I am a supporter of the 2nd amendment, but for the sake of accuracy, gun violence in Australia was indeed reduced when they made gun ownership a lot harder there.
The societal cost of gun ownership is still a lot less than the societal cost of car accidents. I'm more concerned about the societal cost of playing fast and loose with amendments to the constitution.
Yes, but due to substitution effects the overall violent crime rate didn't change much.
The real harm that comes out of the so-called "gun debate" is a polarization of American society and a failure of both sides to recognize our legal and societal framework as a treasure everyone holds in common. Instead, both sides vilify each other and only talk to their own to showboat their intransigence.
As a programmer, I can certainly understand the frustration of pro-gun side. I'm very familiar with the ridiculousness of laws trying to restrict technology written by clueless politicians. Many gun laws fit into this category. I just can't see this situation being resolved in an attractive manner the way things are going now.
The solution? Get people actually talking to each other.
Agreed, but at the same time, disparaging the OP for having to address rhetoric (that old saw) seems antithetical to that aim.
Yes, gun violence decreased in Australia when they banned guns. Violence did not. Violence, to me, seems to be specific enough an objective that specialization isn't needed. I understand why oncologists specialize in curing cancer, as that is their field of expertise. I do not understand why gun control advocates feel that specialization is necessary with violence, if the net effect is the same with or without them.
I believe that is the point that aaronem was trying to make; not that he was trying to be pithy.
For what it's worth, I'm pretty hard-line on the second amendment, and I see value in the second amendment as a tool for the preservation of freedom. If a law were passed that banned possession of a firearm that I already owned, and/or required a mandatory buyback of that firearm, I would probably become a felon for violating that law as I would deem that law unconstitutional. That said, if the 2nd amendment were repealed, I would cede my firearms. That doesn't necessarily say anything on its own, but frames the rest of what I'm about to say; which is that presumably, every responsible gun owner would also like to see a reduction in gun-related crimes, even more so than the average gun control advocates, and it boggles my mind that gun control advocates seem to focus on gun crimes specifically, to the detriment of all other forms of crime, while gun rights advocates seem to do the exact opposite. You'd think the tables would be turned, as gun owners have the most vested interest.
I hear that often. How do you see that happening? What is the reasoning? I wasn't born here and I keep hearing this point touted often. Maybe it is something obvious, I haven't learnt yet. They way I see it presented is "we have guns so we can preserve our Freedom". Freedom from who? Some seem to think it is from criminals taking our possessions, some think it is from government. Which one do you think of when you think "freedom".
If it is the later (and probably the more common interpretation), doesn't seem unreasonable that for guns to be a viable threat or worry-some thing for the government to fear, it would have to match the parity guns had in, oh I don't know, early 1800s? A group of 1000 militia men armed with guns vs 1000 government soldiers armed with guns. I can see that play out well. 1000 men armed with AR-15s vs a nuclear arsenal, tanks, helicopters, machine guns, an intelligence apparatus, total media and public transportation control, satellites, 100s and 100s of billions of dollars in budget. Why are guns even mentioned as a "protection of freedom" when Government is that one freedom is protected? Seems rather like a joke to me (but again maybe I am missing an obvious argument here).
Counter-arguments I can think of and heard before -- "oh but this would be a guerrilla warfare that is why AR-15 and hunting rifles and pistols would be effective", so "need a nuclear arsenal" doesn't apply here. My response to that is "how would guns help". Wouldn't it then be more about guerrilla tactics (or maybe terrorist tactics, depending which side is talking about it). IEDs, poisoning water supplies, sabotage, home-made rockets etc. And again there having or not having legal guns seems to make little difference. What am I missing?
There are numerous stories throughout history wherein firearms were used to protect against oppression. In some cases, those firearms were used against governments, nation-states, guerrilla forces, insurgents, etc. In other cases, they have failed. Regardless, the odds are dramatically skewed when one side has guns and the others don't.
