News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by eof on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @05:54PM (#6931487)
I just.. how does one get the gall to write like that?

> one that has unfortunately attracted outsized attention and investment before correcting any number of glaring security issues.

[links to bitcoin's own wiki about issues of which a small subset are security]

bitcoin has fixed many, many security issues over the years. most, if not all, of the remaining security issues are the same that any other tcp/ip talking protocol has and are based around DOS. straw man.

> Far from a “breakthrough”, Bitcoin is viewed by many technologists as an intellectual sinkhole.

bitcoin solves a previously 'unsolvable' problem. bootstraps multibillion dollar, zero trust, decentralized value transfer system and economy.

> A person’s sincere interest in Bitcoin is evidence that they are disconnected from the financial problems most people face while lacking a fundamental understanding of the role and function of central banking.

Or perhaps they are amateur historians: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hyperinflation#Examples_of_hype...

> If the broader Bitcoin experiment doesn’t implode, the currency will be regulated just as any other. In this best-case scenario for Bitcoin, what of the benefits Dixon claims?

Then it will be doomed, just like bit-torrent.. drat!

> If Bitcoin’s strength comes from decentralization, why pour millions into a single company? Ah, because Coinbase provides an “accessible interface to the Bitcoin protocol”, we’re told. We must centralize to decentralize, you see; such is the perverse logic of capital co-opting power. In order for Bitcoin to grow a thriving ecosystem, it apparently needs a US-based, VC-backed company that has “worked closely with banks and regulators to ensure that the service is safe and compliant”.

This quote right here is the tell that tips the hand. This has absolutely nothing to do with bitcoin and everything to do with outrageous barriers to entry into the payment market. Many have tried and been shut down.. coinbase is becoming successful because they are able to get over the arbitrary barrier of entry.

The author is saying "oh bitcoin will never succeed because real technologists think it's dumb and regulation will happen.. and even looky here they are centralizing anyway because they are hypocrites"

This is, from the most casual observation, asinine. a) bitcoin was bootstrapping itself well before coinbase came along. b) coinbase is succeeding because they are able to successfully battle the very regulations that many in the bitcoin community find burdensome in the first place.

> What’s unclear is the role that Bitcoin or a similar cryptocurrency could play in rectifying this dire situation [under and unbanked peoples].

What is clear is that the author is clearly removed from reality with regard to the unbanked who have access to cellphones but not banks; and insurmountable friction between local economies and more profitable ones. Many, many, many people have already used cryptocurrency in this regard and there is zero evidence that people are doing it less today than they were yesterday.

> I’ve enjoyed the thought experiment of Bitcoin as much as the next nerd, but it’s time to dispense with the opportunism and adolescent fantasies of a crypto-powered stateless future and return to the work of building technology and social services that meaningfully and accountably improve our collective quality of life.

So.. what does the author think here? Bitcoin is a fad and will have a similar fate to beanie-babies? It is over valued at the moment? Does the author really want to stake his reputation on the fact that cryptocurrencies are nothing more than 'an intellectual sinkhole?'

tl;dr; citation needed

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by jwesley on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:06PM (#6931563)
All the recent politically oriented attacks on Bitcoin are completely devoid of logical analysis and steeped in establishment dogma. They use name calling tactics like "play money" and "beenie babies fad" and scare tactics like "bubble" and "cesspool of criminal activity".

What none of these arguments ever address is the massive gains in economic efficiency that Bitcoin can clearly provide. It cuts out parasitic elements of the financial system that have grown like a giant parasite over the entire society.

The author claims that Bitcoin is steeped in nerd paternalism, but what about the epic paternalism of banks and regulators? Paternalism is their entire argument against Bitcoin, which basically amounts to "if people gain economic freedom, they will hurt themselves".

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by slg on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:18PM (#6931646)
>They use name calling tactics... It cuts out parasitic elements of the financial system that have grown like a giant parasite over the entire society.

I like your style, calling out the other side for using biased and loaded vocabulary and then you turn around and do exactly the same.

As the original article states, what some people view as a parasite on the system some people view as necessarily regulation and consumer protection. Just look at one of the other Coinbase stories currently on the front page [1]. Due to a mistake by Coinbase a customer was potentially looking at a loss in the five figures USD. The point of regulation is to make sure things like that don't happen and to have a course of action to correct them if they do happen. It isn't about "if people gain economic freedom, they will hurt themselves". It is about "if people gain too much economic freedom, they will hurt others".

