Re:NSA phone surveillance program likely unconstitutional, f...
by direwolf on Monday December 16, 2013 @05:42PM
(#6918363)
You're absolutely right that there are reasons to believe this might not stand up on appeal. However, the reasoning from Smith is hugely problematic with the advent of the cloud. Smith is based on what's called third-party doctrine: basically that the Fourth Amendment applies to your stuff that's in your possession. If you give your stuff to someone else, they don't have a Fourth Amendment right to it, and the government can take it without a warrant. Before the digital age, it was unusual to entrust sensitive private information to third parties. Most of what we had was kept on paper. Now, people put huge amounts of information in the hands of third parties, often without really realizing it. Extending third-party doctrine to all digital information would decimate online privacy.
This is where the future of Fourth Amendment jurisprudence is headed, and how the courts decide will have huge ramifications for the future of privacy. So again, you're right that there's significant precedent that must be overcome, but it's by no means a done deal. Even some of the conservative Justices in the recent Fourth Amendment cases seem pretty concerned.
Re:NSA phone surveillance program likely unconstitutional, f...
by declan on Monday December 16, 2013 @05:45PM
(#6918381)
There's been a lot of movement in the legal community (well, outside of FedGov) for rethinking Smith v. Maryland. This may give SCOTUS an opportunity. I doubt they'd go as far as today's opinion, but there's plenty of scholarship to say that Smith is outdated.
Compare to the decades of legal scholarship that eventually culminated in the Second Amendment being reinstated, kind of, by SCOTUS in the Heller and McDonald cases. What, it actually means the government can't ban guns? Gasp!
Re:NSA phone surveillance program likely unconstitutional, f...
by guelo on Monday December 16, 2013 @11:30PM
(#6919632)
IOW, you don't believe privacy should exist at all in the digital age. Others disagree.
Re:NSA phone surveillance program likely unconstitutional, f...
by rayiner on Tuesday December 17, 2013 @09:28AM
(#6921226)
The issue isn't whether privacy should exist in the digital age. The fact is that it doesn't, or at least not as we have understood it for all of these years. Something that dozens of sysadmins at Google can read is simply not private within traditional definitions. The real issue is whether we can create a practical pretense of privacy: treating data that isn't private, as a matter of fact, as private as a matter of law.
Basically, the judge found the on-point Supreme Court precedent to be inapplicable based on changes in technology in the intervening time:
"Leon wrote that the government was justifying its counterterrorism program based on a 34-year-old Supreme Court precedent that has been eclipsed by 'technological advances and a cell phone-centric lifestyle heretofore inconceivable.'"
It's very worthwhile to read the case that is discussed (Smith v. Maryland): http://scholar.google.com/scholar_case?case=3033726127475530...
Pay specific attention to the discussion starting at the end of page 743 ("Second, even if petitioner..."). That reasoning doesn't seem any less valid to me today than it was 34 years ago. It's an easy, clear rule: "private" means private, not "private but shared with my hundred closest sysadmin friends at AT&T or Google."