Reductio ad Hitlerum, before "Germany" became "Nazi Germany", there was far less in the way of gun control. The regime prior to Hitler had made gun control a priority, so the citizen was generally not armed. Before Hitler began committing genocide against Jews, he actually loosened gun control regulations... for everybody that wasn't Jewish. I'll spare you the remainder of the details, with which I'm sure you're at least somewhat familiar.
Before Hitler, there was a Revolution in the 1700s from some would-be sovereigns that claimed Independence from Britain. Before that revolution, the redcoats attempted to seize the arms that would later become the implements of war by the militia. In some cases they were successful. In either case, Americans found that they hadn't been armed enough, and later had to entreat with France for more arms to be provided. Long story short, then America was born.
These are not particularly unique stories. There are many stories where governments have committed genocide en masse. There are less stories where those governments enacted gun control and disarmed citizens prior to committing that genocide. There are fewer still stories where those citizens were not disarmed, and of those, there are stories where the citizenry was able to escape from, defray, deter, or even prevent those catastrophes from occurring.
> doesn't seem unreasonable that for guns to be a viable threat or worry-some thing for the government to fear
Quite probably, yes. That doesn't mean that the gun will be the only implement. It's probably even more so now, but let's not forget how out-gunned we were compared to Britain. But despite the improbability, we won that. It's also worth noting that you might not be fighting against the federal government, but perhaps a local government, or rogue police officers. The "Battle of Athens"[1] occurred in the 40s, and was fought against a corrupt county level government.
> And again there having or not having legal guns seems to make little difference. What am I missing?
That the objective need not necessarily be "to defeat the US military". A successful outcome might be to defend against slaughter just long enough to escape, as some Jews did in Germany that had hidden their firearms from confiscation. A successful outcome might be to simply highlight that the US government is waging war to the general populace. There are a variety of successful outcomes between "die" and "successfully defeat the entire armed forces with my shotgun" that could be attained.
An all-out war between the federal government and the US citizenry is definitely a lop-sided battle. Drones operate out of range of being shot down, and even the assaultiest assault weapon does little damage against a tank or armored vehicle. That said, that's the least likely type of skirmish to occur. For 1) the US government isn't likely to declare any such type of war, nor could they easily justify it, even with media control. What is more likely to happen is something like the Japanese Internment, or a WACO style of incident. Even in those cases, our odds are slim of obtaining an outright 'win', but holding off attackers long enough for the media to catch on that the government is trying to kill you might be? Etc.
If your intent is to raise the hassle and expense of owning lawnmowers, then the effect of so doing on gardening and lawn care is entirely irrelevant. If your intent is to reduce the extent to which gardening and lawn care take place, it's entirely relevant. In such ambiguities originate the suspicions of the pro-lawnmower faction.
As regards the rest, I think you've got cause and effect mixed up; it seems to me not so much that the "gun debate", and similar "debates", polarize American society, as that what we call American society, and in particular the politics of the United States, revolve around a conflict between two fundamentally irreconcilable perspectives on -- well, on everything, more or less. A century and a half ago, this conflict erupted into open warfare, which concluded in a decisive victory for one of the two factions; while neither side has taken up arms in any meaningful way since, the conflict itself remains unresolved, and has simmered under the surface ever since.
On the other hand, the side which won that war I mentioned has done a sterling job of consolidating its gains and pushing to expand them, to the extent that it would be all but impossible for their opponents to pull off an upset by any conceivable means -- and God be thanked for that! It's the only thing which stands between our comfortable lives here in the United States, and chaos.
So, on the whole, I'm satisfied. Of course, I'd be happier still if I thought the winning side had a program with a snowball's chance of actually working when implemented on a platform of some three hundred million or so human beings, but I figure that, by dint of careful neglect of my health, I can more or less ensure that I won't be around to see anything worse than, at most, the initial stages of the collapse which I expect, in the fullness of time, will arrive. Sure, I could be wrong about that, but I don't think I am -- and, in the meantime, there's Calvados, and good fellowship among friends, and even a few programming languages to work in which aren't as terrible as the rest, and who can say fairer than that?
I suspect you'd agree: much proposed gun regulation is a knee-jerk in reaction to fear. Its consequences to society aren't well thought out.
