News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by gnaritas on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @01:25PM (#6963731)
No one deserves to be paid simply for working. You might be the best X in the world but if the world doesn't value X then you don't get paid. Pay is earned by doing things people want to pay for, not simply by doing things. If people don't want to pay for music/lyrics then music/lyrics has no market value. You don't deserve anything.
Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by sanswork on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @01:49PM (#6963811)
Clearly there is value since there is demand. What you're saying essentially is that peoples right to pay what they want outweighs the creators right to set their own price for their creations. That's not the way the world works. Demand can dictate price to an extent in that the seller wants to maximize earnings but it doesn't dictate it absolutely.

These companies(RG, azlyrics, etc) are making money where their main product is the creative work of someone else. Damn straight that other person deserves a cut of the profits because without them there is no site.

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by gnaritas on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @01:53PM (#6963822)
> What you're saying essentially is that peoples right to pay what they want outweighs the creators right to set their own price for their creations. That's not the way the world works.

No, that's exactly how the world works for luxury items like music; demand drives, not supply. What the seller wants to charge means absolutely nothing if demand is elastic and consumers can simply stop buying. Demand sets the price, not the seller. Creators can set whatever price they like, and consumers can and will ignore them; if you want to sell something you have to set a price the market will actually bear.

> Damn straight that other person deserves a cut of the profits because without them there is no site.

No they don't; they got paid to write the song, they're done. The notion that a person deserves to be paid forever in secondary markets where people trade their creations is a perverse and absurd notion that exists only in the messed up modern world; it's wrong and it's stupid. You as an artist do not deserve to be paid every time someone makes a copy of your art; period. If I paint a copy of a Picasso, I don't owe the Picasso family anything and the same should apply to any other creation. Copies are not theft and the artist doesn't deserve anything.

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by shock-value on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @02:19PM (#6963908)
> No they don't; they got paid to write the song, they're done. The notion that a person deserves to be paid forever in secondary markets where people trade their creations is a perverse and absurd notion that exists only in the messed up modern world; it's wrong and it's stupid.

Whether or not a person deserves to get paid forever for their work is irrelevant to this discussion... The point is that someone is getting paid forever in this situation -- either the original songwriter or the owners of the lyrics site. I'll accept for the sake of argument that it shouldn't be possible for a person to monetize his or her work in perpetuity -- so then why the hell should it be allowable for an unrelated third party to do so?

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by gnaritas on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @02:33PM (#6963962)
> I'll accept for the sake of argument that it shouldn't be possible for a person to monetize his or her work in perpetuity -- so then why the hell should it be allowable for an unrelated third party to do so?

Ok, fair question. I didn't claim a person, be it first or third party, shouldn't be able to monetize anything; I said they don't deserve it, not that they can't do it. I'm disputing the sense of entitlement displayed by the use of the word deserve. No one, whether the creator nor the third party, is entitled to consumers money.

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by sanswork on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @02:00PM (#6963848)
The seller sets the price. People either don't buy it or acquire it without paying. But the buyers don't set the price. In this case the buyer is the website and they have to pay the price since they are using the product openly and publicly.

>No they don't; they got paid to write the song, they're done. The notion that a person deserves to be paid forever in secondary markets where people trade their creations is a perverse and absurd notion that exists only in the messed up modern world; it's wrong.

Who is this magically being that pays the writer to write the song exactly? It isn't a secondary market it's a primary market. The song writer has created something(A song!) and the site wants to use that song. They are dealing with the song writer or copyright holder that is a first sale.

That person deserves to be paid for what they have created which is what this is. Your job wouldn't exist without that belief and neither would mine.

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by gnaritas on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @02:03PM (#6963860)
> But the buyers don't set the price.

I never said they did, please do try and comprehend before simply repeating yourself.

> That person deserves to be paid for what they have created which is what this is.

False.

> Your job wouldn't exist without that belief and neither would mine.

This is a belief you hold, not a fact.

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by snowwrestler on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @08:45PM (#6964971)
> they got paid to write the song, they're done.

In the vast majority of cases this is wrong. Most songwriters do not get paid to write songs. They get paid only when they receive royalties on the reproduction of their song.

This is good for society because it means that the songs that everyone likes will provide the most reward--so songwriters have a strong incentive to write the best songs they can.

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by enneff on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @03:44PM (#6964179)
So it's ok to copy and resell books without compensating the author?
Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by steven2012 on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @02:59PM (#6964047)
You're wrong. Saying that music/lyrics has no market value is just as stupid as saying that just because I personally don't want to pay for a Mercedes Benz means it has no value, and I can take one freely.

