News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by icegreentea on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:01PM (#6968737)
Ugh, had to go scurrying around to find this info (really wish they linked it directly), but here's the actual proposal (and its press release):

1) In the next three years, every high school will offer a foundational “Exploring Computer Science” course. (This is a survey course - my note)

2) In the next five years, at least half of all high schools will also offer an AP Computer Science course. (My note: AP CS is a Java based course that looks roughly comparable to first year computer engineering courses, including algorithms and data structure... I've never taken AP CS, but I bet lots of people here have, and they can probably elaborate on its usefulness)

3) Chicago will also be the first US urban district to offer a K-8 computer science pathway, reaching one in four elementary schools in the next five years.

4) Within five years, CPS will allow computer science to count as a graduation requirement (e.g. possibly as a math, science, or foreign language credit). Only thirteen other states have elevated computer science to a core subject instead of an elective.

http://www.cityofchicago.org/city/en/depts/mayor/press_room/...

And for reference, here is CPS' current requirements for highscool graduation: http://www.cps.edu/SiteCollectionDocuments/PromotionPolicy/H...

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by sillysaurus2 on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:11PM (#6968761)
Anyone who's cheering this proposal should remember how well making mathematics compulsory has worked out for us. How many kids are (justifiably) disgusted with advanced mathematics because it's forced on them?

It's also important to remember highschool teachers aren't college professors. You may have had awesome and passionate HS teachers, but from what I saw, there don't seem to be very many.

I think the quickest way to destroy a future programmer is by forcing them to learn dumb ideas from half-interested teachers during their formative years, and it seems like this proposal will lead to that. It's hard to understand why people trust the modern highschool system to teach kids anything. Most of the kids aren't there to learn; they're there because they're forced to be. If an ambitious highschooler wants to learn programming, why not give them a way to learn it in a university early?

I really hope I'm wrong, but in my experience the highschool system is a grim situation for nerds, especially in the Midwest.

EDIT: Regarding highschool teachers vs CS professors: I meant that teaching programming requires programming ability, not just teaching ability. Maybe highschool teachers will become good programmers first. I don't know. And certainly, awful college professors exist just like awful highschool teachers exist. It just seems like the average CS professor has a higher chance of imparting useful knowledge to kids than a highschool teacher who has to learn it from the same book as the kids they're teaching it to. Worse, the kids have a high chance of becoming disgusted with the idea of programming if it's taught poorly, so this proposal seems at least as potentially dangerous as it is potentially helpful.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by StefanKarpinski on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:33PM (#6968816)
There does seem to be a lot of negativity about "math", but at the same time people do generally know how to do basic arithmetic, problem solving, and even some algebra – none of which comes naturally to humans. You could argue that in average schools, kids "learn dumb ideas from half-interested teachers" in all subjects. The question therefore, is whether computer programming/science will suffer the same fate as math and become cool to hate, or be more like english, history, or foreign languages, which while not universally beloved, are at least not typically reviled. Honestly, I think that learning programming is probably a lot more fun than any of the traditional subjects. The interactivity and immediate feedback could actually make it by far the least distasteful subject for many school kids. If anything, programming could indirectly get more kids interested in math.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by 001sky on Thursday December 26, 2013 @09:23PM (#6969115)
At some level 'math' becomes an academic word, and what students need is more rigourous fundamental numeracy. I hate the phrase 'quantitative' reasoning, but many people outside of maths departments actually use math in fundamental, yet rigorous ways. Part of the issue seems the deference to authority in the schooling system, which is paralleled in other ways...deference to 'expertise'...or 'abstraction' when what should be the heart of the matter is actually rigor and fundamental soundness. The latter is at conflict with other pet ideas, though. Like everybody wins and the overpromotion of self esteem. The cool to hate ("fancy math") thing is just a channeled form of anti-authoritarianism. Whereas fundamental soundness is actually providing the tools for power and freedom for the individual. When schools (but rarely) teach proper maths notation...I wonder...how/are they going to swallow cs?
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by superuser2 on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:11AM (#6969588)
Students are taught that "math" is doing arithmetic by hand, simplifying and factoring expressions, memorization, plugging-and-chugging formulas, and in general performing rote computations with pencil and paper. These things are simply not pleasant for a lot of people. Nothing anti-authoritarian about it, they're just unpleasant and repetitive tasks that any good hacker would be aching to automate.

I had great science teachers who taught me about fundamental soundness, reasoning from first principles, developing/testing/revising quantative models, and describing the state and behavior of the universe (i.e. what calculus was created for in the first place). That was fun. But nobody was doing that thinking "so this is math" because it wasn't called that, it was called physics or chemistry.

When you are in an a middle or high school classroom called "Math" with a book called "Math" you are doing rote algebraic manipulation, full stop. So that is what math is to you. No wonder people hate it.

Fundamental soundness, proof, etc. has very little to do with numeracy in the sense of mental arithmetic, estimation skills. Those are useful too, but different things. I still can't multiply two-digit numbers in my head but that never posed a problem in calculus, computer science, chemistry, physics, or anything else.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by userbinator on Friday December 27, 2013 @02:50AM (#6969823)
> I still can't multiply two-digit numbers in my head but that never posed a problem in calculus, computer science, chemistry, physics, or anything else. How about daily life? Would you rather pull out a calculator?

