Re:Professor admits faking AIDS vaccine to get $19M in grants
by JackFr on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:24AM
(#6969612)
IANAL, but my understanding is that wire fraud is specifically used to give federal prosecutors standing in a case they might not otherwise have jurisdiction to prosecute. That is is a fraud took place entirely within one state, it would be a state affair, and there would be no federal crime -- unless they used either the mail or a national telecommunications network to facilitate the fraud.
However, in this case since the target was a federal agency, presumably it is a federal crime already. More interesting I would think is that even if the US attorney doesn't want to press charges, I'm sure the AG of Iowa (and possibly Maryland) could.
Re:Professor admits faking AIDS vaccine to get $19M in grants
by CharlieA on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:03AM
(#6969571)
I agree with your premise that the spirit of a law shouldn't be violated to send a message but I don't see that it applies here.
For me this doesn't pass the sense test: should a person be able to knowingly, intentionally fake the results of a scientific experiment in order to secure a grant of taxpayer money? No. No more than you should be able to fake the 'results' of your yearly income, say, for the purpose of receiving welfare.
Going down the route of "find crimes to charge him with" is a bad idea for many reasons, one being: if it becomes commonplace to bend the spirit of laws just to send a message, then that will make the already-too-powerful courts even moreso.