News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by maratd on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:08PM (#6911144)
Finally, somebody with a basic understanding of economics decides to chime in. It is not possible for bitcoin to be a currency due to its deflationary nature.

Bitcoin might be an interesting investment vehicle, a storage of value, but something that will at some point replace the dollar? No.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by lettergram on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:24PM (#6911244)
Actually, I studied economics in the past and technically you can have a currency which is deflationary in nature, it just does not make it ideal. The Dollar has a similar disadvantage in many respects due to inflation.

It would actually be better to have some sort of currency which expands based on the number of transactions... There's a pretty large theory behind it and I out line some of it on my blog, where I also explain how a crypto currency can "potentially" work[1] or you could read one of Friedman[2] or Knights[3] books.

[1] http://austingwalters.com/the-currencies-of-tomorrow/ [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Milton_Friedman [3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frank_Knight

Further, economic system and in turn the manipulation of the Dollar in the U.S. is based largely off Kaynes work, which for the most part (we now know) is an inaccurate portrial of economics.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by zanny on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:29PM (#6911283)
This. Bitcoin is digital gold. Once it proves itself, we will probably transition into something like peercoin, or more appropriately an unimplemented proof-of-work payment scheme that calculates the payments not only on difficulty but also on the transaction rate across the last several blocks. You would want a median 1% inflation, but if exchange slows significantly (indicating money hoarding) you want the inflation rate to increase. If too many transactions are happening, you would turn down the inflation rate to compensate.

The only real "hard" part is preventing spoofing the system by moving money back and forth between accounts to fake economic activity, so you would have to put weights on idle money so that money that has been stationary longer has more impact than money changing hands, to avoid tampering.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by fragsworth on Sunday December 15, 2013 @07:12PM (#6911762)
I strongly suspect that the Bitcoin developers and mining community will eventually choose to inflate the currency. Not for any economic reasons, but rather to provide the funding for a large and secure mining network, because future transaction fees might prove to be insufficient.

That 21 million number is not set in stone, and will change if there is a need for it.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by zanny on Sunday December 15, 2013 @07:45PM (#6911897)
That still doesn't account for the fact that having a mathematical model for inflation is hugely advantageous for a currency. Current btc should be inflating at upwards of 10% considering how little money movement there is in the network due to the investment hoarding.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by maratd on Sunday December 15, 2013 @11:06PM (#6912798)
> That still doesn't account for the fact that having a mathematical model for inflation is hugely advantageous for a currency.

This is hugely important and obvious to anybody who has taken Econ 101.

Everybody knows this.

So why would you invent a currency that was deflationary in nature due to an artificial cap? Well, once you realize that the guy(s) who invented it are holding 10% of it, you'll have your answer.

Bitcoin is in a huge bubble at the moment. My only hope is that this bubble bursts before the inventors can cash out. Oh, sweet justice.

After the collapse, there is every reason to believe that Bitcoin will become something genuinely useful or at the very least, inspire something that will be useful.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by fragsworth on Monday December 16, 2013 @12:45AM (#6913122)
Deflation is only a threat because of fractional-reserve lending. The world ends up owing itself more than it actually has in currency, and it collapses in on itself in a massive disaster if and when the currency deflates.

Fractional reserve lending of bitcoins seems highly unlikely to happen any time soon, if ever. And if it does start happening, it is likely to be made quickly illegal, because the system simply won't work.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by ryanjshaw on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:48PM (#6911376)
Are we even able to analyse Bitcoin as we would fiat currencies or precious metals? Why is this assumption left unstated and unanalysed?

Cryptocurrencies have several interesting properties that these traditional mediums of exchange do not, for example:

- the supply is fixed and precisely known at any point in time, with very little chance of that ever changing by unilateral decision (e.g. politics, war); surely this will factor into future decisions to price goods and services, in the same way businesses already factor inflation into their business models

- low transaction costs for high value cross-border payments could see a niche use that no fiat currency can compete with (unless you somehow believe there will be a unified global real-time gross settlement system or the like any time soon)

- settlement times could also see a niche use that no fiat currency can compete with (if it works, and your transaction is confirmed in seconds/minutes/hours rather than days as with ETFs, then I foresee people using it for certain value transactions)

- accessibility (just look at M-PESA in Kenya -- everybody has cellphones, but moving physical cash around is expensive and dangerous)

- up until all the coins are mined, and probably for some time thereafter, the value will be quite volatile; after that, however, value will pretty much reflect real economic activity and volatility will be less predictable -- why is there this obsession over the present volatility? All the coins will be mined within a fixed time frame provided 1 person continues mining, which is almost a certainty, and eventually the price will have to stabilise.

