News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by minimax on Saturday December 21, 2013 @07:11PM (#6948703)
Here we have more evidence of the miraculous ability of crypto currencies to turn unassuming computer programmers into economics experts. Let's take a look at some choice quotes.

There’s no inherent reason that a piece of paper has a certain amount of value. There is a subjective reason, though: namely, that a large enough number of people agree that USD is a worthwhile commodity. They believe that for a number of reasons, including that our Army will go off and fucking kill anybody who threatens to break the spell that makes everyone agree that USD are worth your time to accept.

That's a bunch of needlessly cynical and completely ignorant bullshit. We don't use the army to convince people to use dollars. That's quackery. People use dollars because the value is relatively stable, most goods for sale in the U.S. and exported from the U.S. are priced in dollars, people in the U.S. pay their taxes in dollars, oil tends to be priced in dollars internationally, foreign countries hold lots of dollars as reserves, in the U.S. you can have a bank account denominated in dollars that will retain it's value up to $250,000 even if the bank blows up(!), and so on. All of these are reasons people use dollars. It isn't something that's done at the point of a gun.

Everyone agrees that dollars are worth something, and we trade them all the time. They’re really easy to trade. I don’t know of any coffee shop near me that takes Euros, so even though 1€ is “worth more” than $1 USD, the Euro note I have in my backpack is basically useless for me to get some coffee. Economists call this property ‘liquidity,’ and it basically means ‘how easy is it for me to get what I want with this commodity.’

Stop calling currencies commodities. Currencies aren't like some weird subset of commodities. The reason Euro isn't useful in the U.S. is because there are no good reasons for it to be useful. I can't pay my taxes in Euros. Almost nothing for sale here is priced in Euros. If I try to deposit Euros in my dollar denominated bank account I will get a shitty FX rate from the bank. There is a lot of obvious friction involved in using things other than USD as a currency in the U.S. It has nothing to do with "liquidity."

Imagine a “Dogecoin VISA”, a credit card where I hold a balance in DOGE.

Great idea! Ok so now a bank has given me a certain amount of dogecoin denominated credit. Presumably that is backed up by dogecoin denominated savings accounts or whatever. People give their dogecoins to the bank and the bank lends the dogecoins to me. I spend my full line of credit but I can't pay it back. Suppose there are a bunch of crappy dogecoin debtors out there and none of us can pay back our dogecoin denominated debt. Now suppose the banks depositors get wind of the situation and all try to withdraw their deposits at once. Classic bank run. Depositors are all fucked because there is no FDIC insurance for dogecoins.

* TWTR -> USD -> BTC -> DOGE -> MYCOMPANY *

You lose money at every step along the way. You pay the spread for every transaction, and if banks get involved, you can probably expected to get fucked in all sorts of mysterious ways by the FX desk at some point too.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by egypturnash on Saturday December 21, 2013 @07:29PM (#6948757)
The OP gets snarky about the reasons people think dollars are a viable medium if exchange; you get serious. But four of your six reasons why people use dollars kinda boil down to "people use dollars because lots of people use dollars".

He's realized that "money" is just a very complicated game we play with each other. Possibly this is the lead-in to realizing that society is also a complicated game we play with each other. Either way, dude just had his mind blown because a silly joke currency made him start to think about What Money Is for the first time in his life.

That said, yeah his lengthy chains of currency exchange are a bad idea. Which is why there are exchanges that let you buy and sell BTC (and other cryptocurrencies, maybe even DOGE - I'm not going to bother checking) in currencies other than USD.

And there are a lot more rules that need to be added around cryptocurrencies before having a DOGE credit card, or bank account, is a sane game to play. Don't be putting anything you can't afford to lose in DOGE, or BTC for that matter.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by ChuckMcM on Saturday December 21, 2013 @08:21PM (#6948884)
And the author figures out it is all about liquidity, which it is. The reason you might take a Euro for something is that you can give it to your bank and they can convert it into something you can use for more things (dollars, rupees what ever).

I'm really curious though about what happens when someone walks up to Coinbase (as an example) and says "I've got 150,000BTC, please convert that into dollars for me at the market rate. What? No worries I'll just wait here. You can wire the dollars to this account here ..."