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6929705

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by thisosound on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:23PM (#6931681)
Banking is the most heavily regulated industry there is. Regulators have offices inside banks, yet it didn't prevent 2008, HSBC and every other billion-dollar scandal.
Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by slg on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:28PM (#6931721)
Protections systems failing isn't a reason to completely get rid of them, it is a reason to reform them.

Using an analogy that has been mentioned elsewhere in this thread, think of your front door lock and your home. Would you get ride of all locks because someone robbed your house? Or would you invest in some other type of lock and security that might not have the same vulnerabilities?

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by thisosound on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @07:26PM (#6932055)
Regulations made by the state? Why wouldn't corporations pay lobbyists to make regulations shield them from competition and hurt consumers?
Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by TrevorJ on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:16PM (#6931635)
Even the media is complicit in this. NPR had a short story on Bitcoin this morning and made a point to say transactions were untraceable. One of the KEY points of Bitcoin is the public ledger. I'm amazed that as a journalist, you can get that so badly wrong.

Having said that, I think there are serious hurdles to overcome with Bitcoin, and the hype cycle and speculators are doing very little for the credibility of Bitcoin.

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by jwesley on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:23PM (#6931685)
Bitcoin doesn't need credibility. It just needs to work. Hype and speculators are a natural product of the energy gathering around the massive technical innovation and corresponding social movement that is Bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:27PM (#6931711)
> Bitcoin doesn't need credibility. It just needs to work.

What currencies need to work, more than anything else, is for people to believe they will work -- i.e., credibility.

That's what, ultimately, discussions of supposedly "intrinsic" value (which are somewhat dubious taken literally, value is, arguably, inherently extrinsic) of commodity currency and the reliability of the particular governments backing fiat currencies are about -- credibility. Because, ultimately, a currency like anything else is worth exactly what people are convinced that its worth.

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by jwesley on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:54PM (#6931897)
Fair enough, I see your point and completely agree that all currencies are based on belief. I guess that why I am all over the internet all day long trying to convince bitcoin is worth a shot.
Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by bmelton on Thursday December 19, 2013 @01:44AM (#6933257)
It's kind of naive to say that currencies are entirely based on belief, and I think you had it more right with your initial statement.

The only big distinction between the US Dollar and Bitcoin, from a practical perspective, is that Bitcoin doesn't have any armies willing to defend its status as legal tender. Even if everybody stopped 'believing' in the dollar, its buying power might tank, but it's still legally required to be accepted as payment for all debts, public and private. That legality is implemented through force of law, not good natured belief.

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by Crito on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:27PM (#6931705)
Bitcoin does need credibility in the real world.

Consider wire transfers. Those undeniably work, but their reputation has been tarnished to the point that most people who do business online will run the other direction if the other party so much as mentions the concept (see: craigslist).

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by TrevorJ on Thursday December 19, 2013 @03:04PM (#6937426)
Bitcoin does need credibility. Not in the abstract 'if everyone believes it is worth something then it is worth something' way, but in the sense that for Bitcoin to survive, it needs to be usable at a wide variety of merchants. Merchants aren't going to adopt some clown-car currency where a dozen or so flawed rumors come piling out whenever you mention the word Bitcoin to somebody.
Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by thisosound on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:24PM (#6931687)
I don't think they are intentionally trying to mislead people to favour Bitcoin.
Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by angersock on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:20PM (#6931663)
Show me the legal sectors powered by the bitconomy. Show me the heavy industry, the agriculture, the medicine, the consumer.

Show me the percent of BTC transactions used for actual business that a middle-class or poor person would conduct.

As it stands, the impression is just of a huge virtual casino, where you are at the table with either crazies or sharks from investing firms.

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by beat on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:10PM (#6931594)
Or someone else will hurt them.

I could get into my house faster at night if I didn't go through the trouble of locking and unlocking, too. Every security measure has overhead. "Massive gains in economic efficiency"? What's the tradeoff for this? If it's reduced security, then most people will say, "No thank you".

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by jwesley on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:13PM (#6931610)
People should have the freedom to make those security choices for themselves. People who are scared by the security issues of Bitcoin can avoid it, or only use it when the efficiency benefits are advantageous to them.
Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by kevingadd on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:08PM (#6931575)
If you're going to write a long, highly critical rant about a post containing dozens of outbound links to sources, you probably shouldn't end it with 'tl;dr; citation needed'. It implies that you didn't read the whole post before ranting about it, which isn't exactly an appropriate approach to discourse on Hacker News.

When did he ever even claim that Bitcoin will never succeed? It's certainly not in the article.

'clearly removed from reality' is strong criticism to direct at the author of a piece you seem not to have read to completion.

