News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Twenty questions about the GPL by theBobMcCormick on Monday July 13, 2009 @04:02PM (#702357)
This would be a much more interesting article if the author had at least tried to get answers to his questions (perhaps from the GNU foundation or the Software Freedom Law Center, etc) and included that with his questions. That would have been an interesting article, and possibly useful to hackers and software entrepreneurs.

As it is, I'm surprised and disappointed that an article with so little substance has made it so high on the HN front page.

Re:Twenty questions about the GPL by callahad on Monday July 13, 2009 @06:01PM (#702588)
Just because "this is broken" wasn't followed by "...and here's how to fix it" doesn't mean that pointing out the initial flaw was without merit or substance. Still, I too wish someone at a qualified institution (FSF, SFLC, etc) would weigh in.
Re:Twenty questions about the GPL by tjr on Monday July 13, 2009 @05:31PM (#702527)
Yes, it would be more interesting. These questions may very well shed light on ambiguities in GPLv3. If so, then I imagine that the FSF would want to take this into consideration for GPLv4.
Re:Twenty questions about the GPL by eli on Monday July 13, 2009 @09:23PM (#702899)
I bet if you did that and reposted the questions with answers on your blog, it would make it to the front page again
Re:Twenty questions about the GPL by jrockway on Monday July 13, 2009 @05:13PM (#702491)
HN is largely anti-GPL. You are being dowmodded for that reason.
Re:Twenty questions about the GPL by benatkin on Monday July 13, 2009 @05:40PM (#702544)
No, he's being downmodded for suggesting that the author should have to contact one particular organization to get answers to simple questions about something as widely used and discussed as the GPL.
Re:Twenty questions about the GPL by tjr on Monday July 13, 2009 @05:49PM (#702569)
Then he's being downmodded unjustly, as he listed two specific organizations, included an "etc." in his list of organizations, and prefaced the entire list with a "perhaps".

Regardless of where the answers to these questions come from, it would be good to share the confusion with the FSF, in hopes that they can remedy it. I do not believe their goal is to inflict confusing licenses upon the general public, but they do have rather specific goals and attempt to address those goals in their licenses.

Re:Twenty questions about the GPL by benatkin on Tuesday July 14, 2009 @03:12PM (#704381)
Well, there's no such thing as the GNU Foundation (there's the Free Software Foundation and the GNU Project), so technically there's only one. :)

Assuming that he meant Free Software Foundation, his mention of The Free Software Law Center invalidates my point, though, because clearly they're not closely tied to the Free Software Foundation. Otherwise, they wouldn't say "Open Source" on their home page without going into a diatribe about the term.