In my experience, (fast) mental arithmetic is very very useful for all sorts of things. Shopping, driving, eating, anything.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by superuser2 on Friday December 27, 2013 @03:01AM (#6969857)
Useful, yes. Fundamental to soundness, proof, etc? Not at all.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by hatu on Friday December 27, 2013 @04:32AM (#6970047)
Sure kids will hate all kinds of subjects. I always hated math in school until I started using it in programming. I think getting kids from poor families on a computer with the compiler set up can get the ones who had a knack for it but never had the opportunity to maybe start pursuing a career in it. People who later became programmers/engineers soaked up any kind of programming/CS class like sponges and went way beyond the scope once they got excited.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by dragonwriter on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:21PM (#6968786)
> It's also important to remember highschool teachers aren't college professors. You may have had awesome and passionate HS teachers, but from what I saw, there don't seem to be very many.

I had some -- none in my programming classes, though -- but that wasn't all too different than my college experience. If anything, the high school teachers seemed, on average, better teachers, though perhaps in a worse teaching environment.

The college professors obviously had more formal education in their subject area.

> I think the quickest way to destroy a future programmer is by forcing them to learn dumb ideas from half-interested teachers during their formative years.

I think the quickest way to destroy a potential future programmer is to have them learn nothing relevant from anyone during their formative years.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by timjahn on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:21PM (#6968789)
"It's also important to remember highschool teachers aren't college professors. You may have had awesome and passionate HS teachers, but from what I saw, there don't seem to be very many."

So, because you had some lousy high school teachers, that means college professors are passionate and high school teachers aren't? Why are high school teachers inferior to college professors?

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mathattack on Thursday December 26, 2013 @08:51PM (#6969015)
The challenge is how they'll be able to teach folks computer science, when they fail to teach them basic reading and math.

The AP Computer Science class I took was close enough to first year coursework that they let me pass out of it. The biggest benefit was having a very serious teacher whose goal in life was that class. (He taught others, but his main focus as a teacher was the top 2-3% of programmers in the student body) It was a course that's both rigorous and useful.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by jseliger on Thursday December 26, 2013 @11:11PM (#6969363)
The challenge is how they'll be able to teach folks computer science, when they fail to teach them basic reading and math.

The other problem may be salary. Years ago I was looking at teacher salaries for Seattle public schools. Salaries were identical for all subjects and increased only with length of time as a teacher and advanced degrees. They started around $30K with a BA and $36K with an MA. Pay topped out after 30 years at $60 or $70K-ish.

You're just not going to get many competent CS people for that kind of pay. Yeah, a couple of hero teachers will show up, but for the most part you're going to get shortages.

Based on the reading I assembled here: http://jseliger.wordpress.com/2009/11/12/susan-engel-doesnt-... , I'm skeptical that we're going to see much improvement in public schools, and especially urban public schools, until we deal with the teacher union issue. Unions enforce lockstep payscales.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by krakensden on Friday December 27, 2013 @03:04AM (#6969862)
My SO is a teacher. We have a similar amount of experience, my partner has more degrees. I make exactly twice as much money.

It's not like I'm working harder or what I'm doing is more important. You just can't convince Americans to spend money on public schools.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by yummyfajitas on Friday December 27, 2013 @04:08AM (#6970005)
The marginal product of your work is higher. The amount of money you make is proportional to how much value would not be produced if you were to quit. To copy an older explanation I wrote:

Consider a very important profession, say superhero. Having one superhero to stop the Joker is worth $1M. Having two superheros is worth $1.1M - Batman is sufficient to stop the very dangerous Joker, but two superheros can stop both the Joker and the far less dangerous Harleyquinn. The marginal productivity of an extra superhero is $100k even if the mean productivity is $550k. As a result, superheros get paid $100k because if any superhero quits, society loses only $100k rather than $550k.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6846579

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by krakensden on Sunday December 29, 2013 @07:52PM (#6982425)
Public school teacher compensation is totally unrelated to their productivity. Measurement is haphazard and terrible, outcomes are universally ignored, and generally pay depends on the the tax assessment of the surrounding real estate.

There are professions where that's a good model, but it seems remarkably unrelated to the dynamics of the teaching market.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mathattack on Friday December 27, 2013 @02:27PM (#6972169)
I was going to tear your response apart, but I think your logic is actually very correct. This is especially true if the employer is a monopoly.

But let's say there are multiple employers competing for the superheroes, each with their own bad guys to hunt down... Then you can get paid more.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by yummyfajitas on Friday December 27, 2013 @02:46PM (#6972259)
This has nothing to do with a monopsony. In a perfectly competitive market, wage == marginal product.

