Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency
by rglullis on Sunday December 15, 2013 @06:31PM
(#6911611)
Why does it need to replace the dollar, though? Why can't it be just some form of hedge? Why can't I negotiatiate my salary to be 70% paid in USD, and the rest paid in some X BTC, with X being the remaining 30% at the day's rate of BTC/USD?
People keep saying that just because it's deflationary, they are never going to spend the coins. But as someone who grew up with hyperinflation (1980's Brazil) I can tell you that people still saved, they just used other currencies. I clearly remember my father buying dollars after getting his paycheck. Investment-wise it was a bad idea, but all people wanted was some sense of safety. When hyperinflation finally came to an end and I knew that my lunch at school would cost the same thing every week (instead of costing 20% more every Monday!), people started spending/selling their dollars.
The problem of BTC now is a problem of trust. And this lack of trust is due to the crazy volatility, not its deflationary nature. So, it is a chicken-and-egg problem. The more merchants you have accepting BTC, the more people will be able to spend their coins. Sure, the merchants buy be turning the 100% of their BTC into fiat right as they get them, but BTC could still be defined as the transaction currency.
People keep saying that just because it's deflationary, they are never going to spend the coins. But as someone who grew up with hyperinflation (1980's Brazil) I can tell you that people still saved, they just used other currencies. I clearly remember my father buying dollars after getting his paycheck. Investment-wise it was a bad idea, but all people wanted was some sense of safety. When hyperinflation finally came to an end and I knew that my lunch at school would cost the same thing every week (instead of costing 20% more every Monday!), people started spending/selling their dollars.
The problem of BTC now is a problem of trust. And this lack of trust is due to the crazy volatility, not its deflationary nature. So, it is a chicken-and-egg problem. The more merchants you have accepting BTC, the more people will be able to spend their coins. Sure, the merchants buy be turning the 100% of their BTC into fiat right as they get them, but BTC could still be defined as the transaction currency.