I fear the article is comparing apples and oranges. Maybe the author just wants to sow FUD while he buys some cheap BTC :)

Don't get me wrong - I have my doubts that Bitcoin has what it takes (among other things, I think the initial unequal distribution of wealth is a serious problem), but cryptocurrencies in general are likely to be a successful and inevitable medium of exchange at some point in the future.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by maxerickson on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:53PM (#6911409)
It's merely very unlikely that the supply changes. Current accepted wisdom is that rewriting the client to produce more coins would fracture the currency. Future accepted wisdom may change.

It's also hard to beat cash for settlement times.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by ryanjshaw on Sunday December 15, 2013 @06:04PM (#6911479)
Rewriting the client is not sufficient. You need to convince everybody to run the new client. I don't see that happening as easily as you presume. It is highly likely that cryptobanks will come into place in the future (cryptocurrencies are not very layperson friendly right now), with traditional contractual law ensuring the cryptobanks do not suddenly change the rules under client's noses.

I disagree regarding cash. You're making a blanket statement and I'm saying there are niches where cash sucks.

Aside from the M-PESA example I've given, another is overseas travel. Cash can be a big waste of time - depending on your local laws, obtaining forex prior to departure can be a pain (e.g. in South Africa), the withdrawal fees are exorbitant and often unclear, the risk of theft significant, you have to be aware of local exchange rates and if you want to save money you have to be aware of the exchange rate of the cash you have on hand vs. your debit and/or credit card processor etc., then when you get back (again in South Africa at least) you have to resell your forex within 30 days, and you also have limitations on how much you can purchase in a year.

Another is cash payments over a certain value -- again in South Africa, walking around with more than a certain amount of cash in your pocket is asking for trouble.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by maxerickson on Sunday December 15, 2013 @06:09PM (#6911510)
Yes, I understand you would have to get widespread acceptance of the new client. I don't think it is likely (hence 'fracture the currency').

I didn't say cash was always better than bitcoin, I just pointed out that it is very hard to beat on settlement times (and you revised your comment to say fiat currency rather than cash). Maybe I replied to an early draft.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by clin_ on Sunday December 15, 2013 @06:03PM (#6911477)
Why are people replying to this post like OP is some kind of authority? It doesn't sound like he "studied economics" so much as he took a course.

Of course you can have a deflationary currency. The problem is that people won't spend it. The dollar is not naturally inflationary. Instead, the fed allows for a controlled amount of inflation every year to encourage spending. Automatically managed currencies like you discuss still suffer from inflexibility—as our understanding of monetary economics adjusts, or qualities of the economy change (as with the change in velocity of money during the 80's-90's), it would be difficult to adjust the algorithm to better stabilize the money supply.

More importantly, cryptocurrencies are region agnostic. I take it you learned about optimal currency area in your studies? Any arbitrary threshold would risk having inconsistent effects in different places. Expansion may be just the thing to encourage additional transactions in a recessionary region, but may encourage rapid inflation elsewhere. The result is always high volatility, making it unfit as a store of value.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by philwelch on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:28PM (#6911271)
I think some variety of Friedman coin would be ideal. You even have the information necessary to implement it because Bitcoin mining is already based on blockchain data, right?
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by rglullis on Sunday December 15, 2013 @06:31PM (#6911611)
Why does it need to replace the dollar, though? Why can't it be just some form of hedge? Why can't I negotiatiate my salary to be 70% paid in USD, and the rest paid in some X BTC, with X being the remaining 30% at the day's rate of BTC/USD?

People keep saying that just because it's deflationary, they are never going to spend the coins. But as someone who grew up with hyperinflation (1980's Brazil) I can tell you that people still saved, they just used other currencies. I clearly remember my father buying dollars after getting his paycheck. Investment-wise it was a bad idea, but all people wanted was some sense of safety. When hyperinflation finally came to an end and I knew that my lunch at school would cost the same thing every week (instead of costing 20% more every Monday!), people started spending/selling their dollars.

The problem of BTC now is a problem of trust. And this lack of trust is due to the crazy volatility, not its deflationary nature. So, it is a chicken-and-egg problem. The more merchants you have accepting BTC, the more people will be able to spend their coins. Sure, the merchants buy be turning the 100% of their BTC into fiat right as they get them, but BTC could still be defined as the transaction currency.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by jpttsn on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:20PM (#6911212)
That proves itself: A deflationary currency can't replace the dollar, because the dollar isn't deflationary.

However, the present system is perhaps not the only possible system. Some alternative schools of thought in economics see possibilities beyond systematic inflation.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by philwelch on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:24PM (#6911246)
That's like saying "some alternative schools of thought in biology see possibilities beyond evolution" or "some alternative schools of thought in climatology see possibilities beyond anthropogenic climate change".
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by jpttsn on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:37PM (#6911324)
And in astronomy, to possibilities beyond the geocentric universe.