Let's assume that BTC were trading at $600 each, that is $90M dollars. Where does Coinbase get the $90M to cover their side of the transaction? Since nobody "bought" the BTC from Coinbase (perhaps some was bought there, but perhaps someone had just stolen it from the FBI or something) the counter party to that transaction (the person who gave dollars for BTC or gave watt-hours for BTC) their contributed value isn't at Coinbase, it is spread across perhaps a half dozen exchanges.

How does that even work at scale?

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by minimax on Saturday December 21, 2013 @09:30PM (#6949081)
It's not about liquidity. EURUSD is one of the most liquid currency pairs in the world. You can exchange millions or tens of millions in one trade at a firm price. That's liquidity at scale. In spite of that, Euro is still completely useless as a currency in the U.S. The liquidity argument is not a real argument.
Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by ChuckMcM on Saturday December 21, 2013 @09:55PM (#6949140)
Perhaps we're not talking about the same thing. For any national currency, a bank has a way of resolving your request to exchange their currency for a local, more acceptable, currency. That is part of what the banking system does, and BitCoin eschews.

In my fictional example, if an exchange didn't have deposits to cover the conversion they would go to their currencies central bank for the $90M and then exchange the BTC they got with the BTC central bank for $90M and pay back their overnight 'loan' from the local currency bank. How does that work for an exchange with BTC? Do you clean them out of all the dollars they have? Then what happens to other people who have BTC deposited and want dollars out? How does that work? Do the later people have to wait until someone buys some BTC and puts in dollars? If you have two people waiting for dollars out, who gets the dollars you just got? First one to request to get out? best customer? first one you can satisfy their complete withdrawal?

Those questions are the "liquidity argument" if you want to call it that. Who pays the price for not being able to convert coins? The exchange? The customer? Lets say the price of BTC plummets, people head for the doors and want their money in dollars now. Does the exchange give them dollars that they won't recover? Or do they wait on all withdrawals until the number stabilizes and the pay out at that price? In the former the institution takes the risk, in the later the customer takes the risk.

I totally get the BTC market as an awesome way to exchange markers securely. I'm not sure how it gets to be a currency without something providing the banking function. (one of those functions being liquidity as the author points out)

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by minimax on Saturday December 21, 2013 @10:34PM (#6949219)
There are a lot of question marks in your comment and I'm sure some of them are meant to be rhetorical and maybe some aren't. Also you mentioned something about exchanges talking to central banks which isn't something that happens. Your fictional example is:

I've got 150,000BTC, please convert that into dollars for me at the market rate. What? No worries I'll just wait here. You can wire the dollars to this account here ...

That isn't the kind of thing you do at the teller window. That kind of liquidity doesn't exist in bitcoin (though it would be a cinch in other major currencies). At this point you are in need of a really clever broker to find you someone to take the other side of the trade at a price that doesn't totally suck. Though that probably isn't very likely...

You seem to imply that the exchange has some responsibility here that I don't understand. The exchange matches buyers and sellers at a price they can both agree on. If there are no buyers for what you are trying to sell, that's too bad but it isn't the exchange's problem. Go look on the CME product list and you'll see tons of contracts that are listed but have no bids because nobody is interested in trading them.

If you want to trade a shitload of a questionable thing then you just might find there's no bid. See also: people selling mortgage backed securities in 2008. The price for not being able to sell a thing is paid by the people that own the thing (especially if they purchased the thing with borrowed monies and they are forced to price the thing by marking it to the market).

I think maybe your question is just "What happens if you want to sell bitcoins and nobody wants to buy them?" and in that case the sellers are just screwed.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by ChuckMcM on Saturday December 21, 2013 @11:48PM (#6949405)
I think maybe your question is just "What happens if you want to sell bitcoins and nobody wants to buy them?" and in that case the sellers are just screwed.

Nicely summarized. We are talking about the same thing.