A monopsonistic situation can drive wages below the marginal product. A monopolistic situation (e.g., multiple school districts, 1 union) can drive it above the marginal product. What I described is simply the ideal situation.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mathattack on Friday December 27, 2013 @08:57PM (#6973520)
Yes - but the reality in most large cities (where the problems are) is 1 union and 1 employer. Once you get to the suburbs, there is a lot more mobility amongst the teachers. If they don't like a school system, another is 5 miles away.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by krakensden on Saturday December 28, 2013 @08:36PM (#6977720)
It highly depends on the metro area.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by rayiner on Friday December 27, 2013 @09:01AM (#6970609)
> You just can't convince Americans to spend money on public schools.

Americans spend more on public schools than pretty much anyone else, by almost any measure you choose: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2013/06/25/oecd-education-repo....

Chicago spends about the same per student as the wealthy suburb where I grew up. Teachers' salaries are also higher in Chicago than where I grew up, despite having comparable if not lower cost of living.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mathattack on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:01AM (#6970796)
It's not just money, it's accountability, it's income of the students, it's how progress is measured... Tossing money at a broken school is about as productive as tossing money at an overdue software project. Conceivably it could help, but the data suggests that you should fix the root cause of the problem first.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by rayiner on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:23AM (#6970908)
I'll go one further than that: we blame schools for not fixing what are fundamentally deep-seated social, rather than educational, problems. Tossing more money at schools, broken or functional, isn't productive.

Half of all children in Chicago live in single-parent homes, and the poverty rate for families headed by a single mother are around 40%: http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2013-11-03/news/ct-edit-x.... That percentage is almost certainly much higher within the Chicago public school system, which skews poorer than the city as a whole.

You can't have functional schools with students who have to worry more about gang violence in their neighborhood than their grades. More money, better curricula, better teachers, none of that matters when the social structure outside the school is crumbling.

I imagine much of the dysfunction endemic to urban school systems is related to the Sisyphean nature of the task we give them. We focus almost single-mindedly on schools and education to solve all the ills of urban society. If only our schools were functional and our teachers competent, we say, these kids would be able to rise out of their condition and better themselves. But teachers who teach in these systems realize the absurdity of that charge. Stuck between a student population that needs help in ways that are not within their power to give, and a society that fails to realize the actual needs of these young people, teachers shift to a mode focused on self-preservation. Hence the dysfunction present in urban school systems.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mathattack on Friday December 27, 2013 @02:32PM (#6972187)
Here's the strange thing though... Some charter schools do educate the same poor populations, and do it well. The Success Academy [1] is very controversial, but their kids in Harlem and the Bronx do get good test scores. [2] One can argue that they weed out bad apples, but the numbers are still phenomenal even if you assume they've pushed out the bottom 10%.

Of course the new mayor of New York wants to stop their growth, but that's another complaint.

[1] http://www.successacademies.org/

[2] http://projects.nytimes.com/new-york-schools-test-scores/cou...

and

http://perdidostreetschool.blogspot.com/2013/08/bronx-succes...

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by gensym on Friday December 27, 2013 @09:21PM (#6973568)
Not so strange once you find out the some charter schools can effectively choose their populations via disciplinary measures. http://www.nydailynews.com/new-york/education/success-academ...
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by rayiner on Friday December 27, 2013 @08:39PM (#6973483)
I'd imagine the students at charter schools have families trying very hard to overcome the ambient culture.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mathattack on Friday December 27, 2013 @08:58PM (#6973523)
Yes, that too. But what's wrong with giving all those families opportunities in schools that allow it, rather than forcing them into cesspools that people are afraid to close for political reasons?
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by dragonwriter on Friday December 27, 2013 @12:24PM (#6971549)
> Chicago spends about the same per student as the wealthy suburb where I grew up. Teachers' salaries are also higher in Chicago than where I grew up, despite having comparable if not lower cost of living.

Teacher salaries are often higher in urban districts than suburban ones (and often still result in teacher shortages) because the conditions in urban districts are often less attractive to qualified teachers. (Policies which equalize per student spending across states means this also results in lower non-teacher-salary spending in those districts, which results in worse working conditions and more pressure for teachers to reach into their own pockets to meet classroom needs, which makes teaching in those districts even less attractive.)

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by rayiner on Friday December 27, 2013 @04:39PM (#6972747)
But Chicago isn't facing teacher shortages. They have an oversupply give the drop in enrollment over the last decade.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by krakensden on Friday December 27, 2013 @12:21PM (#6971530)
California isn't Chicago. There were cuts in the majority of years since 2000, and we never spent that much to begin with.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by rayiner on Friday December 27, 2013 @08:53PM (#6973513)
SFUD starts at $46k plus $4k pension contribution plus $6k-8k health insurance contribution. Plus Extensivr time off. That's not top of the market nationwide, but its very good for non-STEM people. Arguing otherwise is totally oblivious to the job situation currently faced by non-Stanford, non-UC liberal arts and humanities majors in this economy. Remember, nationwide the full time employment rate for recent grads is below 50%. Even a $40k per year job with no benefits is great outside of STEM.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by krakensden on Saturday December 28, 2013 @08:38PM (#6977730)
I know it. Most of my humanities and psychology-major friends are working retail or driving trucks. The higher achieving girls are teachers.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mathattack on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:04AM (#6970816)
I suspect your salary will triple theirs within 5 years.

