News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by millzlane on Thursday December 12, 2013 @11:12AM (#6895175)
Let let me explain why one might watermark their photos. I sell aftermarket car parts for JDM vehicles. Most of these products don't have images from the manufacturer. Why? Well there lots of reasons but it boils down to different configurations. It would be too time consuming to take an image of every product in every configuration for every model they sell. So they may have a generic picture of an exhaust system, that may or may not be the product you're paying for.

I know that consumers like to see what they buy. I want to have pictures of every image I sell. To do that, I need to order 1 of everything I plan to sell so I can take photos of each item. As you can see it gets pretty costly. I'm spending time, money and effort, to give the best possible shopping experience. All while letting the customer know I have a product in my hands that my competitors don't.

My competitors on the other hand. They just signed up for a new drop shipping account with the same distributor but guess what? They have no images of the items they sell and have no capital to order the item in. So where do they get those images? You guessed it, from everyone else.

When I first started I remember giving discounts to customers who would allow me to open their package and take showcase photos before sending them. I would be upset if someone used my photos without my permission. I don't have time or money to police the internet. So I protect my investment through the use of the water mark. If not, it'd be like Ebay where you see 40 different sellers using the same exact product image, atrocious.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by Pxtl on Thursday December 12, 2013 @11:22AM (#6895238)
Funny how we destroy file-formats and screw up the very HTML standard itself and muck up YouTube all to protect video and audio content, but nobody gives a crap about images and we're left with a Wild West. Look how many above-board publicly-run sites are based on the trading of copyrighted image content. Ask a webcomic author what they think of Funnyjunk and the like.

I don't know what the right solution is, but it seems absurd that one form of copyrighted content lives completely without protection because that's the content that's created by small businesses instead of global megacoporations.

That said, Google probably could at least protect your image content from being filched by other users within the Google platform if you could "register" your image with them as the original - they have image-matching algorithms to enforce that.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by ivanca on Thursday December 12, 2013 @05:12PM (#6897647)
That's already the case; they see who posted the image first and it scores "SEO points" for that.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by TrevorJ on Friday December 13, 2013 @11:09AM (#6901203)
I don't care about Google fun bucks (Tm) or whatever reward they feel is fair for forcing me to not protect my images. I should be able to protect the images I created.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by RokStdy on Thursday December 12, 2013 @11:20AM (#6895225)
Thanks for the interesting perspective. This doesn't help you since you already have a catalog of photos, but I wonder if you might get around this rule if you took pictures of <part> on a backdrop with your logo repeated. That way, sure, I could try to crop it to get rid of your logo, but if it's an irregular shape I'd have to Photoshop your stuff out. Or maybe a sticker with your logo on an unimportant part of the product.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by Pxtl on Thursday December 12, 2013 @11:24AM (#6895252)
That does restrain them a bit though - with a watermark, they can batch-change the nature or obtrusiveness of the watermark, they can resell the unmarked images, they can update their logo freely.

None of that can be done with the real-world-logo appearing on the product.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by sentenza on Thursday December 12, 2013 @12:56PM (#6895872)
It might be possible to use a greenscreen, though.

You do your photoshoot with a greenscreen in the background/part of the background, then digitally replace the grenscreen with your logo. Since your logo and the product are mixed at the edge pixels, it will look crappy if cropped, whereas you yourself have the greenscreen originals and can change the background whenever and however you like.

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by Pxtl on Thursday December 12, 2013 @01:10PM (#6895975)
If you wanted to be really super-fancy you could apply some image recognition decals to the greenscreen that would allow a program to determine the orientation of the platform below or background behind the object. Then you can actually do a more sophisticated projection of your logo onto the surface and keep the shadows provided by your subject. But at this point it's gotten a little sophisticated for a small seller.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by millzlane on Thursday December 12, 2013 @11:26AM (#6895267)
That's a good idea. Instead of watermarking the images, silkscreen our logo on the backdrop. I wonder if that qualifies as "promotional text".
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by mark-r on Thursday December 12, 2013 @03:43PM (#6897112)
Reading the original post, this would run afoul of the rules too.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by jborden13 on Thursday December 12, 2013 @04:31PM (#6897418)
The inverse holds true here as well. Manufacturers are constantly battling with unauthorized & shady retailers to maintain the integrity of the images - as well as with the 2 major platforms that own eCommerce and online product advertising. This is seriously some anti-competitive action, on the whole. See the Amazon model where they monitor the products and retailers on the platform, identify the best sellers and then set their systems to always be the cheapest and always win on integrated services. Eventually no one can compete and only AMZN shareholders will win in the long run.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by wahsd on Friday December 13, 2013 @05:25PM (#6903252)
Just curious are you watermarking to specifically deter unauthorized use of the image?

I ask because I could see how you could use steganography to hide copyright information or simply add the watermark in such a manner that you would only be able to detect/reveal it by a specific method of color alterations. That way you would still have a case if you needed to take legal action.

edit: I just realized that will probably never be answered so does anyone else feel like giving some perspective?

Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by prodigal_erik on Thursday December 12, 2013 @02:42PM (#6896595)
Could you send the FTC after competing "merchants" who are advertising products they not only don't have in stock but have literally never seen? It sounds like a scam, and I wouldn't knowingly give money to an outfit like that.
Re:Google Shopping: Upload Your Content Without Watermarks o... by msbarnett on Thursday December 12, 2013 @02:55PM (#6896696)
> Could you send the FTC after competing "merchants" who are advertising products they not only don't have in stock but have literally never seen? It sounds like a scam, and I wouldn't knowingly give money to an outfit like that.

I hate to break it to you, but a HUGE amount of e-commerce sites are nothing more than front-ends to drop-shipping accounts with suppliers. This is the dominant pattern in the industry. Actually holding your own inventory is a rarity that would put you at a major competitive disadvantage.

Unless you're dealing with a very large, well-capitalized site, or a company that makes their own product, you're almost certainly dealing with this kind of store.