That particular point is lost on a lot of people who are looking at Bitcoin. They see the surface aspect. Gee 1 BTC gets me $X and $X gets me 1 BTC. And from that they leap to 1 BTC is $X. That leap doesn't work because there is no equivalent of a market maker in BTC. I explain to folks who are wondering about BTC like this, "the more you want to trade the less they are worth, probably all the way to zero." So unlike Euros where 100 euros might be worth $132 and a million Euros $1.32M$ 100 BTC could be worth $X and a million BTC could be worth (small fraction x (10000 x $X)).

It is the difference between a currency and a collectibles market. Euros are the former, BTC are the latter.

Funny anecdote. My brother in law was buying property in europe and needed to do the transaction in Euros, prior to closing escrow he noticed that at the Hotel desk in the Caribbean where he was staying they had a better conversion rate than the bank had quoted him. The down payment was about $100,000 USD. On a whim he asked the desk clerk if he could change $100,000 USD to Euros and the clerk said, "Cash or check?" That one really through my brother-in-law for a loop!

I agree though, generally large foreign exchange transfers are scheduled things but they aren't all that complicated and seem to happen in the same 24 hr transaction window that other wire transfers do.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by Dylan16807 on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:21AM (#6949655)
>It is the difference between a currency and a collectibles market.

What, the size? I bet there are currencies from small countries that are harder than bitcoin to exchange without crashing the price. I don't think your distinction is a good one.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by steveklabnik on Saturday December 21, 2013 @09:51PM (#6949135)
If you have access to currency markets, absolutely, EURO/USD is incredibly liquid. At the point of sale, I do not have access to this market, so my Euros are not liquid. If they accepted credit cards (the shop I was at did not) and I had, say, a VISA that was denominated in Euro but which the bank would change into USD, my Euro would be liquid.

Another way to think about access: if I give a homeless man in the Mission 20 Euro, is that useful to him?

The actual form that you have the asset in matters.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by kolinko on Saturday December 21, 2013 @09:45PM (#6949120)
"at a market rate" doesn't mean "at a current price", but "at the amount people would be willing to pay".

Selling such a high position would lower the price of bitcoin on all the exchanges, until enough people would be willing to buy them.

So, for example, if you wanted to sell 100k BTC on MtGox in an instant, you could do that. It's just that the price would get down to around $120, and you'd get "just" $35M. (real numbers, via http://bitcoinity.org/markets/mtgox/USD )

As for Coinbase - as far as I understand, they don't hold a bitcoin position, but use internal trading and external exchanges. So both the money and the btc would come from people willing to buy Bitcoin.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by steveklabnik on Saturday December 21, 2013 @07:33PM (#6948764)
> Either way, dude just had his mind blown because a silly joke currency made him start to think about What Money Is for the first time in his life.

For the record, _I_ know this, it's that I think that _other_ people will start to think of this.

> Don't be putting anything you can't afford to lose in DOGE, or BTC for that matter.

Plus a zillion here.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by oafitupa on Saturday December 21, 2013 @08:11PM (#6948859)
"oil tends to be priced in dollars internationally"

And when that doesn't happen, suddenly they have the CIA overthrowing their leader, creating terrorists groups for false-flag operations, the US government spreading lies about WMDs, and then the entire army can go and fight the illegal (by international laws) war on terror.

There should be a war on ignorance, so that we don't have to read comments like yours anymore.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by minimax on Saturday December 21, 2013 @10:56PM (#6949272)
When oil isn't priced in USD what do you think it will be priced in? And what do you think CIA will be able to do about it?
Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by trrocket on Sunday December 22, 2013 @12:10AM (#6949452)
For many years it seemed likely it would be the Euro. At least Russia and Iraq circa 2002/3 publicly threatened making the switch, there may have been others. However, it seems that Iran stopped trading oil in USD (as of 2012) and apparently now uses a variety of other currencies[0], although I haven't looked into this to see if it actually happened yet. I am under the impression that China currently buys oil from Iran in Yuan/Renminbi.

I'd be interested to know if Iran went ahead with its plan to stop accepting USD altogether. I'd personally be surprised if threats and posturing regarding Iran's nuclear program went away without some sort of agreement on USD oil trade.

