News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why the Pentagon’s many campaigns to clean up its account... by rayiner on Monday December 23, 2013 @11:25AM (#6955018)
One aspect that's missing in these comments is an acknowledgement of the complexity of the projects which are the subject of defense contracts. The Pentagon and its contractors are literally at the edge of the state of the art in fields like aerospace. Very few companies have the expertise to even attempt to take on these contracts, and most projects have ill-defined specifications simply because nobody is quite sure what is technologically possible until the project is well underway. And nobody knows how much money will be needed up front. That's like asking Zuck in his dorm room: "how much money will you need to build Facebook as it exists circa 2013?"

I used to work at a company that did DOD contracts (in the wireless sector). In that area, what the DOD was playing with in the early 2000's is what VC-funded companies are playing with just in the last few years. For the work we did, there were no detailed specs because nobody really knew what was within reach. In response to the question: "what do you want?" the DOD's response is often: "what could we have?" Pointing at how much more efficient private industry is makes no sense. Take an example like Space X. They're a shining example of private industry, and are doing very innovative stuff, but they're treading a lot of the same ground NASA and DOD contractors did in the 1960's. Of course they're getting it done for a lot less money! They know what's possible, they have a general idea of what works. The contractors doing this stuff in the 1960's had none of that to work with.

Obviously the time is due for modernizing the accounting system. But it's important to realize that a lot of the mess dates from the Cold War, where keeping up with the Soviet Union was the priority, not satisfying the bean counters.

Re:Why the Pentagon’s many campaigns to clean up its account... by omegant on Monday December 23, 2013 @01:10PM (#6955590)
This is very well explained at the book moon lander, it's an amazing inside story of the problems they encountered during the design and comstruction of the modules. What has surpriced me is that the design effort was minor compared with the management and quality control. They had to multiply the budgets severaltimes to be able to correct unexpected problems.
Re:Why the Pentagon’s many campaigns to clean up its account... by pnathan on Monday December 23, 2013 @04:45PM (#6956699)
I don't think that having a bucket for "Gold Toilet Seats" or "Classified Research" is the key problem. I think that the problem is that there is a gigantic integration effort that fails due to a variety of interlocking political factors and the malincentives to get the job done right.
Re:Why the Pentagon’s many campaigns to clean up its account... by bhewes on Monday December 23, 2013 @01:13PM (#6955607)
I have to agree with you about dealing with the Soviet Union it made accounting an after thought. Now the war has moved to an economic front (if it was not always that). And a fighting force that cannot effectively keep track of its resource usage is a vulnerable one.
Re:Why the Pentagon’s many campaigns to clean up its account... by revelation on Monday December 23, 2013 @03:56PM (#6956475)
Nobody has a problem with funding experimental research and projects. That is not an excuse to not follow basic accounting principles and, quite frankly, have no clue where money has gone.
Re:Why the Pentagon’s many campaigns to clean up its account... by tomohawk on Monday December 23, 2013 @07:51PM (#6957606)
That may be, but isn't this an ERP system?

Why does the DoD need to run a project like this as if they're creating the next stealth weapon?