As regards the rest, I think you've got cause and effect mixed up
Regardless of how it all got started, people talking at each other is now a part of a self-perpetuating cycle.
The issues that polarize Americans today are very different from what they were 150 years ago.
But you will note that at no point, in the comment to which you replied, did I give a name to either faction of which I spoke. This was quite deliberate. I have names for those factions. So do you. So does anyone who might take part in a discussion like this one. But those names aren't all that often the same, and even when they are, it usually turns out that each party has his own idea of precisely what they mean. Throwing names around, in my experience, tends very strongly to confuse the matter, rather than to clarify it.
That said, I'll grant I did not expect a comment like yours. Where did you happen upon the remarkable idea that "Republican", a century and a half ago, meant anything remotely similar to what it means today?
"'Killed by an AK-47' implies that...."
Do you seriously not see the contradiction here?
Perhaps I misunderstand. If so, perhaps you'll formalize the matter closely enough that I'm able to spot where I have gone wrong.
Yes, p => q implies !q => !p regardless of any opinion you hold. But you have decided that the original phrase means p => q, and that is interpretation. And one which is rather wrong, since everybody, including yourself, who reads the original phrasing will understand it differently.
I hope it's uncontroversial to state that the most effective way of steering political opinion is to establish a method of determining the terms in which political discussion is undertaken. (It should certainly be uncontroversial to state this to a progressive, whose political movement has more precisely formalized the concept than any other in recent history!)
In this line, one might promulgate a formula by which human agency is as much as possible elided from discussion of one particular method by which humans have been known to kill one another, in favor of the unstated but strong implication -- yes, that word again -- that the essential problem lies in the method, rather than in the untrammelled urge to kill. "Killed by an AK-47" is a sterling example of the type.
You argue that "everyone knows" what is meant by that formula, and I wouldn't presume to disagree with such a trivially obvious statement. But, in that case, I'm forced to wonder why anyone bothers with the obfuscation at all! What does it add, to the attempt to reason as accurately as possible about a phenomenon in order to enact laws intended to control it to the benefit of all, to use a form of words which suggests by its structure the absurd thought of a firearm floating around willy-nilly shooting people of its own accord? To whose benefit is this absurdity deployed?
In another reply to me elsewhere, you said that you have no political purposes here. Why, then, are you so convinced that this phrasing is used for the purposes of steering political opinion, and why are you so offended by that notion?
This must be why all the armies of the world don't bother supplying their soldiers with firearms, since they're just as able to kill people with other methods, like perhaps a knife. Knives, of course, are much cheaper and easier to maintain. Facilitating something generally makes that thing more common.
It's curious that you've retreated into a polysyllabic fortress of formal logic, yet rely on absurdist analogies like banning carpentry, as if there's any demographic that even slightly wants that. The reason why it's hard to find something appropriate to compare in the common modern experience is because there's nothing else like firearms; nothing where the general public can have one member exert their will so forcefully over another. There's no such analogy to be fairly made.
You strike to the heart of the matter when you describe a firearm as a means for one person to work his will upon another. This is true, but only in conjunction with the unstated assumption that the other so described has no similar means of defending himself. A man is not helpless against his enemy so long as both are similarly armed, but you render him quite thoroughly so when you disarm him -- which is precisely what you do when one man is an honest citizen, the other is a criminal, and you pass a law prohibiting the ownership of firearms.
A man is not helpless against his enemy so long as both are similarly armed, but you render him quite thoroughly so when you disarm him
Here is a fundamental difference between how we see the world. You see the world through the eyes of the beseiged, us and them. Those people out there want to get me. They are my enemy. I must be able to destroy them, I must be able to project my power and keep what is mine. There are 'honest citizens' and 'criminals' and never the twain shall meet.
I see the world as 'we're all in this together'. People do shitty things, but we can reduce the total number of shitty things by working to improve everyone's lot. If someone does a shitty thing, instead of treating them like a criminal and making them worse, work towards rehabilitation.