If Iran has stuck to its plan to stop accepting USD for oil AND the US backs off I think that signals a pretty significant loss for the US not just in terms of its relationship with Iran but ultimately, in the long term, in its attempts to remain a dominant force in the global economy. It would be a result of pressure from an international community that the US government feels it needs to keep on side, but also conversely an international community that may have an interest in reducing the economic dominance of the US.

Your second question is an interesting one. I think the US' next move - or Iran's (potentially changing its mind about USD oil trade) - will tell us how strong the US is at this moment in time. The position of economic & military dominance the US currently enjoys (which helps its "intelligence" agencies to get away with actions that would be otherwise considered acts of war) is bound to end at some point. I'm not willing to stick my neck on the line and predict the end of US hegemony is nigh (I'm not really a crystal ball kind of person) but I'd just say that the signs of a superpower fighting for its position should be evident. There will come a point where the US can no longer risk such interventions.

EDIT:

Having read a bit more (though not much, to be honest, so I'm happy to be corrected) it seems the Oil Bourse is for oil-derived products not crude oil (it actually says this on the Wikipedia article, doh). Also part of the agreement that reduced sanctions on Iran was to stop taking gold as payment for oil[1]. So there's no need to worry about the US' position in the world just yet.

Anyway, hopefully in 2014 some members of OPEC will be seriously advocating trading oil in dogecoin ;). To the moon!

0: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iranian_oil_bourse 1: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-11-24/iran-agrees-to-hist...

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by oafitupa on Sunday December 22, 2013 @03:55PM (#6951699)
Euros or dinars, or anything that looks less of a ponzi scheme than the USD.

What will the CIA be able to do? What I said, overthrow their democratically elected leader, create terrorist groups, etc:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1953_Iranian_coup_d%27%C3%A9ta...

You might also have heard of Libya...?

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by steveklabnik on Saturday December 21, 2013 @07:18PM (#6948720)
wow. much serious. many tears. so angry.

I specifically said I wasn't an expert. ;)

> That's a bunch of needlessly cynical and completely ignorant bullshit.

We're arguing the same thing. I'm just being a bit snarky about _why_ those things are true. You're totally right that those are the first-order reasons.

> Stop calling currencies commodities.

Sorry, my Marxism is showing. From a Marxist perspective, money _is_ just another commodity, though a special one. Maybe shouldn't have mixed that concept in, good call.

> Depositors are all fucked because there is no FDIC insurance for dogecoins.

Agreed. That's why I describe myself as 'scared.' I just said it's possible, not that it's a good idea. You won't find me quitting my job and starting that project any time soon.

> You lose money at every step along the way.

Absolutely, which is why you have to account for that when making the trades. I assumed that was too basic to bother to mention.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by minimax on Saturday December 21, 2013 @09:10PM (#6949022)
Sorry steveklabnik, I would have replied sooner but got stuck on a long phone call.

I'm not angry. I thought the post was worthy of a reasonably harsh takedown comment (sidenote: HN loves harsh takedown comments) because of its hubris. "Ho hum. We SF computer guys have got this shit all figured out. Paper currencies are bullshit because x, y, z. Also U.S.A. will bomb you if you don't agree." It's so completely fallacious and it ignores the decades experience that have got us to where we are.

I'm a tech person as I'm sure all of you are, but I think we are doing ourselves a disservice when we show up in other fields as arrogant outsiders proclaiming truth without understanding any of the details. I follow you on twitter and I think you understand this in terms of employment gender and discrimination issues but maybe not so much in terms of macroeconomic topics. That's all.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by steveklabnik on Saturday December 21, 2013 @09:32PM (#6949087)
It's all good. I enjoy your other comments on HN, i've upvoted many of them. I probably should have been working today rather than writing blog posts, oh well.

I do not think paper currencies are bullshit. I really really hate it when people say 'fiat' as a derogatory term. I also agree that SF techies running into other people's fields is terrible. However, economics is a field that I have actually attempted to educate myself on. This post was written with my 'junior economist' hat on, not my 'software dev' hat.

