Re:California Arrests the Owner of a Revenge Porn Site
by tn13 on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @05:09PM
(#6891189)
I am curious to know if I can make my girlfriend sign a document giving me the absolute rights of all the photographs I might click of hers. [I am only hypothetically speaking.]
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:California Arrests the Owner of a Revenge Porn Site
by jimktrains2 on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @05:36PM
(#6891349)
You own the rights to any photo you take, regardless of who is in it.
However, you can't use the subject to advertise or endorse something w/o their consent iirc (ianal).
Re:California Arrests the Owner of a Revenge Porn Site
by grecy on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @07:00PM
(#6891829)
>You own the rights to any photo you take, regardless of who is in it.
Are you sure? I remember reading about a bunch of lawsuits against people that had taken photos of iconic shapes (coke bottle, certain cars) and the maker of the iconic shape claimed copyright. (I can't find a link right now)
Re:California Arrests the Owner of a Revenge Porn Site
by jimktrains2 on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @11:05PM
(#6892735)
How was that image being used was probably important in those cases.
Re:California Arrests the Owner of a Revenge Porn Site
by grecy on Thursday December 12, 2013 @03:58PM
(#6897215)
Are you saying that even though I own the copyright to an image I can't use it however I want? (Genuinely confused)
Re:California Arrests the Owner of a Revenge Porn Site
by jimktrains2 on Thursday December 12, 2013 @09:43PM
(#6898761)
Yes. You can't use the subject of the image to advertise or otherwise promote something without the subjects consent, but the image itself is your property.
You could take a picture of a random person in public and publish it in a gallery, but you couldn't use that image to sell your brand of pop, iirc and ianal. Sorry I can't find a good link right now.
Re:California Arrests the Owner of a Revenge Porn Site
by gamblor956 on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @07:18PM
(#6891911)
You own the rights to the photo...but that does not necessarily give you the rights to the object(s) photographed, or in the case of a person, to their likeness.
Re:California Arrests the Owner of a Revenge Porn Site
by roel_v on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @05:42PM
(#6891393)
The issue in this case was not about the rights on these pictures, it was about what was done with them, apart from IE issues. You can't enter into a contract that will let you do illegal things to somebody. So you can't enter into a contract that will let you extort her. Of course once a contract exists that says you can do anything you want with the pictures, the bar for being 'extortion' will be much higher. It will still be contextually defined by a judge though. It all depends on the exact circumstances.
Re:California Arrests the Owner of a Revenge Porn Site
by cookingrobot on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @06:38PM
(#6891709)
It's called a model release.