News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sweden fines pirate $650,000 for illegally sharing a sing... by lisper on Thursday December 19, 2013 @10:25AM (#6935120)
Speaking as a filmmaker myself, you are overlooking an important point: timing matters. A lot. Releasing a low-quality bootleg after a film has already been officially released through normal channels is very different from releasing a low-quality bootleg as the film's de-facto premiere. You only get one chance to make a first impression, and in this case the pirate took that opportunity away from the filmmaker.
Re:Sweden fines pirate $650,000 for illegally sharing a sing... by DanBC on Thursday December 19, 2013 @10:41AM (#6935239)
I was about to disagree with you and say that anyone downloading pre-release low quality products know that they're getting low quality product and know that the film will be better.

But then I remembered the people with beta OS access who file reviews for software that doesn't work with that beta product yet, even though the software producers are not allowed to incorporate those fixes yet.

Re:Sweden fines pirate $650,000 for illegally sharing a sing... by pbhjpbhj on Thursday December 19, 2013 @10:58AM (#6935386)
I don't think the Beta OS users software review situation carries over to the other context.

If it's a low quality then you're relying on the story. If the story of the movie is good then there's no harm - people will be more keen to see it. If the story is OK but the visuals are clearly harmed by the quality of the copy - then people will be more keen to see it in a better definition/encoding/format.

Some movies you just know you want to see at the cinema even if you've bought the DVD just because you know you'll appreciate the scale more. I've never watched a movie with a good story and said "I wouldn't watch that if the visuals were better".

YM[as a movie distributor]MV.

Re:Sweden fines pirate $650,000 for illegally sharing a sing... by MichaelGG on Thursday December 19, 2013 @01:12PM (#6936457)
Anecdote: I torrented Ponyo when it first came out, before the English version was available (it never had a theatrical release where my kids live), right during the Japanese theatre release. It was a terrible screener, complete with people getting up in the middle of it. And a rather funny attempt at subtitles. Even so, my kids watched it on repeat for weeks.
Re:Sweden fines pirate $650,000 for illegally sharing a sing... by anigbrowl on Thursday December 19, 2013 @01:40PM (#6936701)
anyone downloading pre-release low quality products know that they're getting low quality product and know that the film will be better

The OS parallel is somewhat similar, but as regards movies the reality if that with an unreleased film, you don't know that the official product will be better. Films with good stories or acting sometimes have shitty production values or run out of money at the post-production stage, leading to technical corners being cut. The general public is not literate in the technicalities of filmmaking so they're apt to misjudge things badly.

There's a truism in the industry that 'if your sound is bad, people will say the film has terrible lighting.' Most people don't know or think much about sound and so they literally can't articulate what they dislike if the sound is inferior in some way that isn't immediately obvious (bits missing or badly distorted). So if a poor-quality copy of an unreleased film hits the torrents and word goes around that it looks amateurish, most people are not going to say 'well hold on, are you sure that's a production issue and not just compression artifacts?'

Re:Sweden fines pirate $650,000 for illegally sharing a sing... by DanBC on Thursday December 19, 2013 @03:08PM (#6937451)
whoa wait. Most people don't care that much. see how long VHS lasted, or how awful US NTSC was.

When I say "not good" I mean with hard coded Mandarin subs or with people walking out half way through or someone eating popcorn next to the shakily held cam.

Re:Sweden fines pirate $650,000 for illegally sharing a sing... by anigbrowl on Thursday December 19, 2013 @08:10PM (#6939246)
That's not the point. They knew that VHS provided a poor copy of the original film. But if someone saw a copy on video before the movie was in theaters or on TV, they would almost certainly consider the whole thing to be of lower quality.