Clearly SOME people are willing to pay for the right to use lyrics, ie. singers, record labels, etc. Just because a single individual, ex. rapgenius, doesn't want to pay for the music/lyrics, which they legally are obliged to do, doesn't mean that music/lyrics have no market value. There is a market value which has been established, and which people pay for. It just means that if they don't pay for the lyrics, they are stealing it.

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by gnaritas on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @07:05PM (#6964767)
> You're wrong. Saying that music/lyrics has no market value

Well since I didn't say that, you're wrong.

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by mscarborough on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @05:30PM (#6964518)
Are you for real? The world values the lyrics/songs, and are searching for them. There is a system in place to compensate artists, and "OMG DISRUPTION PIGGYBACK" is getting really tired.

Commenting on established artworks with a cute little javascript popup doesn't add anything to the original art. If I want to check lyrics, I am looking for the lyrics, not a popup that shows a picture of a ham when I hover over 'ham'. RG doesn't even have good content, just a bunch of smartass nonsense and obvious comments.

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by gnaritas on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @07:15PM (#6964788)
> The world values the lyrics/songs

Never said they didn't, try understanding what was sad before flying off the handle.

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by chaz on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @03:04PM (#6964062)
You're right -- no one deserves to get paid simply for working (i.e. creating a work). But everyone deserves the opportunity to sell that work. When someone else takes what someone does, it diminishes the value of that opportunity. Copyrights protect that opportunity.
Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by gnaritas on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @07:12PM (#6964776)
> But everyone deserves the opportunity to sell that work.

We agree.

> When someone else takes what someone does, it diminishes the value of that opportunity.

No it doesn't, those people wouldn't have paid anyway. Copying is not theft. This is the same tired argument the MPAA's been trying to make and it's just a sign of the establishment not adjusting to the new reality that distribution is not a profitable industry anymore.

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by chaz on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @09:45PM (#6965071)
> No it doesn't, those people wouldn't have paid anyway.

You can't know all of the ways they will possibly make money from the content. Justin Bieber may want to charge Apple more for including vetted lyrics in iTunes. But why would Apple give Justin Bieber money when they can just copy the content from Rap Genius? Or cut a deal with Rap Genius for a feed?

> distribution is not a profitable industry anymore

This is where you're missing the point. You see the price as paying for distribution, but it's really about the value of the content. Historically, the two were inextricably linked by a physical medium. Now they are completely separate things with different prices and costs, and are almost unrelated to one another. Just because one goes close to zero, doesn't mean the other does, too.

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by gnaritas on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:37PM (#6973785)
Nor do I care about the ways people like to think up to ban other people from doing stuff. If you don't want your work copied, don't publish it. The whole copyright/patent system is a ridiculous absurdity based on the false premise that creative people require monetary incentive to do anything. When technology renders enforcement of laws impractical, then the laws are simply bad. Copying is not theft, creators are not entitled to anything, they deserve no protection for their published works at all.

Art doesn't have to be a business and art will be created regardless of whether artists can profit in perpetuity from their work. The notion that ideas and words are property and can be owned is perverse doublespeak meant to trick people into transferring their gut instincts about physical property onto things that quite simply are not property.

Performers should make money from performing, not being paid forever because the government created artificial monopolies on words and ideas.

Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by look_lookatme on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @01:55PM (#6963830)
If someone makes money off a copyrighted work, the copyright holder deserves to be paid.
Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by gnaritas on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @02:01PM (#6963850)
No they don't; they might legally be required to pay, but legal != deserves. Copyright and patent laws are wrong and create artificial scarcity to create a monopoly where there should be none. Just because something is the law does not make it just or right; they don't deserve anything.
Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by sanswork on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @02:12PM (#6963881)
So you would do away with all non-physical trade?
Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by gnaritas on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @02:33PM (#6963965)
Where did I say or imply this?
Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by sanswork on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @07:13PM (#6964781)
"Copies are not theft and the artist doesn't deserve anything."
Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by gnaritas on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @07:16PM (#6964790)
That doesn't imply what you seem to think it implies.
Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by sanswork on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @08:13PM (#6964907)
Then clarify because so far all you've done is said "People don't deserve this! Copying isn't stealing. They shouldn't get paid for this" then when anyone challenges you they get the reply "Thats not what I meant" or some snarky comment about their comprehension.
Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes by gnaritas on Friday December 27, 2013 @10:41PM (#6973800)
Clarify what. I could send you a bitcoin, look, non-phisical trade. If you want to critique something, it's up to you to make a clear critique, not me to figure out what you mean when the words you wrote are trivially and obviously false. When you infer I mean things I didn't say, it's not snarky to point out I didn't say that or mean that. I said what I meant, deciphering meaning was not an exercise left for the reader, it's right there in the words I wrote.