I pay my taxes. I show up 9-5 for my work. I don't get in people's way. If someone has a turn for the worse in the street, I usually step in and help. This morning I evaded my public transport fare, as I did last night. Am I an 'honest citizen'? Am I a 'criminal'? If I were to obtain a firearm, would the 'honest citizens' around me be right to feel threatened? People are not separable into these two polar groups.
There is hysteria on both sides of the gun debate - and the pro-gun side's version is to paint the world in this ridiculous shades of the brightest white and the darkest night. Either for us or against us. It's a particularly weirdly conformist point to push, given that the same people are usually the same folks trumpeting personal freedom (not that you have been here)
The use of "honest citizen" and "criminal" was an instance of extreme imprecision on my part, brought about by unnecessary haste to reach my point, and you're right to pick on that. I could much more usefully replace those terms with "one who seeks to contribute to society" and "one who seeks to parasitize society". While still imprecise, those phrases come much closer to the heart of the distinction I draw.
You will no doubt take exception to that latter phrase in particular, and I don't blame you; "parasite" in description of any person is an extremely loaded word. Let me respond in kind by noting that "rehabilitation" is the wrong term for your meaning. To rehabilitate someone is to restore him to an ability which he previously lacked. But someone who is not able to obey the law, be he willing or otherwise, is not someone our society generally regards as criminal, because he cannot accurately be said to have possessed mens rea -- in other words, he lacks the capacity to know that what he is doing is unlawful. For some who break the law, this is true. For many, many more who break the law, this is not true in the slightest; most who break laws choose to do so, whether they conceive of themselves as having done so or otherwise.
Such a person need not be "rehabilitated", because his problem is not that he is unable to behave in accordance with the requirements of society, but rather that he chooses to do otherwise. The process through which he needs to go, in order to be restored to society's good graces, cannot therefore be accurately called rehabilitation; unfortunately, I'm not sure that our modern vernacular has a word which does describe that process. In days gone by, this process was considered one of penitence, hence the old name "penitentiary" for that institution which we now call a "prison".
Moreover, I consider the rehabilitative model a grave insult against the human dignity of most who commit crimes -- specifically, all those who commit crimes while being able to behave otherwise should they so choose. You seem to regard these people, more or less, as though they were ill, or perhaps mentally disabled; in other words, you consider them as bereft of either the necessary volition to behave other than in a criminal fashion, or of the necessary reason to differentiate behavior which accords with society's requirements from behavior which does not.
The Soviet travesty of criminal justice, for at least a considerable part of its existence, regarded its dissidents in precisely this fashion, and labeled them with a variety of pseudo-psychiatric diagnoses in an effort to explain the supposed insanity which rendered them unable to recognize the obviously ongoing triumph of dialectical materialism. You may have heard the phrase "sluggish schizophrenia"; in this enormity it has its origin, and I'm sure you can imagine what life became for those misfortunates who fell foul of the Soviet state in this fashion. Years prior, during the eugenics fad in the United States, a family history of criminal behavior was considered grounds for sterilization, in order to prevent whatever genetic traits led to such misbehavior from propagating further.
Do I seek to slander you by these invidious comparisons? I do not. I seek merely to place in sharp relief some historical consequences of the way you look at criminal behavior, in order to help demonstrate the essential difference between my attitude toward that subject and yours. Specifically, where you by default regard someone who has committed a crime -- "done a shitty thing", in your formulation -- as being unwell or mentally disabled and therefore in need of custodial care to restore him to full health, I by default regard him as having made a choice to behave as he has, and, until he demonstrates otherwise, being just as fully equipped as anyone else to choose to behave otherwise. The former, if I may borrow a term from the vernacular of the social sciences, dehumanizes him; the latter instead exalts that sine qua non of humanity, the ability to make moral choices, that which Catholics call the indwelling Holy Spirit, which Quakers call the Inner Light, and the existence of which even those au courant with the most modern atheistic agnosticism recognize, even if they tend to lack words with which to name it.
