News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Daft Punk Created One of Their Most Famous Samples by 3stripe on Saturday January 04, 2014 @11:16AM (#7011531)
Funny headline... you don't create samples, you take samples
Re:How Daft Punk Created One of Their Most Famous Samples by elvinmelvin on Saturday January 04, 2014 @12:16PM (#7011827)
the final product of the sample taken produced a newly created track. at least for sake of brevity, created seems acceptable in this context. it also probably is a good way of conceptualizing the legal issues involved (©) when an artist manipulates a sample enough to create a new derivative work so distinct that it ought be deemed a separate entity from the original. These legal limits are still being tested but after watching the video, i like the idea of looking at this manipulation as a form of creation rather than simply "taking". your legal millage may vary.
Re:How Daft Punk Created One of Their Most Famous Samples by 3stripe on Saturday January 04, 2014 @12:24PM (#7011858)
Agreed, so the sample is taken/used to create something new. I'm not saying that sampling is not creative, and I've done it myself on plenty of tracks.

But a sample only becomes creative after it is taken. You can't 'create' a sample because it is just a snippet of audio.

As the article says, it's about "building songs from samples".

I'm not being pedantic by the way.. I just see the person who 'created' the sample as the original recording artist.

Re:How Daft Punk Created One of Their Most Famous Samples by 001sky on Saturday January 04, 2014 @01:18PM (#7012168)
I just see the person who 'created' the sample as the original recording artist.

This is a perpetual debate =D. Although I'm not sure its black or white. A good artist can use a "sample" in the same way a panatone color is used by a pointillist painter. At that stage, its all about the spectrum of color, the contrast, and the entire effevt of many points of color...not just the quality of the sampled pigments in any one brush-stroke.

Re:How Daft Punk Created One of Their Most Famous Samples by catshirt on Saturday January 04, 2014 @11:31PM (#7014542)
Daft Punk is using samples to create a new sample.

so i think everyone is correct in this argument; they are using samples to create samples.

Re:How Daft Punk Created One of Their Most Famous Samples by aldanor on Saturday January 04, 2014 @06:54PM (#7013612)
In the context of this post, you indeed take and mangle samples. Generally speaking, you can create/synthesize samples, nothing wrong with it.
Re:How Daft Punk Created One of Their Most Famous Samples by 3stripe on Saturday January 04, 2014 @12:15PM (#7011815)
Why was this downvoted?
Re:How Daft Punk Created One of Their Most Famous Samples by JonnieCache on Saturday January 04, 2014 @12:23PM (#7011852)
Because it's tedious semantic quibbling, and it's not even correct. One samples a record, by doing this one creates a sample in ones sampler. One then plays this sample in a record of ones own, just like you would any other instrument or sound. You will likely manipulate the sample, like in the video, and then you will have created a new sample.

This isn't very clear in the video, because the editing process in modern software is very non destructive, so you never actually "make" a new sample. In the more primitive hardware of the past, the process is much more explicit.

If you have some other point to make about creative/artistic legitimacy, you should just make it.

Re:How Daft Punk Created One of Their Most Famous Samples by 3stripe on Saturday January 04, 2014 @12:26PM (#7011876)
So by your description, if it was really about how Daft Punk 'created' that sample, the article would just be a description of how they plugged a record player into a sampler and pressed the record button.

Which it clearly isn't.

Hence my first comment.

Re:How Daft Punk Created One of Their Most Famous Samples by JonnieCache on Saturday January 04, 2014 @12:33PM (#7011918)
I guess it sounds like you're pretending not to understand what is a fairly simple linguistic ambiguity, in order to start and then win a boring argument.

Sorry if this sounds mean, but you did ask.

Re:How Daft Punk Created One of Their Most Famous Samples by skunkworks on Saturday January 04, 2014 @01:34PM (#7012249)
No one, and I mean absolutely no one, is confused about what it means to sample a song, or to create a sample, or to take a sample from a song. That would be a tedious semantic argument of no value.

So most people interpret would instead interpret it as snide commentary on the illegitimacy of sampling as an art.

Which most people also don't like.

Hence the downvoting.

Re:How Daft Punk Created One of Their Most Famous Samples by f00_ on Saturday January 04, 2014 @12:47PM (#7012002)
Even if you didn't read that, you must at some point come to the conclusion the word "sample" is a bit ambiguous and might have many contexts and uses wouldn't you? Trying to make yourself feel smart by making a witty one liner, which in all fairness was unjustified, won't win you any awards.
Re:How Daft Punk Created One of Their Most Famous Samples by sliverstorm on Saturday January 04, 2014 @01:14PM (#7012146)
Because we all love unexpected debates over trivial semantics! Can't get enough of them!