essential A level for admission.)
In addition to that, among my circle of friends, it's common to know people who switched majors mid-school because they stumbled upon something they found more interesting - isn't that great? They thought they loved something, but found something they loved even more. Or, I guess they should have just been given the boot instead.
Yes, it's quite silly that college is mandatory rather than somewhere you go for the purpose of learning something in further depth.
I hope that you never make it to any position of authority or influence within education.
Thank god you're not in charge.
http://www.amazon.com/Fundamentals-Aerodynamics-Aeronautical...
Started reading it and the math was way above my head. So I went to my calc teacher and he acknowledged the material was beyond my reach. But then he pointed me to materials to help and offered his time to explain the basics.
This was before there were countless free high quality learning materials online.
Are you going to learn differential equations, statics, dynamics, etc... in high school? Maybe. Probably not. Who cares? That doesn't mean you can't start.
Build a model rocket. Build an RC plane. Dive into more accessible subjects like linear algebra. Learn matlab or octave. I could go on forever.
You would not believe the amount of AE students that struggled - and I mean struggled with Ds through intro to programming with C. I helped many with their homework. Get a leg up and start on that!
If the goal is to have a job, there are better ways of accomplishing that than taking on student debt and pursing something you are not that interested in (or spending lots of money trying to figure out what you enjoy).
At college I started as a Bioengineering major, because I really wanted to make medical devices. I took a CS class in the Spring of my Freshman year and realized that it "clicked" for me and I could go forward with it.
I am now graduating as a Bioengineering and Computer Science dual major and moving to a full time software engineering job at Google next year. I am grateful for the opportunity to learn something entirely new, and I worked my ass off to catch up with the kids who had been coding since they were 12. I don't think that I'm an impostor in the world of CS and I have the additional perspective of not always having known that this is what I want to do.
Guess those kids that cannot afford a computer are S.O.L. in your world.
Most subjects are easier to approach than computer programming just because of cost of entry.
Except for the Keynes thing, the stuff you're talking about is included in classes that every 12-year-old has to take. The analog would be using a computer rather than programming a computer.
It's not exactly a sexy career (for every übergeek in shorts with a Macbook Air there is an army of corporate drones with comporate-issue desktops using whatever tools corporate IT mandates, wearing corporate-standard neckties), it's difficult (to do it right) and financial return is far from assured.
http://www.studentbeans.com/student-money/a/degree-courses-w...
According to these numbers, of the 2006/2007 graduates in the UK, Computer Science had the highest unemployment rate after 6 months (10%).
I taught many aspiring programmers over my career and it's painful to see the struggle some go through contrasted with the ease the "naturals" have. Programming classes can't turn you into a programmer any more than swimming classes won't make you a fish. A good teacher will help you become a good programmer, but only if you have the knack [1].
> The idea behind a tiny and cheap computer for kids came in 2006, when Eben Upton, Rob Mullins, Jack Lang and Alan Mycroft, based at the University of Cambridge’s Computer Laboratory, became concerned about the year-on-year decline in the numbers and skills levels of the A Level students applying to read Computer Science. From a situation in the 1990s where most of the kids applying were coming to interview as experienced hobbyist programmers, the landscape in the 2000s was very different; a typical applicant might only have done a little web design.
I joined at about that time and found it noticeable that having experience with C++ and a few other languages marked me out as more advanced than many of the other students.
Also relevant to this discussion is that in the first term we learnt ML, a functional language. This was partially because of advantages in talking about algorithms in it, but also to put everyone on a level playing field and introduce something that even keener students won't have encountered before. We did Java later, which I found much less rewarding.
Also Larry Paulson is a legend.
Also, I once heard that Larry Paulson stopped going to a certain college's annual computer science dinner because he was hit with a pineapple during a food fight. Bastards.
However, I went to a pretty poor University (ranked ~60th), I have no doubt that the numbers are very different in the top universities.
Further evidence is the four class intro sequence steadily had fewer sections (of the same size) with each passing term
Honors Intro to Programming (161) is taught in Haskell and introduces monads 4 weeks in. Intro to Programming (151) is taught in Scheme (well, Racket) and works through How to Design Programs.
I know my university's first class in programming assumes prior experience (though nothing to worry about for a motivated student) and then offers an introductory course in python for students with no experience if they'd like. The University in question is still stuck in Java for the main courses like many other Universities.
Over in the UK I certainly hadn't encountered anything more complicated than html before I hit university, and was very happy with sticking with Java for the entirety of first year. I had been exposed to C++, ADA(!), Prolog and had an in depth look at Erlang by the time my course finished...