I think that you undervalue the role of imperialism with regards to the purchasing power of USD, but really, that whole thing is a sidenote anyway.

I still am unclear as to what your actual objection is. My assertion is that Dogecoin is just as legitimate of a currency as every other currency, as long as enough people believe in it as a medium of exchange, and that as long as the BTC <-> USD exchanges hold up, that it provides legitimacy (and liquidity) for all other cryptocurrencies. That's basically it. Oh, and that lack of consumer protection, like the FDIC insurance you mention, will harm people until we take cryptocurrency seriously and regulate it like we do other financial instruments.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by minimax on Saturday December 21, 2013 @10:08PM (#6949167)
I think that you undervalue the role of imperialism with regards to the purchasing power of USD

Point me to a historical example of the US government saying "Use dollars or else!" and I'll change my tune. I think foreigners use dollars because dollars are actually a really great currency relative to the local alternative ... or bartering (3 goats for 1 iPhone sort of thing).

My objection to your argument is that USD is better than alternative cryptocurrencies because the Federal Reserve does a good job of managing the stability of the value of the currency, and that's a social good for everyone. If your latte costs 3 dogecoins today and 6 dogecoins tomorrow you can be like "lol. so latte. much coins." That's funny for you and that's great. But if a bushel of wheat doubles or triples in price overnight because it's priced in some weird volatile currency, people will starve. And that's not funny.

I moved to Chicago recently and I work on the technology behind some of the commodities markets here. I guess that has sort of forced me to think more about these kinds of things. If you are in Chicago hit me up and we can bullshit face to face (over coffee that's probably better than whatever you have in SF. Zing!)

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by steveklabnik on Saturday December 21, 2013 @10:29PM (#6949200)
Basically, I agree with Greenspan, before he recanted:

> Without elaborating, he writes, "I am saddened that it is politically inconvenient to acknowledge what everyone knows: the Iraq war is largely about oil."

http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2007/09...

Every so often, OPEC threatens to switch over to the Euro...

But really, I don't think modern imperialism works via direct threat. That was the style of the 1700s. You won't find a direct statement to 'use the dollar or else,' you'll just find lots of wars and economic sanctions.

I don't think cryptocurrencies are 'better' than USD. I agree that the Fed is good for basically everyone, or at least, I don't think abolishing the Fed is a good idea. I agree that the volatility of DOGE makes it bad for anything but playing around at this point, and BTC dropping 50% in a day means that it's also nothing more than a speculative commodity at this point.

I've been thinking about this more because I moved here to work for a payments company, so ha! I actually know someone in Chicago who's working in commodities market stuff, IIRC... I always thought I'd live in Chicago before SFO. I'll certainly tweet if I'm ever there, and feel free to go take the blue line to Forest Park and put some flowers on Emma Goldman's grave for me ;) (I bet the coffee is better there, luckily, I don't really have a taste for good coffee, it's all just about the chemicals for me.)

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by Articulate on Sunday December 22, 2013 @07:22AM (#6950120)
I think you are overlooking some serious changes to the way the Fed regulates the money supply in the last five years. They are printing over 85 billion dollars every month. The stock market is soaring... why? because the government is artificially controlling interest rates which makes the value of your dollars go down fast- so people are forced not to save their money in a bank account but instead put their money "into" the economy- wealthy people are putting it into hard assets, and people that don't have as much are dumping money into the stock market as a hedge that their savings is loosing value every day. The result is a market that looks like it is doing great but is quiet volatile itself.

I agree that we should be very careful to just suddenly start running around yelling "the sky is falling" but I have heard an economist at the Fed (during a banking townhall) say "We are in totally uncharted territory" referring to how they will pull back all of the liquidity they have pumped into the market.

As for your comment about the US government saying "Use US Dollars or else..." that may not be the way that it looks on the surface but the US Government is very heavy handed in how other countries are allowed to control their own currencies, how multilateral trade deals are written in terms that force other countries to give up control over their own monetary policy.

You are correct that individuals around the world views the US dollar as stable and prefer to keep at least some portion of their wealth in US backed treasuries- but I would caution anyone from thinking that this is a foregone conclusion.

