Re:Google Has Officially Penalized Rap Genius For Link Schemes
by gnaritas on Wednesday December 25, 2013 @02:03PM
(#6963860)
> But the buyers don't set the price.
I never said they did, please do try and comprehend before simply repeating yourself.
> That person deserves to be paid for what they have created which is what this is.
False.
> Your job wouldn't exist without that belief and neither would mine.
This is a belief you hold, not a fact.
>No they don't; they got paid to write the song, they're done. The notion that a person deserves to be paid forever in secondary markets where people trade their creations is a perverse and absurd notion that exists only in the messed up modern world; it's wrong.
Who is this magically being that pays the writer to write the song exactly? It isn't a secondary market it's a primary market. The song writer has created something(A song!) and the site wants to use that song. They are dealing with the song writer or copyright holder that is a first sale.
That person deserves to be paid for what they have created which is what this is. Your job wouldn't exist without that belief and neither would mine.