My sense is there are a few reasons for this:

1) It is very hard to measure the benefits of good teaching, and it tends to be on a much longer timeframe. (Do we value nice teachers, or the ones that force us to learn? And is there a good test for it? I still get lessons from my great high school teachers, but it took a long time to appreciate some of them.)

2) There is little competition for skills of high school teachers. In large cities, there is one employer, take it or leave it. Teachers get one salary - based on how long they've been there. By the time they're most beaten down and least effective, they're paid the most. Meanwhile, the academic literature suggests that after 5 years, there is little correlation between time in classroom and improved skills.

What can be done? Improve the imperfect measurements, and open up the system for competition. Make it easier for schools to compete for better teachers by paying them more. (In the end, parents know which teachers are better) Make it easier for parents to leave bad schools. Make it easier to close schools whose parents leave.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by auctiontheory on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:56PM (#6972031)
You just can't convince Americans to spend money on public schools.

Public schools get plenty of money. It just doesn't go to the classroom teachers.

As a psychologist friend pointed out to me yesterday, jobs that are traditionally held by women tend to be underpaid compared to "equivalent" jobs that are traditionally male. Compare teacher salaries to police and fireman salaries in the same district.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by krakensden on Saturday December 28, 2013 @08:35PM (#6977712)
Most of the higher-paid administrators, etc., are women though.

That said, most of the (invariably obscenely overcompensated) superintendents I've heard of have been male.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mathattack on Friday December 27, 2013 @09:59AM (#6970785)
Seliger is a great writer.

Unions perversely hurt themselves. By creating a monopoly for their services, they make it much harder for alternative providers to come along and bid up their services.

The new NYC mayor put the partner of the AFT (American Federation of Teachers) on his transition team. Part of his campaign platform was, "Less measuring, no more charter schools, no more closing failing schools." I fear for the future of NYC schools.

But to the original point, I think the only hope is getting post-career engineers who have already made their money to become CS teachers.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by king_jester on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:16AM (#6970865)
> Part of his campaign platform was, "Less measuring, no more charter schools, no more closing failing schools." I fear for the future of NYC schools.

All of those things are positives for NYC, not negatives. Closing failing schools has equated to closing schools in communities comprised of black and hispanic people and replacing them with charter school options that have less accountability. Charter schools themselves have not been shown to be a suitable large scale replacement for the public school system and have their own issues. As for measuring, the strictness of standardized tests and how they tie into student and teacher performance/evaluation has already been shown to be having an negative effect on classrooms.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by drivingmissm on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:45AM (#6971008)
Charter schools are, in fact, public schools. They just aren't administered by the centralized government system.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mathattack on Friday December 27, 2013 @02:34PM (#6972193)
Yes. And more accountable. The waiting lists are huge for charter schools. Why not give the parents more options for their kids? As a parent, I would prefer results like these, to the results of failing schools.

http://projects.nytimes.com/new-york-schools-test-scores/cou...

and

http://perdidostreetschool.blogspot.com/2013/08/bronx-succes...

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by king_jester on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:37PM (#6971928)
Partially or wholly publicly funded, yes. Publicly operated or administered, no. The part about operation and administration is the key point about parents and communities being able to have input into their children's schooling. Charter schools don't address the existing problems with public education in regards to many communities being able to have a voice in achieving quality education.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by dragonwriter on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:42PM (#6971951)
> Partially or wholly publicly funded, yes. Publicly operated or administered, no.

In many cases, charter schools are both publicly funded and administer. The charter is a governing document providing exceptions and alternatives to the governing rules otherwise applicable to public schools.

Charter schools may be privately operated/administered, but that's not universally the case.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mathattack on Friday December 27, 2013 @02:36PM (#6972202)
Charter schools don't address the existing problems with public education in regards to many communities being able to have a voice in achieving quality education.

Yes they do. You always have a choice of charter school or non-charter school. Many charters are so popular that they have 10 applicants for every spot. This isn't the sign of a lack of a voice, it's a sign of people voicing their displeasure with their terrible zoned schools.

We allow airlines to compete for our business, and the bad ones should close. We allow grocery stores to compete for our business, and the bad ones should close. Why not allow schools to compete for business and let them close?

Charters have more accountability than district public schools. If a charter misses it's #s, it won't get renewed. Every 5 years they have to prove themselves.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by pjmorris on Friday December 27, 2013 @03:24AM (#6969911)
If the lockstep payscale were double or triple the present rate you wouldn't need to fix the union.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by rayiner on Friday December 27, 2013 @09:05AM (#6970623)
Teachers generally make more than the average college graduate despite having below-average qualifications. It makes absolutely no sense to pay existing teachers more money. If the rationale behind paying teachers more is to get a higher caliber of person, then the only thing that makes sense is to make the higher pay-rates applicable only to new teachers hired under more stringent criteria.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by king_jester on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:18AM (#6970875)
This seems backwards. More experience on the job means you are no longer qualified for more pay, but new hires that have no experience in classrooms do qualify for higher pay?
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by rayiner on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:32AM (#6970949)
What's the rationale for paying teachers more money? The usual one that is trotted out is that existing levels of teacher pay are insufficient to attract the caliber of teachers we want in our schools. In other words, experienced or not, our existing teachers just aren't very good: http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/answer-sheet/post/do-tea....