Let me finally address the siege mentality under which you seem wrongly to believe I labor. When I speak of "enemy", I refer not to some nebulous Lacanian Other, but instead to the man who is not satisfied merely to mug someone on the street for his wallet, but feels it necessary to answer any resistance with a knife, or a gun, or worse indignities still. I've been fortunate thus far in never having fallen foul of such men myself, despite having lived in some of the less delightful areas of a city generally regarded as not particularly safe. Not all my friends and acquaintances have had the same good fortune. I acknowledge that this somewhat prejudices my perspective on the matter. No doubt firsthand experience would prejudice my perspective still further. Should it not be so? Do you ask that I not merely vow allegiance to your principles, but value those principles more highly than I value my own life and unpunctured carcass? You are of course welcome to make whatever decision in that regard you find meet, inasmuch as it concerns your own meat; I'll thank you not to tell me how to dispose of mine, it being the only one I've got and a whole life's worth of use to get out of it.
Perhaps you believe it is possible to render firearms unavailable to men of such ilk. While that belief seems optimistic at best given the commonality of firearms in the United States, we need not stipulate in either direction to acknowledge that, be he able or unable to lay hands on a gun, he will certainly have no difficulty in finding a knife.
Perhaps you believe it is possible to empanel a sufficiency of police officers to ensure that such men are unable to pursue their fell trade. This has been tried. It has never worked. I see no reason to imagine it will ever work. The police we do have, God protect them, have among themselves a saying: "When seconds count, the police are there in minutes." And even if it were possible so to multiply their ranks, it is inherently enfeebling of self-respect and self-determination to be dependent, for such a basic need as the integrity of one's own corpus, on another human being -- the condition of a child, not that of an adult.
I have no general fear of my fellow man; as far as I can tell, everybody's just trying to get through the day, the same as me, and why not? But if my fellow man should start to think that the best way for him to get through his day might be to interrupt mine with a demand for my wallet and a weapon at the ready should I presume to demur, I am very much in favor of the idea that he should be afraid of me -- not because I mean him harm, which I do not, but because he recognizes that, should he offer me harm, I'm just likely to see him and raise him.
Is this an ideal state of affairs? Of course not, but no ideal state of affairs is attainable in any case -- that's what "ideal" means. But I greatly prefer the situation I describe to one in which, should my fellow man take it in mind to behave toward me with fell intent, he feels free to do so unencumbered by any shadow of concern that his intended victim might ventilate him, instead. Were that state of affairs more general, I misdoubt I'd have fewer friends with scars.
it behooves you not to say things like this: You seem to regard these people, more or less, as though they were ill, or perhaps mentally disabled; in other words, you consider them as bereft of either the necessary volition to behave other than in a criminal fashion, or of the necessary reason to differentiate behavior which accords with society's requirements from behavior which does not.
The modifying word 'seem' is merely a weasel word. Here what you are doing is telling me how I see the world, something that you will not accept about yourself, 'especially unasked'. Each of us has stated how the other person appears to see the world - you take exception to this being applied to yourself, though.
To rehabilitate someone is to restore him to an ability which he previously lacked
Much of your argument rests on this faulty definition. 'Habilitate' means 'to make fit or capable'. In a legal context, a person is a capable member of society until they perform an antisocial act, a criminal act. Re-habilitation means making that person a capable member of society again. Your definition doesn't even make internal sense, because you can't restore something that has not yet existed ('previously lacked').
Antisocial behaviour is also not limited to crimes. Someone can become an alcoholic, cutting off their loved ones, and undergo rehabilitation to restore them to their previous capacity. Hence why I formulate it as 'done a shitty thing' rather than focus simply on criminals.
I by default regard him as having made a choice to behave as he has, and, until he demonstrates otherwise, being just as fully equipped as anyone else to choose to behave otherwise.
This statement betrays your near-complete lack of understanding of human psychology, and also mental illness. One part of rehabilitative work is to help the person understand how they're making patterns of bad decisions without realising it, in an unconscious way. The idea that everything we do is a conscious, premeditated choice is pure pablum. Simple evidence that people have trouble choosing to behave a certain way by simple fiat lies in the low success rate of diets.
