Ambitious people leave in droves, because an organization run entirely on "other people's money" always steers towards complacency and lack of accountability, translating to ambitious people who care about delivering on-time being surrounded by people whose kid's softball game takes precedence over leaving customers out in the cold.
Anyone who has EVER dealt with the federal government in any fucking way knows that what you are saying would never work. The laziest people I have ever encountered in my life are in the Federal government. I'm a huge advocate for the environment, and my first dealings with the EPA made me want to cry. They are horrifically lazy at a cultural level. The DoD is fucking awful. Go to a military base at 3:00 PM on a Friday afternoon and watch as a traffic line builds up at the exit gates as the civillian workers go home 2 hours early, EVERY weekend.
The military is some of the hardest working but criminally underpaid.
The whole contracting system is broken - the amount of money government leaks there is criminal.
When you get out, you have access to federally subsidized loans that nobody else gets, as well as the ability to have Tricare (ultra cheap health insurance) for the rest of your life. When you consider that less than 10% of active duty military will ever see combat, this is a bargain.
Companies reputation is a fuzzy number too. As the stock market adage goes "past performance does not guarantee future success". Sure brand reputation means something but how do you measure that and create equal comparison...across hugely disparate government contracts. Comparing the US Census contract (yes this is contracted out almost entirely) to the F35 contract would be absurd.
I do not necessarily have the end all solution. I tend to favor smaller government because I am not sure our current political system scales to be able to execute large projects (I tend to think the ideas behind many large scale projects are correct but fail when you consider the costs of implementation within our political constraints).
If the government is able to do something internally for $500m, and the disadvantaged private sector is going to cost $750m, then let the government do it themselves. (On the government's books, this is a net win.) If the government costs it at $500m, but a private company can do it for $400m... Why let the government do it? Contract it out and save money.
Yes, that competitor provided you a solution for 10% less, however it's horribly bloated and inefficient and will have double the on-going hardware costs, and the solution itself is a fucking mess that is going to increase the cost of any changes or maintenance ten-fold.
Problem is, they don't know the difference. The people who will best know the difference are going to be the people who work with/in the same area - the supplier's competitors. Far from impartial.
So maybe we set up some sort of oversight agency, but then we either have them make snap judgements without the appropriate understanding and penalizing what may be more difficult/complicated projects (meaning no one will want to bid on them), or we create such a huge overhead in documentation that we're pretty much back where we are now - no one but the largest of players can even afford the overhead to participate.