Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow
by insteadof on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @04:21PM
(#6992911)
Asking about the colour of the bikeshed always draws more upvotes and views than a question asking why the screws buckle and eject when the outside temperature reaches 30C but only if the interior is 21C.
Popularity does not mean a question is within the scope of the site guidelines.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow
by frostmatthew on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @06:18PM
(#6993384)
> Popularity does not mean a question is within the scope of the site guidelines.
True, but it might indicate adequate reason for modifying the guidelines.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow
by m_myers on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @06:28PM
(#6993421)
There is a time and a place for everything. For opinion-based questions about programming, that place is http://www.slant.co/ (not affiliated with Stack Exchange).
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow
by vitd on Wednesday January 01, 2014 @02:50AM
(#6994525)
I just checked this out and it looks horrible. There are no categories. It's just a long list of unrelated questions, like "What's the best app for listening to music?" and "What's the best 2D graphics and physics engine?" It looks completely unusable.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow
by praveenhm on Tuesday December 31, 2013 @06:26PM
(#6993416)
This is one of the most annoying part of stack overflow,instead of closing the discussion,they should have a provision to move to more opinionated discussion list.
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow
by vitd on Wednesday January 01, 2014 @02:27AM
(#6994481)
They do. When you vote to close a question (and anyone can do that, not just moderators), you have to give a reason. One of the predefined reasons is "belongs on SuperUser stack exchange," and another where you can fill in a reason, such as "belongs on Programmer stack exchange." (Programmer is for code review, style questions, opinion-based stuff, etc.)
Re:Why I no longer contribute to Stack Overflow
by mark-r on Wednesday January 01, 2014 @01:15PM
(#6995765)
My experience is that programmers.stackexchange is even more militant about closing questions than stackoverflow. I guess they got tired of receiving all of the unwanted garbage and it makes them extra sensitive.
150 question upvotes.