The fed uses a few people to try and hit multiple targets all at the same time... they have to deal with a bureaucracy that favors age and longevity, they have political pressures (see the Greenspan article above), and they have to make certain that their decisions keep their institution (coincidentally not a gov't institution but a private company)alive. The Fed is first and foremost a US-centric org. Whereas cryptocurrencies use the global market to find their level- whatever people agree is the price is the price... set number of bitcoins, completely liquid, and can cross borders without blinking... making trade easier than has ever been imagined before.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by patrickg_zill on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:17AM (#6949646)
You can only pay your taxes in Federal Reserve Notes (which are neither Federal, not backed by any reserve, and not notes).

THAT is why the income tax and US fiat currency were put into law at almost exactly the same time. Same as in ancient China and many other empires and countries - people can be forced to use fiat if they go to jail for not paying their taxes. Thus they have to work to get fiat.

Your statement about the Federal Reserve is laughable... I suggest some remedial learning, perhaps Ron Paul, or even just Zerohedge.com.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by Confusion on Sunday December 22, 2013 @05:02AM (#6949900)
I don't understand how you could read Steve's post as saying 'we have got this shit figured out' and 'proclaiming truth'. It's just someone's take on (crypto)currency; no reason to get all huffy about mistakes, let alone about disagreements.
Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by kordless on Saturday December 21, 2013 @07:23PM (#6948736)
> wow. much serious. so angry.

You said it yourself. People are scared by this. Anger comes with fear.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by thwest on Saturday December 21, 2013 @07:43PM (#6948781)
> That's a bunch of needlessly cynical and completely ignorant bullshit. [...] It isn't something that's done at the point of a gun.

Alan Greenspan is of the opinion that our Iraq wars were 'largely about oil' and economic stability. The point is debatable, but certainly not completely ignorant bullshit.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by derleth on Saturday December 21, 2013 @08:26PM (#6948896)
If the 'point of a gun' element was the major determinant in how much currencies are worth, Zimbabwe, which had and has a military sufficient to kill its own citizens, would never have had hyperinflation.
Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by steveklabnik on Saturday December 21, 2013 @08:30PM (#6948911)
The US's place in the global economy is just a bit difference than Zimbabwe, so that's a false equivalence.

Hint: I was talking about imperialism, not "buy stuff with the national money, citizen!"

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by guscost on Saturday December 21, 2013 @10:30PM (#6949202)
The American hegemony is bigger and involves a lot more moving parts, sure, but is that really a difference in kind rather than scale?

And if being a global superpower is the key to running an economy based on fiat money, how did it get that big in the first place?

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by espeed on Tuesday December 24, 2013 @11:17PM (#6962147)
America didn't start with fiat. The transcontinental railroads (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/First_Transcontinental_Railroad) provided the backbone for a continental network that helped unleash human creative potential, much like the Internet is doing today. This led to an economic boom. Then two world wars destroyed Europe while leaving America virtually untouched. In the aftermath America had risen to superpower status (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aftermath_of_World_War_II).
Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by Plasmoid on Saturday December 21, 2013 @11:39PM (#6949370)
> Currencies aren't like some weird subset of commodities.

Actually, currencies are considered to be the ultimate commodity. They don't degrade, they're 100% fungible, and they're instantly moveable worldwide. They're even susceptible to runs and shortages.

Think of it this way, what is the price of money? Is it $1 for a sandwich or 1 sandwich for a dollar? In this way, money has a price. So if the price of money goes up, by say everyone worrying that they'll lose their job and not spending anything, "prices" for goods will drop. Conversely, you can get runs when people think their money will lose value, eg during a war or disaster.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by kordless on Saturday December 21, 2013 @07:21PM (#6948729)
I'd argue that cryptocurrencies have a fair amount of commodity worth to them. The security of the coin is enabled by work put into the system by miners. Hypothetically there is some value in linking a commodity compute operation to crypto coin value.

