Re:Bitcoin and positive vs. normative economics
by olalonde on Sunday December 29, 2013 @12:18AM
(#6978513)
I could name at least one Nobel winning economist who has completely opposite views from Krugman. Economics is far from a hard science unfortunately.
Re:Bitcoin and positive vs. normative economics
by jhonovich on Sunday December 29, 2013 @01:48AM
(#6978700)
The point is about dismissing a Nobel winning economist with a two paragraph comment on HN concluding "how little anyone really understands money or economics". If you are going to play judge of economic expertise, a little more analysis is in order.
Re:Bitcoin and positive vs. normative economics
by fat0wl on Sunday December 29, 2013 @12:08AM
(#6978491)
lol this this thisssss! bitcoin culture in a nutshell. the major economists & finance analysts say stuff like "explain how this is not a speculative bubble", for example, because they outright see it as one & the bitcoiners dismiss them as hacks because they didn't use a bunch of crypto buzzwords
Re:Bitcoin and positive vs. normative economics
by jadeddrag on Sunday December 29, 2013 @01:56AM
(#6978718)
Which is more likely, that economists don't understand cryptography, or cryptologists don't understand economics?
Re:Bitcoin and positive vs. normative economics
by dragonwriter on Sunday December 29, 2013 @02:27AM
(#6978771)
More likely than either being particularly more likely than the other is that neither economists nor cryptographers are particularly likely to understand the other field.
Re:Bitcoin and positive vs. normative economics
by fat0wl on Monday December 30, 2013 @01:03AM
(#6983288)
yea but my view here is that you don't need to understand cryptography to derive the value of a Bitcoin. It is akin to other currency systems that have come before it. the crypto aspects are new, sure, & provide a good infrastructure that may give it staying power but the cryptography shouldn't actually be where the value comes from.
I think a sound economic analysis of the market can be done regardless of the transactional method. sure, it's clever but its a feature of a value store, not actual value
That is an incredibly arrogant statement, considering the article is from a Nobel prize winning economist and you did nothing to refute or undermine his actual points or references.