Under that rationale it makes no sense to pay existing teachers more money. Paying the same people more money isn't going to make them more qualified, more competent, or smarter. Higher salaries are just a tool we can use to recruit people with those qualities.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by king_jester on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:47AM (#6971021)
Well, the notion that all existing teachers are no good is not true, so that rationale doesn't really hold up. College graduation stats for teachers doesn't tell the whole story of how teachers perform in their jobs and school districts. It is true that higher pay would attract more people to teaching, but there are a lot of factors that go into why teachers aren't paid more in the first place.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by rayiner on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:53AM (#6971061)
> Well, the notion that all existing teachers are no good is not true, so that rationale doesn't really hold up.

There's two basic facts:

1) Teachers, in the U.S., are generally drawn from the bottom half of college graduates.

2) Generally, teachers get paid about as much as the average non-STEM college graduate.

If the existing teachers we have are as "good as we need" then there is no reason to pay teachers more. There's no shortage of teachers at existing pay levels and teacher pay is consistent with the market pay for other college graduates of similar qualifications.

Thus, those who lobby for higher teacher pay argue that it will attract more qualified people to teaching. They point to countries like Finland, where it is common for teachers to have been in the top 10% of their college classes. They note that STEM majors, who make more than non-STEM majors, take a major pay cut to go into teaching. But under that rationale, it makes no sense to pay more to existing teachers, who don't have those qualifications.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by dragonwriter on Friday December 27, 2013 @11:01AM (#6971101)
> Teachers, in the U.S., are generally drawn from the bottom half of college graduates.

[citation needed]

> There's no shortage of teachers at existing pay levels.

The fact that a number of districts are forced to waive generally-applicable requirements (e.g., issue "emergency credentials", etc.) to get teachers and/or rely on series of long-term substitutes to assure that there is actually a teacher in the classroom suggests that this is not true

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by rayiner on Friday December 27, 2013 @12:05PM (#6971445)
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by dragonwriter on Friday December 27, 2013 @12:20PM (#6971529)
So its a weakened modification (from "bottom third" to "bottom half") to a claim that, even in the weaker form, has only fairly weak justification depending on the particular time-based slice of the teacher workforce you look at, and relies on ranking college graduates not by any kind of college performance, but by college entrance exams?
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by rayiner on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:07PM (#6971757)
Specifically:

> The appendix to the report confirms that the “top-“ and “bottom” third figures are also based on SAT/ACT scores, specifically those of 1999 graduates whose first job (at least by 2001) was teaching. The breakdown for these graduates is as follows: 23 percent came from the “top third;” 47 percent from the “bottom third;” and 29 percent from the “middle third.”

Comparing performance on entrance exams is more consistent with how private sector employers evaluate non-STEM college graduates. Those 47% of teachers scoring in the bottom third of the SAT/ACT aren't going to be in the running for very high-paying jobs almost regardless of their college performance.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by king_jester on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:35PM (#6971916)
> Comparing performance on entrance exams is more consistent with how private sector employers evaluate non-STEM college graduates.

How exactly is that? I've not heard of an employer asking for SAT/ACT scores for college grads. I've heard of reporting GPA and talking about internship/club roles, but never standardized test scores taken before college.

> Those 47% of teachers scoring in the bottom third of the SAT/ACT aren't going to be in the running for very high-paying jobs almost regardless of their college performance.

Seriously? You could score in the middle or poorly on a standardized test and go on to do extremely well in college and the workforce. Further, scoring high on SAT/ACT tests doesn't indicate you will do well in college or the workforce. Employers are almost always looking for a couple of factors for potential hires, not just one, and we would expect teacher hires to be no different in that regard.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by rayiner on Friday December 27, 2013 @03:20PM (#6972432)
I'm necessarily talking about aggregates here. Bottom 1/3 on the SAT is around 900/1600 on the SAT scale used between 1995 and 2005. Generally people who score in that range go to a college that does not offer a great prospect of making more than your average college graduate, even with a very good (but not extraordinary) performance in college.

Starting salary for a teacher in Chicago with just a BA is almost $50k/year with very good benefits. There are jobs for non-STEM majors that pay that or substantially higher, but the college options available with that kind of SAT score put you at a great handicap for those jobs.

Again, we're talking about aggregates here, not individuals. Lots of people do poorly on the SAT and end up wealthy. But if we're talking about a group where 47% perform in the bottom 1/3 of the SAT, I don't think it's unreasonable to say that this group's expected salary outside of teaching is substantially lower than for the average college graduate, regardless of the fact that individuals may outperform their entrance exams.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by king_jester on Friday December 27, 2013 @03:48PM (#6972553)
> I'm necessarily talking about aggregates here. Bottom 1/3 on the SAT is around 900/1600 on the SAT scale used between 1995 and 2005. Generally people who score in that range go to a college that does not offer a great prospect of making more than your average college graduate, even with a very good (but not extraordinary) performance in college.

