That line of thinking is also a major cultural problem. A kid learning a lot in school does not in any way either magical or practical imply the world will provide a good job upon graduation.
There is a practical concern of that which can't continue forever will not continue forever. Median incomes are permanently dropping, at least in the USA, and will continue to do so for at least a couple decades best case. Go ahead, keep raising the cost of education, see where that leads you in a supply-demand scenario where the supply of money to feed the system is permanently declining but the supply of available product is permanently increasing with substantial fixed costs. That couldn't possibly lead to a collapse in that business sector in the future, could it? The only question is how to maximally profit off it by investing at this time for the future. Now that is a hard question.
No, but if you come out of college without being functionally literate, like 69% of US college graduates, then you're pretty much guaranteed not to get a good job. C.f nces.ed.gov/NAAL/PDF/2006470.PDF
From the document: "Basic indicates skills necessary to perform simple and everyday literacy activities." That sounds like functional literacy.
In Table 8 they break out 3 different types of literacy (prose, document, quantitative).
Those with college degrees that score at Basic or above are:
Prose: 97% (with 83% being above Basic)
Document: 98% (with 87% being above Basic)
Quantitative: 96% (with 74% being above Basic)
Note, if you compare this to people with less than High School (no HS degree or GED):
Prose: 50%
Document: 55%
Quantitative: 36%
Those are not skills I personally feel qualify you for a "good job", my definition of good job being defined as one where you work with your mind. However, basic literacy does not mean you cannot be a very skilled tradesman and know a craft extremely well.
However, the majority of college graduates are intermediate or proficient. Will they all become lawyers or programmers? No. Are they functionally literate and can they perform in a workplace? Most likely, yes.
The term has an actual definition. The fact is that 'proficient' is the minimum necessary to read a newspaper article, as per their definition of 'proficient'. If you can't do that, you sure as hell can't do any sort of knowledge work.
In the above scenario the demand form the right dried up, whereas with student loans the supply from the left is going to dry up, so it's a different scenario. However, who is the equivalent of the construction companies in this scenario? My guess is the companies who supply equipment etc to universities and are over reliant on their custom. If you can find them, short them.
Well anyway that's the best I could think up. Unlike other investments, a degree is something you keep forever, so it's interesting to analyse...
- Can I ask why you defined it this way? One could very well argue that this is precisely the problem. Students are looking at "cheap" monthly payments and not looking at the actual debt amount they're accruing. Cheap interest rates for student loans may or may not go away. The total amount of debt they collect will certain not go away. So we let them get saddled with debt in the hope that historically low interest rates aren't going anywhere. Sounds familiar.
So 1 year after graduation, of students with remaining loans, the average amount owed was 20.1k, and the median monthly payment was 8.0% of salary at the same point in time. But after a year or two salary should increase substantially, so loan payments should be a much smaller percentage. And a total average remaining debt of 20.1k after one year certainly isn't ideal, but it isn't really that unreasonable either, nor should it be especially burdensome. Obviously some people are dramatically worse off than this, but for most people the system doesn't seem especially broken. But to answer your question, I think that you need to look wholistically at total net cost increases, along with total debt, along with monthly loan payments and employment statistics. Looking at any one on its own will be highly misleading. Also keep in mind that different types of institutions and degrees lead to dramatically different outcomes in all of the above. I'm really only concerned with 4-year degrees from public or private non-profit institutions, because 2-year degrees and for-profit colleges are largely scams.
The official student loan market quantity is nothing more than how much of a subsidy the .gov wants to pay off to the .edu. That doesn't necessarily imply much about the total cost of education other than its probably at least that much although it could be much more.
Depends on the particular kind of student loan.
"In 2009 65.6% of first-time bachelor's degree recipients took out student loans, compared with 49.3% in 1994. Of those who borrowed, the cumulative amount borrowed was $24,700 in 2009, as compared with $14,700 (2009 dollars) in 1994. [...]
Among first-time bachelor's degree recipients with loans and who were employed and repaying their loans 1 year after bachelor's degree receipt, the average monthly loan repayments were 13.1% of monthly salary in 2009, as compared with 11.1% in 1994. The median monthly loan repayments were 8.0% in 2009, as compared with 6.8% in 1994.
In 2009 51.7% had monthly loan repayments that were 1-8% of their monthly salary, 17.1% had monthly loan repayments that were 9-12% of their monthly salary, 11.7% had monthly loan repayments that were 13-17% of their monthly salary, and 19.4% had monthly loan repayments that were more than 17% of their monthly salary." Source: Tables 1, 6, 7: http://nces.ed.gov/pubs2013/2013156.pdf
So basically the macroeconomic view wildly exaggerates the situation; while it is a problem that students with bachelors degrees are getting shitty jobs, the idea that it's impossible for students to get an education without outrageous monthly loan payments is just wrong. The people getting fucked over by college debt are mainly the ones who enroll in scam for-profit colleges, rack up hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of debt, and then don't graduate. Getting an actual bachelors degree is only nominally to moderately more expensive than it was 40 years ago. The fact that college graduates aren't well-educated enough to get good jobs is an enormous problem, but the idea that college is suddenly unaffordable because of cost increases is complete BS. Consider also:
"The net TFRB (tuition/room/fees/board sticker price minus total grant aid and tax benefits) at public 4-year colleges for in-state residents increased from $7,400 in 1990-91 (2012 dollars) to $12,110 in 2012-13. At private non-profit institution the net price increased from $18,330 in 1990-91 to $23,840 in 2012-13." Source: CollegeBoard - Tuition and Fee and Room and Board Charges over Time in 2012 Dollars, 1972-73 through 2012-13, Selected Years, Table 7 - Average Net Price for Full-Time Students over Time - Public Institutions, Table 8 - Average Net Price for Full-Time Students over Time - Private Institutions
"The average net tuition (tuition and fees minus all grants) in 2007-08 was $4,900 at public doctorate-granting institutions, $16,400 at private non-profit doctorate-granting institutions, and $9,200 at for-profit institutions." Source: http://nces.ed.gov/datalab/tableslibrary/viewtable.aspx?tabl... http://nces.ed.gov/datalab/tableslibrary/viewtable.aspx?tabl...