For one thing, energy density needs to improvement by an order of magnitude to make mass application useful, and the average lifetime of the battery I would say would have to increase 2-3x. Batteries are expensive to manufacture and the ecological impact of disposal is also extremely high - better to make longer-lasting batteries than cheap crap.
"Lithium Ion batteries are classified by the federal government as non-hazardous waste and are safe for disposal in the normal municipal waste stream," says Kate Krebs at the National Recycling Coalition. http://bit.ly/wS344
In general, throwing away stuff that isn't naturally occuring in the eco system is often bad, and sometimes too much of something natural can be bad too. But blanket statements that something is bad don't help. The battery system would be replacing something else, like a petrol driven engine, which also has an environmental impact and is much less efficient.
Using electrolysis, right? How pure must the water be? One can't use seawater, as that would produce HCl instead of H2, right? Desalination consumes a lot of power, but it may be an option if enough hydroelectric / wind / solar power is generated.
I wonder if one could use the water stored in the ice caps for electrolysis. An enormous source of relatively pure water could perhaps be an economical and scalable source of H2. Just speculating.
Energy density of 1 kilogram of hydrogen = ~1 US gallon of gas. A gallon of water has ~2/(2+16) * 3.8kg =0.4 kg.
So ~2.4 gallons of water + (ton of energy) ~= 1 gallon of gas.
PS: Bulk fresh water still tends to run at thousandths of a cent per gallon in most areas. But, 14 kilowatt hours desalinates 1000 gallons of seawater so 14 watts per gallon which is a tiny fraction of the energy needed to split water into hydrogen and oxygen.
The marginal price of water in San Jose is around 0.3 cents/gallon. However, the "connection charge" and various taxes and fees end up doubling the "as delivered" cost.
However, the connection charge is just highway robbery if you are really paying that per gallon. They might also be adding the sewer system charges based on your water usage.
PS: The average American uses ~90 gallon /day * 0.3 = 27cents per day * 365 = 100$ / year which is hardly breaking the bank.
> However, the connection charge is just highway robbery if you are really paying that per gallon.
San Jose city govt uses services to pay off various folk.
> They might also be adding the sewer system charges based on your water usage.
I just looked - the sewage charge is on the property tax bill.
The "water source" report that they send every year mentions ground and well water. It does not mention desalinization.
H2 is a complicated/inefficient/explosive way to move energy, but it's very clean (as a energy transfer medium). At the moment, the way H2 is generated is very unclean (using Methane, or using the power from coal and other dirty power sources).
But if the origin of the energy is totally clean (hydroelectric, wind, solar), you can use that energy to break water down, then transfer that hydrogen in to the vehicle. Breaking down water is not so efficient, but it's still clean. I think this is the ideal (maybe dreamlike) goal of the H2 Camp.