It's really quite a bizarre point for anyone familiar with the topic (myself formally trained, also worked in neurology) to see put forward. People are not capable of making decisions to the same degree, for a host of reasons, even simple education. People often don't see the harmful patterns in their lives because sometimes they're simply unaware of the existence of such a thing. One example might be yellow journalism - it's harder to fall prey to it once you've been educated in statistics, journalism, or one of a few similar fields. But if you don't know the tricks they use, you can't really counter them since you're not aware of them.
Do you ask that I not merely vow allegiance to your principles, but value those principles more highly than I value my own life and unpunctured carcass?
Criminology is actually pretty clear on the point. If you rehabilitate people rather than ostracise them, there are fewer punctured carcasses overall. The problem with your argument style is that it's similar to the pro-gun lobby: it focuses solely on the individual situation. "If X happened, I'd want a gun!". The thing is, with a better, more inclusive society, "X" happens far less frequently.
By making histrionic personal appeals as the pro-gun lobby does, you distort decision-making. It's an open secret that prisons in the US take minor offenders and make major offenders out of them; making decent jobs harder to get, exposing them long-term to harder criminal contacts, and reinforcing the social divide between your 'honest citizens' and 'criminals'. Sure, if someone came at me with a knife, I'd like a gun. But I'd rather them not come at me with a knife in the first place. Stop crime at the source, the motive, rather than at the last step before it actually happens. An ounce of prevention is better than a pound of cure.
Perhaps you believe it is possible to empanel a sufficiency of police officers to ensure that such men are unable to pursue their fell trade. This has been tried. It has never worked.
When, in the US? "Never worked" suggests multiple attempts. It's certainly worked outside the US, in Australia.
And even if it were possible so to multiply their ranks, it is inherently enfeebling of self-respect and self-determination to be dependent, for such a basic need as the integrity of one's own corpus, on another human being -- the condition of a child, not that of an adult.
This is patent nonsense. We are a society, and we are all in this together. The only way I would accept this comment from you is if you were a fully self-sufficient recluse living in the woods somewhere. Do you live only on food you grew yourself? Drink only water you collect yourself? Clothe yourself only in self-made clothes? Use only your self-made fuel for heating, should the climate require? Self-treat all medical issues, from headaches to broken bones? Transport yourself using only your feet or self-made items? If not, then by your own definition, you dependent on another human being for a basic need and are therefore a child, with thoroughly enfeebled self-respect and self-determination. And even if you are such a self-sufficient person, pretty much everyone else in the developed world is not, along with pretty much everyone who isn't a subsistence farmer/fisher in the developing world.
The short form of the argument is that the US currently does exactly what you're claiming is the right way: fuck the criminals and arm the populace. It doesn't work. 1% of US adults are in prison. The US has an incarceration rate of 750/100k - all other Western democracies are between 70 and 150, except for New Zealand at 200. The US is a clear outlier. It still has a higher violent crime rate. Its murder rate is four times that of its contemporaries. It's creating a hardened underclass that doesn't have access to the self-respect and particularly not the self-determination you so value. The extreme demand on the public purse for prisons stops beneficial infrastructure projects from being developed. You try to make me sounds Soviet in my outlook, hoping that the reflected anti-glory taints what I say, whereas I am more "other western democracies" in my outlook.
You have excellent rhetoric, but the underpinning arguments are faulty to their core. I would also encourage you though to drop the every-example-person-is-a-man thing, particularly when you're making the argument that everyone should be master of their own destiny.
Edit: cut out a few quote/response stanzas to shorten things
"Killed by an AK-47" implies that, had the weapon been made unavailable beforehand, the killing would not have occurred. This has been tried many times in history. It has never worked. As I discuss in a comment elsewhere in this sub-thread, the range of human ingenuity is far too broad, and the human carcass is far too easily rendered inanimate, for the prohibition of one particular class of tools to bring about an end, or even a meaningful reduction, in killing. Banning firearms to save lives is precisely as absurd a proposition as banning hammers to prevent carpentry -- indeed, in a nation as historically awash with firearms as the United States, even more so.