That is, if people are successfully using a crypto asset for their business, AND they are able to use a power and network infrastructure for this that is difficult enough(not perfect) that government authorities aren't successfully applying their "monopoly on force," then government is now pushed into competition with the crypto-anarchic principles and must find a way to become a "better product," enough so that people will prefer government money over crypto.
How will government come up with a product that is better - in a positive way - than a crypto asset? Government has the authority to issue new centralized currencies. This means that if it truly embraced computing - which it never has to date, having never faced a challenge of that nature - it could program a form of currency that is "smart" and bakes in the policy decisions and taxation currently executed by bureaucracy. It would be made attractive to citizens by building in basic income, as well as the service provisions. The result would be more powerful and more efficient than anything we currently know as government. Cash would still exist as a backup, but the government could discourage its use except in emergency situations.
I hate the "terrorism" BS as much as you, but money laundering and large-scale scamming ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6972139 ) are actual threats.
Yes, banks launder drug money for cartels. Without the state, who would slap their wrists?
Meanwhile, people's lives are ruined for selling or even possessing small amounts of harmless drugs.
http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-07-02/hsbc-judge-approves...
but yeah...bitcoin is bad! cuz...bad people!
Bitcoin makes a lot of this even more complex, and as more people start using/trusting it for larger transactions, it'll be quite difficult to know who actually owns what. I might not even need half my loopholes anymore.
1. just like this guy: http://blogs.wsj.com/wealth/2008/05/19/the-homeless-billiona...
Just how you do the actual enforcement, that's a different issue, especially if corruption is entrenched already.
The funds from your undeclared income could be going to other people' undeclared incomes.
My friend, you fall under this critique. While the middle-class can make transactions if it chooses using Bitcoin, it has to deal with its huge volatility - a 'store of value' problem. You cannot have just a 'medium of exchange', like the song "You can't have one, without the other".
So what we have is governemnt creating an illusion of unmanaged store of value through financial engineering. It's is somewhat artificial, so I suspect it's not stable either. Consider that financial bubbles are caused by excess of capital relative to production needs, and the glut of capital was accumulated strictly due to people trying to preserve value of their savings. There is a mismatch between amount of value people are trying to preserve and cumulative size of viable investment opportunities.
Anyway, I think the root of the problem with those mainstream journalists is that they do not distinguish between Bitcoin as an unit of account (like, I have 0.5 BTC, or this item cost 0.1 BTC), and a Bitcoin as a technology (peer-to-peer trustless network with all the wonderful attributes it has). Their mind mangles those two things into one, and they then see Bitcoins as only some virtual numbers, which are moving from one wallet to another. Starting from this perspective, they can't conclude anything useful, and can't see the intrinsic value of Bitcoin the technology.
Monitoring for taxes comes second.
All federal tax information for employees is self-reported by employers. There isn't a huge monitoring infrastructure in place—just required-by-law reporting of what people get paid. Getting paid with not-dollars doesn't change the system.
We don't have any system in place to show military spending breakdowns or get people upset about it or give people who are upset about it a way to influence changes shrinking it in the future.
So basically it brings an ability to the middle-class that normally only the top 1% have. We know wealthy people use tax loopholes(and a few of them, laundering) and... why do the states need to monitor financial transactions? Don't tell me because terrorism. I'm sick of that being the reason for everything when we have this kind of nonsense[1] happening.
I translate this to: "Bitcoin is designed to free non-rich people from the restrictions, fees & surveillance placed upon them by the wealthy elite"
I don't know if crypo-currency will succeed long-term, but seeing how hardcore scared/doubtful some people are about it makes me think a nerve has been hit. I just hope that if btc fails, it fails naturally/organically/mathematically on its own... not because someone arbitrarily makes it illegal.
1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6954341