I had an inkling, as I think most people do, even the people who most benefit from the status quo. But, being born white and male into a middle class household granted me a tremendous amount of privilege to avoid ever having to see it too closely, without even trying very hard. Having been exposed to technology at a young age, and encouraged in that pursuit, granted me a near complete lack of need to actually work all that hard to survive. It's easy to believe in a meritocratic society when you believe you're meritorious enough to deserve all the good things that happen to you and to avoid all the bad things being inflicted on others.
Let's just say I've grown as a person over the past few years.
Which of the two parties that can plausibly win elections do you believe does not do terrible things?
I worked for years for third party politics. I was a card-carrying member of the LP. Worked for ballot access for both LP and the Green Party. If that's how you want to activate, go do it. I'm done with it. I see the system for what it is: Corrupt.
As long as we have first-past-the-post voting, laws stacked against any third party or independent candidates, and a complicit media, third parties are a pit into which people throw their passions and their energy and their money, with no resulting change.
You do what you gotta do, and I'm gonna do what I gotta do. What I gotta do is help build communities of resistance, and make it as expensive and inconvenient as possible for this shit to keep happening.
But given this situation, I also blame the voters. Polarization is pretty high. Voters readily pledge loyalty to the party line rather than individually consider the pros and cons of each platform's ideas. Voters don't realize that the less precommitted they are to their party, the more pressure they exert over congress. I.e. the less confident politicians are that the same demographics will reelect them, the more likely politicians will actually pay attention to the voters. pg has noticed this, among others.
Unfortunately, zealotry is a tough nut to crack. It's hardwired into human psychology. One can find it in politics, religion, sports, warfare, the dynamics of any group in general. And consciously or not, the parties encourage it (since each party's optimal signalling strategy is to differentiate themselves as much as possible). The media encourages this too, definitely consciously since it feeds their bottom line.
Given Indirect Democracy is here to stay, I think the worst problem is the lobby system. Not only has the power of the voters been diluted, but it's taken a backseat to that of the lobbyists. I'm not saying corporations are conspiratorially colluding to directly control congress, but each corporation's individual bribes certainly incentivizes the government's behavior, and arguably more so than the people's votes.
Not really. The fact that people are individuals who always make decisions at the margins means you can fall into a sort of network effect hysteresis trap. If you have Party X who gives you 20% of what you want and is polling at 49%, Party Y gives you 22% of what you want and is polling at 49%, and Party Z gives you 80% of what you want and is polling at 2%, if you believe the polls are accurate, you have a much larger expected gain from voting for Party Y instead of Party Z.
This is true even if the voter preferences are universal -- if e.g. everyone would get 15%-30% of what they want from X and Y, and 70-90% of what they want from Z.
I believe the odds of activism like this stopping fracking companies is actually very good. Which is why they are being met with police brutality. Suppose fracking protestors can reduce the likelihood of fracking companies to get local land exploitation permits from 95% to 90%, then that is a huge win and will save many wildlife areas.
It may not be "meaningful change" in the large scheme of things, but wins in many small fights compound and leads to bigger changes. Convincing people that they can't make a difference is the most efficient method for suppressing dissent.
It is called opening your eyes, cleaning them of the propaganda-rheum and seeing, wide awake the real structure of the world we live in.
I am a white male, totally privileged. Absolutely lucky to be that way by chance. And you know what - I know of this privilege, I did nothing for to earn.
I know, that the system is rigged like in a mobsters casino. And you know what - I believe it sucks real bad.
And people like you make it harder for everyone fighting for change. Or for people turning their backs on this system, robbing it of its support.
So please, do me a favor: Go home and play with your new shiny toys - what ever keeps you asleep in a world, that needs more people being awake and seeing for real.
Zeitgeist is a name to Marxism that doesn't suck. Anything green is left by definition. RT is official Russian Government propaganda channel. All the journalists you see there are FSB agents are have to cooperate with FSB.
At the same time US backed NGO in Russia are banned from receiving any money from the outside world and the Russian media are tightly controlled by Kremlin. There is no "voice of America" in Russia.
Why to fire bullets when soft skills of youth and intelligentsia indoctrination will do? It woke out great for them, hasn't it? We have a president Marxist, perfect product of the same forces in the educational system in the USA.
Just look how US becomes more and more like Russia as the years pass. I.e. oligarchs (the 1%), poor getting poorer, the police state, lack of democracy. The country is being russiaficated and nobody even notices what is the root of the evil. Genius!
It's a simple question. The post you replied to didn't even mention Zeitgeist or RT, it's you who equates "opening your eyes" with those.
Are you meaning to say that any and all outrage about totalitarianism is, like anything "left", planted by the KGB, and just a means to subvert the US, so it can be overtaken by totalitarianism? So what is your solution? A better police state to defend liberty?
It is disheartening that you realized this only after getting involved in activism. I think that in itself is a more significant indication of how hopeless the situation in America is. It underlines the main reason why serious social change is so difficult.
Put it simply: the government exists to protect the interests of corporations and wealthy people. Dissent of any kind challenges the status quo and therefore must be discouraged and quelled by any means necessary. The rights of "The People" (i.e. the poor) mean jack shit, because The People only exist to make the rich richer. This has been the case since the country's founding.
This is not to say that change is impossible. But, historically, the only time meaningful change has happened is when there was overwhelming social pressure. We aren't talking about petty (and for the most part meaningless) activism here and there. We're talking about social dissent of such magnitude that it threatens to become a revolution. Only in such times has the establishment allowed any sort of concession.