Alternative theories can be wrong or right. Don't oppose them because they're alternative: oppose them where the evidence compels you to.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by philwelch on Sunday December 15, 2013 @06:29PM (#6911600)
Done and done. Unfortunately, I've already used up my lifetime allowance of time spent arguing with cranks, so I have zero time left for goldbugs.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by fthssht on Sunday December 15, 2013 @07:28PM (#6911817)
Oh man that sucks. Good thing nobody cares about your close minded egotistical arrogant thoughts anyway.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by fthssht on Sunday December 15, 2013 @07:29PM (#6911825)
Right on! The established theories are all 100% right.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by fthssht on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:21PM (#6911222)
There's a fixed quantity of it like gold and gold worked as a currency for a very long time. If Bitcoin fails its certainly not because of its "deflationary nature." What you think it a basic understanding of economics is obvious nonsense. How could people have it so twisted?
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by chad_oliver on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:29PM (#6911282)
It also failed as a currency in a very bad way. Part of the reason why the Great Depression was so bad is because most countries still used (or used the mindset associated with) the gold standard. Monetary policy is a very good way of stabilising the economy, and any currency which removes monetary policy as a tool is not likely to be stable in the long term.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by fthssht on Sunday December 15, 2013 @07:23PM (#6911804)
You're dead wrong but even if you werent the fact that it worked for thousands of years completely invalidates the author's point.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by gnaritas on Sunday December 15, 2013 @06:11PM (#6911517)
> There's a fixed quantity of it like gold and gold worked as a currency for a very long time.

And that time has passed, the world moved on.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by fthssht on Sunday December 15, 2013 @07:26PM (#6911811)
"There are three eras of currency: Commodity-based, politically-based, and now, math-based." - Chris Dixon,
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by gnaritas on Sunday December 15, 2013 @07:33PM (#6911842)
With this I'm in complete agreement.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by kordless on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:24PM (#6911243)
Understanding economics does not necessarily provide insight into understanding cryptocurrencies. That's been evident by the wildly varying posts about the topic over the last few months.

Regardless of the nice graphs, Bitcoin is currently NOT deflationary. Every 10 minutes 25 new coins are minted and placed into circulation. The rate of new Bitcoin creation will be halved every four years until there are 21 million BTC in circulation. Additionally, there are a slew of other cryptocurrencies with varying degrees of mining rates - some have a constant rate of inflation built into them. Time will tell which ones are adopted.

The miners who are minting these new coins are helping secure the currency (adding value) are putting work into the system by way of capital expenditure on equipment and costs associated with power. They expect a return on their investments and are probably the determining factor to the current price.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by philwelch on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:26PM (#6911257)
That's not what inflation means. Inflation is when prices rise because the growth in currency outstrips the growth in economic activity. If the growth in currency is less than the growth in economic activity, even if it's still >0, prices will drop, which is the definition of deflation.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by nhaehnle on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:30PM (#6911289)
Even that is a problematic take on it, because you ignore savings and what MVPQ people call the "velocity of money".

When firms like Apple sit on hoards of cash, the amount of currency can grow quite a bit faster than the economy without inflation.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by philwelch on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:32PM (#6911298)
Yeah, the actual definition relies solely upon whether prices rise or fall in aggregate, for reasons that can be solely attributed to monetary factors. Which is a bitch to figure out, because you have all these libertarians screaming about how gasoline and groceries are more expensive, therefore inflation, when really it's because petroleum is expensive.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by gnaritas on Sunday December 15, 2013 @06:07PM (#6911497)
> Bitcoin is currently NOT deflationary.

Incorrect, demand alone has made it hugely deflationary; if everything were priced in Bitcoin right now, prices would have to be adjusted downward constantly, that's deflation. Money supply inflation is not inflation which generally refers to the overall prices of goods and services rising and money supply deflation is not deflation which is the fall of overall prices of goods and services. Bitcoin is currently hugely deflationary.

Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by fragsworth on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:27PM (#6911265)
The author is wrong on several points. The great depression was caused by an overestimation of how much the currency would inflate as a result of the Federal Reserve's lending practices, along with an expectation that the gold standard would be returned. It was an overprinting and contraction of fiat, deflation of which was totally unexpected, that caused it.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by knodi on Sunday December 15, 2013 @05:13PM (#6911173)
This! Bitcoin is an investment and good one at that for short term gains. Its the tulip craze with bytes.
Re:Why Bitcoin Will Never Be a Currency by maratd on Sunday December 15, 2013 @11:19PM (#6912846)
> Its the tulip craze with bytes.

Oh, you! Tulips were better. You at least got the pretty flower after all was said and done.