Its true that earning such a score may be more limiting in what colleges you can attend, but the reality is that ivy league and highly competitive schools are not within the range of most people for a variety of reasons. However, those graduates are skilled and make excellent employees and we as a society depend on a college system that is accessible to have a better skilled workforce. In terms of how this relates to quality of teachers, that some scored low on SAT/ACT and went to different kinds of colleges doesn't mean they are not qualified or successful as teachers.

> Starting salary for a teacher in Chicago with just a BA is almost $50k/year with very good benefits. There are jobs for non-STEM majors that pay that or substantially higher, but the college options available with that kind of SAT score put you at a great handicap for those jobs.

Of course, its not just the college you attend that opens up those higher paying non-STEM jobs to you, it also highly depends on what field you went into, current economic conditions when you start looking for employment, overall availability of positions, etc. Over the last 4 years we have seen that even attending a more competitive school or highly esteemed school isn't enough to get over some of the external difficulties in finding a job in some fields.

> Again, we're talking about aggregates here, not individuals. Lots of people do poorly on the SAT and end up wealthy. But if we're talking about a group where 47% perform in the bottom 1/3 of the SAT, I don't think it's unreasonable to say that this group's expected salary outside of teaching is substantially lower than for the average college graduate, regardless of the fact that individuals may outperform their entrance exams.

We aren't talking about those that become wealthy, we are talking about low SAT/ACT scorers who go on to get a college degree at an accredited institution. It is unreasonable to say that low scorers are going to earn less than high scorers that attend the same class of institution or that the low scorers are less qualified from the high scorers in the same field that attended the same class of institution.

Fundamentally, degree snobbery isn't helpful here. We require a large body of qualified teacher and an environment where those teachers can succeed. Like any profession, there are bad teachers, but calling all teachers bad because they didn't achieve an academically-defined test score that doesn't necessarily have a present bearing on their ability to be a teaching professional is silly.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by dragonwriter on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:39PM (#6971936)
> Comparing performance on entrance exams is more consistent with how private sector employers evaluate non-STEM college graduates.

"Everyone does it" doesn't mean its a meaningful measure, even if its true (and, AFAICT, its not.)

The number of potential employers that have ever cared -- or even asked -- about my college entrance exams is...0. Several have asked for college grade transcripts, though, though most have just asked about degrees and institutions.

I mean, I'd love it if the fact that my entrance exam scores were in the top 0.1% mattered...but generally they don't seem to.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by rayiner on Friday December 27, 2013 @08:56PM (#6973519)
How many people do you know that went to a school where you can get in with a bottom third SAT, in the lat five years, and what do you know about their job situation?

I graduated during the boom, and knew people who went to Georgia State and the like, which require top half SAT scores, and finding a $35k/year job outside STEM was a great result. Bottom third is pushing your luck for places like Valdosta State, and even the STEM people I knew there had trouble landing real engineering jobs. Not uncommon to see a Mech E working as an HVAC technician.

This is not snobbery. I'd never hold the school someone went to against them. But if we're projecting expected outcomes of a large group of people, it's totally relevant.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by droopyEyelids on Thursday December 26, 2013 @10:02PM (#6969229)
> The challenge is how they'll be able to teach folks computer science, when they fail to teach them basic reading and math

This is another form of the "How dare you make a social app when people starve in Africa" objection.

Just in case anyone still feels like it makes sense, be aware of the gross oversimplification it entails. Actually only some students fail to acquire basic reading and math skills, while another group isn't provided with ample opportunity to take their ability to learn to its full extent.

Giving schools the opportunity to add CS as core subject allows schools to offer good students a broader education, and provides an opportunity to capture a larger percent of otherwise disinterested students' attention.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mathattack on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:07AM (#6970826)
Fair enough. I'm not that extreme, and I get that schools need to offer students the best in education. But many of these schools in question are failing enormous quantities of students. The school my kids are zoned for (public, not in Chicago) has 85% of the kids failing state exams, with half getting the lowest score possible. They're investing millions of dollars in trips to the museums and other "magnet" activities, while they can't provide even a basic education.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by auctiontheory on Friday December 27, 2013 @01:49PM (#6971996)
I tutor math at a local high school. The core problem, at least as far as I can understand it, is the students' lack of motivation - learning math is way down their priority list. (The material is basic, and the students appear to be of normal intelligence. There's no reason they couldn't grok this stuff.)

The great thing about CS, at least if it's well taught, is that you can see results. You can think hard, figure something out, and see visible results from your effort. I think/hope that this can be a powerful motivator for a 14-year-old to think analytically - in a way that solving algebra problems isn't.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by belluchan on Thursday December 26, 2013 @09:50PM (#6969197)
> The challenge is how they'll be able to teach folks computer science, when they fail to teach them basic reading and math.