BTW, I looked to see if there was a correlation between oil commodity and USD, and here's what I found: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Petrocurrency

Note the bit about oil in the Middle East being paid for by USD.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by throwaway_yy2Di on Saturday December 21, 2013 @08:02PM (#6948829)
"I'd argue that cryptocurrencies have a fair amount of commodity worth to them. The security of the coin is enabled by work put into the system by miners. Hypothetically there is some value in linking a commodity compute operation to crypto coin value."

You got causality backwards. Intrinsic value is what you can get out of a commodity, not what you spent putting into it. I can spend $100,000 cooking a hotdog over a Tesla Roadster bonfire; this does not inject $100,000 of intrinsic value into the hotdog.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by kordless on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:34PM (#6951375)
A cryptographically secure currency network is infinitely more valuable than a warm hotdog.

Via Wikipedia: causality is the relation between an event (the cause) and a second event (the effect), where the second event is understood as a consequence of the first.

In this example, the consequence of proof-of-work (mining and transaction validation) gives way to a distributed trust effect (crypto currency). i.e. work put into the system by miners gives the value of trust and security to the currency.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by throwaway_yy2Di on Sunday December 22, 2013 @06:54PM (#6952343)
A cryptographically secure currency network is infinitely more valuable than a warm hotdog.

Conversely, a global food distribution network is infinitely more valuable than a single dollar. You're conflating two radically unrelated things: the utility of the existence of a monetary system, with the concrete value of a specific instance of currency. The value of USD doesn't derive from the abstract utility of money. 1920's German hyperinflation didn't reflect people deciding that money systems, in general, are worthless.

Understanding that we're talking over each other:

* I have no doubt that cryptocurrency's utility is "enabled" by the effort spent in cryptographic validation;

* I'm saying it's value does not derive from that cost; it is not causally linked

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by minimax on Saturday December 21, 2013 @11:12PM (#6949313)
I spend a bunch of money buying electricity to run my electric kettle but that doesn't mean there's a huge market for selling hot water.
Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by kordless on Sunday December 22, 2013 @02:36PM (#6951386)
You are correct, but your statement doesn't make a valid comparative argument against mine. Read up on the value of proof of work: http://bitcoin.org/bitcoin.pdf
Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by yxhuvud on Sunday December 22, 2013 @03:58AM (#6949802)
Except when there are, like in areas that has central heating.
Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by rokhayakebe on Saturday December 21, 2013 @08:42PM (#6948950)
There’s no inherent reason that a piece of paper has a certain amount of value.

There is one actually: the cost of Labor and the perceived value of the services or goods that labor produced/produces/will produce. The value of money does not just appear, it is backed by everything everyone in a nation produces and consumes.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by theboywho on Saturday December 21, 2013 @09:03PM (#6949007)
Why is this the top rated comment? I just stopped reading it because of all the twisted logic, I was worried for my brain.
Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by minimax on Saturday December 21, 2013 @10:42PM (#6949237)
Ask a question or offer a critique of my twisted logic and I'll respond to it.
Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by lectrick on Sunday December 22, 2013 @07:42AM (#6950142)
> Currencies aren't like some weird subset of commodities.

I have a chart that is just begging to disagree with you:

https://www.google.com/search?q=usd+vs.+euro

To wit, "Currencies! So stability! Wowe!" A mere 25% fluctuation over the past 5 years! And at the scale of the Euro and the USD, no less!

Also, if currencies were as magically stable as you presume, then "currency trader" wouldn't be a thing. This also wouldn't be a thing:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_exchange_controls

Also,

> dogecoin denominated debt

Cryptocurrencies don't allow credit/debt systems. Just like I can't carry a "negative cash value". You either have cryptocurrency or you don't. And before you respond with "well then how would people buy houses and pay for college?", note that college costs have gone up BECAUSE of student loan availability, not IN SPITE OF it. And you know what? It's about time this happened, because fuck debt slavery.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by minimax on Sunday December 22, 2013 @09:12AM (#6950336)
Cryptocurrencies don't allow credit/debt systems.