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by hammerzeit on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:09PM (#6931581)
You respond to the author's uncited claims and rhetorical flourishes with much of the same.

To pick at a few things: * I'm not sure about you, but I'd think that a bittorrent-like outcome is not a successful one. Bittorrent is certainly ubiquitous but its major use is still an illegal one; the analogous outcome for bitcoin would be one where its primary transactional value is on SilkRoad-like sites. Can you elaborate more on your analogy?

* You strongly imply that you have some sort of argument (and maybe evidence?) about how cryptocurrency will/could impact the unbanked in a positive way. Can you elaborate?

* Your last point seems to take it as a foregone conclusion that bitcoin is going to a high valuation and is here to stay. Do you really believe it's an inevitability at this point?

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by baddox on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:21PM (#6931669)
> Bittorrent is certainly ubiquitous but its major use is still an illegal one; the analogous outcome for bitcoin would be one where its primary transactional value is on SilkRoad-like sites.

That's not a good analogy, at least for me, because I think that copyright protection should not exist and that all drugs should be legal to buy, sell, consume, and manufacture.

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by eof on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:30PM (#6931728)
I think it is outrageous to consider bittorrent 'not successful'. Perhaps not ideal; but wide adoption, serves its purpose, clearly cannot be shutdown despite effort from some of the most powerful agencies on earth. I think bittorrent-like 'success' ('failure' if you prefer) is the worst-case scenario for bitcoin barring any flaws in the crypto.

The unbanked stand the most to gain from bitcoin. There are many, many reasons why people are unbanked, but by and large it is because they are poor and in poor economies. Sometimes it's because they owe banks money (as is the case for most unbanked in the usa). It seems to me self-evident how bitcoin impacts the unbanked.. they can now receive money where before they couldn't. There is no legal framework or local institution necessary to create a bitcoin wallet. You just do it with maths. I have personally sent bitcoin to an unbanked friend (owed money for years to a bank from an overdraft charge and enver dealt with it) who was able to get cash for it in a pinch. Western union doesn't work when one doesn't have an ID. http://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/1rjvby/why_i_really...

My last point was really meant to point out that the author isn't saying anything at all other than hand-wavy attacks. What is the authors stance? Does he think it will fail? Does he think it will succeed? He seem sto strongly imply that it is dumb, stupid, overhyped, etc etc; but stops short of actually making any type of reality-prediction.

I think cryptocurrencies are here to stay; bitcoin's likely, but im less "certain" of that. High valuation? Well.. eventually; but again that may end up being spread out across many cryptos rather than just bitcoin, but I do think it is about 100x as likely that bitcoin gets to 10k than 0. I wouldn't go so far as to say that it is obvious this is all true; but if you ask what I think, then yes.. I do think it is a 'foregone' conclusion that cryptocurrency will acheive s-curve adoption. Of course these things are not prove-able; and I don't have a crystal ball.. but distributed consensus to a limited digital asset is the perfect avenue for money. It clicked for me the first moment I read about it in 2010; and it clicked for many others in the same way. Other's took more convincing. I see about a 1000-1 ratio of people who go from thinking bitcoin is trash to believing in cryptocurrencies vs the other-way around. Literally every metric I have looked at over years points to continued increased adoption; continued minds being changed in the same direction and no sign of slowing down.

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by kiba on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:01PM (#6931539)
As far as regulations is concerned, it's actually too much and too little.

Too little in that overnight exchange operations are prone to shutdowns due to hacking, but too much in that regulations put up needless barrier to entry such that more exchanges exist outside the US than exist inside.

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by kevingadd on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:03PM (#6931547)
Alternately, the regulation is just distributed to the wrong places. Certainly there's a ton of regulation to go around, and a lot of it is insufferable, but somehow we didn't have enough regulation to stop the rampant greed and stupidity that caused our most recent financial crisis.
Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by craigyk on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:14PM (#6931618)
Bitcoin is a fad and will have a similar fate to beanie-babies? It is over valued at the moment? Does the author really want to stake his reputation on the fact that cryptocurrencies are nothing more than 'an intellectual sinkhole?'

yes yes and yes

Re:Bitcoin, Magical Thinking, and Political Ideology by Crito on Wednesday December 18, 2013 @06:54PM (#6931901)
Reputations are rarely staked on predicting the future in tech. You need a rather precise balance of prestige, wrongness, and volume of other work to have your reputation damaged in any significant way by being wrong.

Even cmdrtaco didn't really have his reputation trashed by "No wireless. Less space than a nomad. Lame."