And where are the schools failing at basic reading and math? I doubt that if there are students who fail at this that they would make it into this program.

My guess is that it's not the schools that are failing children, it's the parents.

I know that doesn't ring nicely with the easy to blame "school" blame the "government" all that other libertarian thoughtless unfortunate stuff that's in people's heads, but there you go.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by wisty on Friday December 27, 2013 @07:47AM (#6970423)
Anyone with a math or physics degree in the last 20 years should be able to learn basic programming. Of course, those are the teachers who are already in short supply.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mournit on Thursday December 26, 2013 @08:19PM (#6968953)
I took AP Computer Science in High School. My teacher, who sometimes served as grader for the AP exam, would often tell us of one year in which there was a large number of abysmal tests. Many students could not answer even the most basic of questions. He and the other graders noticed that all of these students were from one particular state.

It turns out that this state had required CS as a subject, but many schools did not have faculty even remotely qualified to teach it. The schools had simply stuck a random math or science teacher in the role, and these teachers had made no effort to learn the content. My teacher told us that in the coding portion of the test, these students would often just write "my teacher did not know computer science, we just sat and browsed the internet all class."

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by StefanKarpinski on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:11PM (#6968758)
Thank you for finding all of that. I think it squashes a lot of the negativity and objections elsewhere in this discussion. That is a legitimate sounding computer science curriculum and it's incredibly refreshing that it puts the discipline on a par with traditional fields.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by warfangle on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:21PM (#6968788)
My High School AP CS class was C++, with a very heavy focus on data structures, up to and including balanced binary search trees (we had covered linked lists, doubly linked lists and other more basic data structures, including pointer math, in CS 3/4). Second semester was a self-directed team project. This was in 2001-2002.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by tsm on Thursday December 26, 2013 @11:51PM (#6969438)
Oh wow. Mine (2010) was in Java, and featured elementary OOP (class/object distinction, inheritance, abstract classes vs. interfaces, polymorphism) and array/ArrayList usage. And reading—but not writing—recursive functions. Implementations of data structures and the mere existence of non-list data structures weren't even hinted at. (And this wasn't just a problem with my school—I aced the class got an easy 5 with the above knowledge.)

I'd consider data structures much more foundational than Java-flavored OOP. It worries me that the curriculum has swung in this direction.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by just2n on Friday December 27, 2013 @03:51PM (#6972565)
It's worth noting around 2009 that the harder Computer Science exam was no [longer being given by AP][wikipedia]. The course I had was AP Computer Science aimed at the AB test back in 2004-2005. It was in Java but every bit as rigorous as the one described by the grandparent's in C++.

Supposedly it was discontinued due to a lack of people taking it, but that was partly due to the fact that it's not a core subject and I assume because it was quite a bit more difficult than the others. I recall taking the Calculus AP BC exam as well and trivially scoring a 5 on it, while the Computer Science AB exam was actually fairly difficult, even though I spent a significant amount of time learning algorithms and data structures, implementing all of them myself, and reading lots of code. One point of anecdata, but in my experience someone who did score a 5 on that exam was likely very well ahead of the curve going into a university. I was able to skip I believe 3 courses at my university based on earning a 5, and I doubt the same is true of the present A exam.

[wikipedia]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AP_Computer_Science#AP_Compute...

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by warfangle on Friday December 27, 2013 @02:16AM (#6969745)
Yeah. We covered operator overloading, OOP (minus polymorphism) in CS 3/4 -- along with learning C++! CS 1/2 was all in Pascal.

I should also note that this was a public (magnet) school in the RTP area. CS 1/2 and 3/4 all had ~10-15 students; AP only had about 8. Almost everyone in all of these classes had been programming long before high school. These were old IBM DOS machines. 486ish I think. On a token ring network (one of the guys wrote a rudimentary chat program that worked locally on the network)

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by michael_h on Friday December 27, 2013 @11:03AM (#6971112)
You were running a token ring network in 2001? Whoa.

I had almost the same setup at a public (non-magnetic) school. No Pascal though - all C++ on NT. I'm not sure if I had the 'average experience' or not. I suspect not.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by warfangle on Friday December 27, 2013 @11:09AM (#6971149)
Yeah; we were running borland turbo c++ 3.0! how modern; wow!

It was actually pretty great: we didn't have to go through learning a new IDE (we were using turbo pascal the previous year). We didn't have to learn weird GUI stuff. We just focused on the curriculum.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by rayiner on Friday December 27, 2013 @09:09AM (#6970633)
I took it at a magnet school too (the same year), but I'm pretty sure the basic curriculum was dictated by the AP test, which tested data structures and the like heavily.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by analog31 on Thursday December 26, 2013 @08:20PM (#6968954)
>>> 3) Chicago will also be the first US urban district to offer a K-8 computer science pathway, reaching one in four elementary schools in the next five years.

In my view this is as big a deal as the high school course, if not bigger. The earlier you teach it, the less rigorous and more fun it can be.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mathattack on Thursday December 26, 2013 @08:49PM (#6969009)
Yes. Though I wonder where they'll find the people to teach it.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by wallflower on Thursday December 26, 2013 @10:22PM (#6969265)
My friends who are involved in this area (teaching kids programming), some of whom work for a number of emerging organizations for teaching kids coding, realize that they need to teach (existing) teachers how to teach coding.

