Re:NSA phone surveillance program likely unconstitutional, f...
by mrobot on Monday December 16, 2013 @06:42PM
(#6918694)
Then what do they mean here, in this hearing, when they make such a big deal out of how Terry applies?
21:07, 23:04, 37:00 of first session link (morning session)
http://www.c-span.org/Events/Civil-Liberties-Board-Reviews-S...
My interpretation was that this was the justification for three-hop data imports based on phone selectors. Which, to me, is interpreting RAS as allowing for stopping and frisking an entire network of people to discover previously unknown operatives, based on suspicion of just one. If you try to imagine how that would look in real life, it's a bit scary. Actually, racial terry stops lean toward doing just that.
But what's going on here is massive, indiscriminate collection of information on people whom the government has no reason whatsoever to suspect of any crime. Not only that, the officer safety and evidence preservation justifications don't apply either. NSA surveillance isn't really comparable to conducting a Terry stop on the entire nation.