Sure they do. If you lend me 5 crypto coins with the understanding that I'll repay you 6 crypto coins next year then we have a system of credit. The invention of credit predates the invention of money by thousands of years. In ancient times people would borrow seed under an agreement to repay at the harvest with associated penalties for default.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by etherael on Sunday December 22, 2013 @12:54AM (#6949513)
> oil tends to be priced in dollars internationally, foreign countries hold lots of dollars as reserves

The first bit there has nothing to do with the US military, and the second bit there is not because of the first.

Repeat after me; Petrodollar warfare is just a paranoid conspiracy theory.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by X4 on Saturday December 21, 2013 @08:28PM (#6948903)
Just asking, but isn't there a flaw in the logic and that this is actually not a one-way, but a two-way system? Like folowing:

* TWTR → USD → BTC → DOGE → MYCOMPANY *

* MYCOMPANY → DOGE -> BTC → USD → TWTR

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by twobits on Saturday December 21, 2013 @08:33PM (#6948919)
"That's a bunch of needlessly cynical and completely ignorant bullshit. We don't use the army to convince people to use dollars. That's quackery. People use dollars because the value is relatively stable, most goods for sale in the U.S. and exported from the U.S. are priced in dollars, people in the U.S. pay their taxes in dollars, oil tends to be priced in dollars internationally, foreign countries hold lots of dollars as reserves, in the U.S. you can have a bank account denominated in dollars that will retain it's value up to $250,000 even if the bank blows up(!), and so on. All of these are reasons people use dollars. It isn't something that's done at the point of a gun."

a) The value isn't stable. Dollars have lost ~90+% of its value since the fed was created. b) You pay taxes in dollars, because otherwise you'd be thrown in jail by force. c) Oil doesn't "tend to be valued in dollars". It's an agreement between the us and the saudis, to only sell oil in dollars, in exchange for protection. Leaders of other countries trying to change that, were suddenly found to be dictators, deposed and killed. d) Foreign countries hold dollars because otherwise they can't buy oil. e) The bank account doesn't hold it's "value" of 250k. It holds its nominal price.

Finally, because of the oil thing, the us has been happily printing dollars, and exporting its inflation to the whole world, stealing everybody.

Sorry, but you are the ignorant.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by afterburner on Saturday December 21, 2013 @08:41PM (#6948946)
"The value isn't stable"

Stability here means not volatile. USD is not volatile, nor are the other major currencies of the world. USD moves tiny amounts day to day and year to year versus other currencies.

You are of course referring to inflation. But inflation in the US has been a slow, gradual thing. The Fed was created 100 years ago. You might have been able to buy a lot more with $1000 in 1913, but you got paid a lot less. Since your salary, and taxes, and almost all goods, were paid for in USD, it didn't matter if all the numbers crept up together slowly.

To call USD unstable, while defending something like BTC or Dogecoin, seems somewhat ignorant, or at least misleading.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by twobits on Saturday December 21, 2013 @08:50PM (#6948973)
"Since your salary, and taxes, and almost all goods, were paid for in USD, it didn't matter if all the numbers crept up together slowly."

The key word is "together". They don't go up together. There is a time differential, with salaries trailing behind. People get constantly negatively affected this way.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by afterburner on Saturday December 21, 2013 @09:11PM (#6949027)
Let me put it this way: they go up together far, far, far more than whatever BTC or Dogecoin is doing.

Talking about very normal inflation in order to make make BTC/Dogecoin look bad is just weird. BTC dropped 50% in a day. And it could go up 100% tomorrow. That's volatility. Denying this just comes off as trolling.

Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by twobits on Saturday December 21, 2013 @09:53PM (#6949136)
I am not arguing for bitcoin or dogecoin. I am arguing against the dollar, and the notion that the dollar isn't backed (just) by force.
Re:How Dogecoin changed my perspective on cryptocurrency by minimax on Saturday December 21, 2013 @11:07PM (#6949303)
a) A predictable low rate of inflation is good for a currency.

b) Yes, that's my point.

c) I didn't say it was "valued in dollars" I said it was priced in dollars. Point me at a liquid oil futures contract not priced in USD that outpaces Brent or WTI and I'll retract my comment.

d) Wat.

e) I have $250k in the bank. Bank blows up. FDIC gives me back $250k. What don't you understand?