Ideally, programming is not taught in isolation but integrated into the other classes. For example, as the student's abilities increase, they can start coding solutions to science homework or the like.

Many organizations are hitting the point where they find they cannot rely on the handful of talented teachers to drive their curriculum agenda forward - especially as they scale to multiple cities. To address this, they need to develop their own teacher training curriculums. Since existing math/science teachers already are state certified for their subjects (and most certification laws allow some leeway for math/science to teach CS - as they should), they are the most likely candidates to promote into adding CS into their curriculum. For a software developer to become a teacher (outside of a private school or charter school context), they will find it difficult - due to the minimum certification requirements - they may even need to go back to school and study stuff that may not have a direct bearing on teaching CS (e.g. determining if children are being physically or mentally abused at home).

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by analog31 on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:51AM (#6971049)
This is a gaping issue. I don't think the answer lies in turning teachers into the kind of programmers that I imagine many of us are on HN. Most K-8 teachers don't have the background that I had when I learned programming, or the spare time to spend hours a day hacking.

Considerable effort has been directed towards bringing programming to kids (e.g., Scratch). Perhaps we now need to make the same effort to bring programming to teachers, the majority of whom are weak in math.

A predicament for teachers is not knowing what "language" will be chosen for teaching kids. If you know nothing about programming, the sheer proliferation of options is going to be a forbidding barrier. At this stage, nobody wants to drive a stake in the ground by declaring a chosen language, but doing so would probably go further than anything else to help teachers get started.

Example: When I learned programming, that choice was driven by being wired into every affordable computer: BASIC. It wasn't the greatest language, but it gave teachers something to hang their hats on.

Editorial: If the moguls really wanted to encourage programming, they wouldn't make computers hard to program. It's an outrage that the most popular computer among teachers and kids -- the iPad -- can't be programmed.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by ucarion on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:51PM (#6968865)
I took AP Computer Science A two years ago as a sophomore.

Most of the questions have to do with understanding how scopes, assignment, loops, and conditionals work. There isn't very much about data structures -- arrays (both the native and ArrayList kind) were the only structures ever covered. Most of the focus is on OOP and using the API for an app called GridWorld, which is pretty neat.

Here's the College Board site about AP CS:

http://apcentral.collegeboard.com/apc/public/courses/teacher...

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by mjmahone17 on Friday December 27, 2013 @04:35AM (#6970051)
This curriculum seems a bit absurd. One of the sample questions from: http://apcentral.collegeboard.com/apc/public/repository/ap-c...

requires students to understand the difference between Integer and int (and therefore understand autoboxing), but they don't need to learn trees in the entire course. It seems like their use of Java limits the concepts that they can teach, which means the test ends up being primarily "Can you figure out what this program does" rather than "Use code to solve an interesting problem."

As an aside, these kinds of tests are also awful on students who are dyslexic. Especially questions such as #3, because you have to keep track of a lot of tiny variables, in the correct order, in order to make the code "run correctly". Which means, if you flip even two arguments in the lengthy list of 8 (which is more than most people can keep in their head), you'll get the wrong answer despite really understanding what's going on under the hood.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by ajayjain on Friday December 27, 2013 @12:14AM (#6969464)
I'm currently a sophomore in APCS after taking a year of the base Java class. Both focus on the language for the most part. In APCS, ~60% of the material is Java OOP, as in specifics behavior when overriding methods, static vs instance, interfaces etc. 20-25% is control structures, syntax etc, and in first semester we've covered basic sorts, built in arrays and ArrayLists. I believe in second semester we talk about elementary data structures like linked lists and _maybe_ binary trees after the AP exam (the class is structured around CollegeBoard's AP exam).

Since there is already a Java class on campus, I think the AP class should focus more on language independent CS concepts. At least half of our final and tests are problems about determining what is printed by an obfuscated Java program to test knowledge of how edge cases are handled.

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by RyanZAG on Friday December 27, 2013 @12:23AM (#6969481)
While not a complete waste of time - having some foundation in that stuff is useful in the way learning to do long division is useful - it's definitely not what they should be teaching. Can't really blame them given that many universities also go that same route with CS classes, but hopefully people can put pressure on them to fix it up.
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by dragonwriter on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:17PM (#6968781)
> I've never taken AP CS, but I bet lots of people here have, and they can probably elaborate on its usefulness

Well, when I took AP Computer Science, it was still Pascal, but it was pretty much what it says on the tin as far as being very roughly equivalent to an introductory college class (of course, the quality of introductory classes varies a lot by institution.)

Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by gambogi on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:27PM (#6968804)
The college board killed the AB test the year I took APCS (which was 2011 iirc)
Re:Chicago makes Computer Science a core subject by dragonwriter on Thursday December 26, 2013 @07:29PM (#6968807)
Removed the reference to AB (the information I can find says it was discontinued in 2009.)