News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gmail blows up e-mail marketing by caching all images on ... by EGreg on Thursday December 12, 2013 @05:21PM (#6897690)
Google does SPAM filtering and has no obligation to deliver those messages. It can throttle its acceptance of messages from the same IP block. How is this different than any other (distributed) DNS attack mitigation?
Re:Gmail blows up e-mail marketing by caching all images on ... by 300bps on Friday December 13, 2013 @06:58AM (#6900121)
It can throttle its acceptance of messages from the same IP block

There are literally tens of millions of computers infected with malware making them part of a botnet (ex: http://www.csmonitor.com/USA/2011/0629/Biggest-ever-criminal...). The cost to hire 1 million of these computers (all with unique IP addresses) to send emails out is trivial. You'd be shocked how cheap it is.

Now here's the thing... SPAM is pretty easy to spot because someone is trying to sell something. In this case, you're not trying to sell anything. You just need Google to download things. So you send an email with "Vacation Pics" in it. Sure, Google could filter them out but they're all from unique IP addresses from home computers across the country/world and they aren't trying to sell anything. They probably could filter out some of them at the cost of filtering out a lot of false positive legitimate mail.

Internet security is complex - you seem to think otherwise.

Re:Gmail blows up e-mail marketing by caching all images on ... by thaumaturgy on Thursday December 12, 2013 @05:44PM (#6897802)
Snowshoe spam is pretty common now, with a lot of the larger networks mixing in spammers with legitimate traffic (lookin' at you, ovh.com).

As it is right now, spam is just mostly a drain on network and human resources.

This attack would also target storage. Google has enormous amounts of storage, so I've no idea whether it would be effective against them or not. But, it would be very effective against any smaller service providers that tried to do the same image caching thing (which so far seems to be a roundly bad idea, IMO).

It would also open up the possibility of using Google as an attacker to take down other sites. If Google's servers immediately requested the image for caching, then just send out a few million messages to Google addresses, each one with a unique URL pointing to some big image file on some site you want to take down. Most sites will accept a query string after an image URL, so ... bob's yer uncle. As it is now, this isn't an effective attack because you need to get people to actually open up the email message and then click "Display images", all within a short period of time.

Re:Gmail blows up e-mail marketing by caching all images on ... by ivanca on Thursday December 12, 2013 @06:06PM (#6897915)
Nope; still the same filtering; they are not going to cache things detected as SPAM; so an attacker would have to fool the anti-spam algorithm first... good luck with that!
Re:Gmail blows up e-mail marketing by caching all images on ... by thaumaturgy on Thursday December 12, 2013 @06:22PM (#6897990)
I wasn't describing a new tactic for spamming, I was describing possible new tactics for targeted attacks. They're different things.
Re:Gmail blows up e-mail marketing by caching all images on ... by ivanca on Thursday December 12, 2013 @06:24PM (#6897996)
An attack that relies on the possibility of being able to send millions of emails without being detected as spam; so it is unlikely to succeed.
Re:Gmail blows up e-mail marketing by caching all images on ... by thaumaturgy on Thursday December 12, 2013 @06:45PM (#6898094)
Gmail has probably the best spam filtering in the world, but you seem to think it's flawless, and it's not. I just now signed into my old Gmail account for the first time in ages. There's spam in there, and recent too. Roughly one per day by the looks of it -- messages that aren't newsletters, or from previous contacts, or anything that I signed up for.

And spammers aren't even that smart, they're just numerous and financially motivated.

If somebody wanted to annoy someone else with this, they could.

And, again, even if this doesn't work against Google directly, it certainly would work against other service providers who decide to follow Google's lead.

Heck, just look at the recent popularity of the WhatsApp spam that spread malware to tons of people (including Cryptolocker in some cases), or the "Secure Document" phish that made the rounds in Gmail in September.

Re:Gmail blows up e-mail marketing by caching all images on ... by ivanca on Thursday December 12, 2013 @07:35PM (#6898341)
Ok I see your point; but I want to add that one of the reasons your old account has spam is because you don't use it; I don't know what algorithm they are using but it certainly relies on usability data; I don't know exactly but could be: what language you usually speak in; what hours of the day you receive and read important email, what subjects you read about, etc etc.
Re:Gmail blows up e-mail marketing by caching all images on ... by thaumaturgy on Thursday December 12, 2013 @08:23PM (#6898510)
Yeah, that could be. I have to spend a significant part of my time now dealing with spam (sysadmin), and Gmail's handling of spam is years ahead of most of the tools I have available.