News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by thenmar on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @09:37PM (#6885522)
Obviously it's not that simple. We need massive reform in public education and affordability of healthcare (such as rehab facilities) before sane drug laws can possibly be implemented.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by pstuart on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:17PM (#6885671)
Actually we don't. Those would be nice to have, but the current drug policy has failed horribly. The meth "epidemic" is a perfect illustration of this: it's illegal but it hasn't stopped those that want to use it from using it.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by thenmar on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:27PM (#6885710)
So your solution to the meth "epidemic" (scare quotes yours) is to... legalize meth?
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by pstuart on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:56PM (#6885825)
I've got legal speed in my medicine cabinet that my doctor prescribed to me for ADHD. I also have legal opiates that my doctor prescribed for pain. I don't want or need your approval for what I put in my body.

I also have a brother dead from a heroin overdose. It's illegal and it didn't stop him. Sanctimonious nanny staters like you think you're protecting people but you're just supporting organized crime, death and ruined lives by pushing this into the shadows.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by steve19 on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:49PM (#6885948)
The fact that so many people mess themselves up on legal amphetamines and opiates is unfortunately why there is so much opposition to legalizing drugs.

I don't care what you put in your body (legal or otherwise), its your body and your life and you are compelled to do so for reasons I might not understand, but if I found a loved one was taking a cocktail of amphetamines and opiates I would do everything in my power to see they got the help and support they needed to get off it.

Legalizing amphetamines would trigger major societal problems. What percentage of HN would feel the need to consume it in order to compete at school, the office or the market.

Nanny state? You make it sound so simple. Drugs are just chemicals. Why not say all chemicals should be legalized. What about RDX (a military-grade explosive)? Is the nanny state getting in the way of me having a good time on private property blowing stuff up? I can safely use military weapons, so why can't I purchase them privately?

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by nate_meurer on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @12:10AM (#6886022)
Your last sentence is one big bait-and-switch. Your simple possession of RDX is an entirely different matter from "blowing stuff up". I can blow stuff up just as easily with ammonium nitrate (used by the ton for fertilizing farmland) and diesel. Both of those are legal, but perhaps you'd rather they not be? You know, just in case...

The drug war has not criminalized harmful behavior caused by drugs. That would make far too much sense. The drug war criminalizes the mere possession of drugs, regardless of any actual harmful behavior. Then the nanny state corrects your behavior by giving you a criminal record.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by vasilipupkin on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @07:56AM (#6887382)
If you make it easier and cheaper to purchase drugs by making it legal, it is natural to expect that more people would use and purchase them, on the margin. Is that what we want?
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by inDigiNeous on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @08:37AM (#6887529)
People are going to get wasted anyhow. Why not offer legal alternatives to alcohol (which just makes us stupid and dead) and tobacco.

The only reason I see why cannabis is not legal yet is because it threatens the medical industry in a big way. Cannabis, although easily becomes an addiction, is also a big medicine for many things.

When people start to realize this in big quantities, the medical companies are going to get worried, as their prescription drugs that may cause coma and death, will not be used so much anymore.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by nate_meurer on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @11:22AM (#6888415)
Your question is bit of a non-sequitur, but any answer would have to depend on the drug in question.

If we're talking about alcohol, then the rise in consumption is absolutely acceptable because 1.) those who abuse are now treated as addicts instead of imprisoned by default, and 2.) those who don't abuse it are now free from the horrors of capricious and arbitrary criminal persecution.

Same goes for marijuana and tobacco (which is, in my meager experience, the most addictive drug of all).

Now, if we're talking about meth or narcotics, then obviously any rise in consumption has to be taken very seriously, and then addressed by treating addicts medically as they should be, instead of sending them deeper underground by making them criminals.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by Crito on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @12:03AM (#6885992)
Ah yes, the good old "If you legalize drugs, next we'll be legalizing plastic explosives!" slippery-slope argume... wait what? That is one hell of a new one. You guys are getting more creative every day...
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by kristiandupont on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @04:15AM (#6886696)
That wasn't GP's argument at all.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by Crito on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @04:45AM (#6886770)
His argument devolved into incoherency. What little of it survived, has already been addressed at considerable length.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by felipe on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @12:51AM (#6886121)
> Why not say all chemicals should be legalized.

Very simple: Law enforcement protects individuals against the actions of other individuals, and not against themselves.

Your loved one needs addiction treatment (i. e.: heathcare), and law enforcement will not solve his/her problem.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by throwaway420420 on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @03:03AM (#6886491)
You are ignorant, have you ever been an addict? I doubt it, you've probably lived a safe life in your white middle-class bubble.

If you think you could just convince a loved one to stop doing dope and crank with words, you're living in a fucking dream world. I speak from experience, having the disease of addiction.

You are extremely naive, stop posting please.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by andyhmltn on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @06:22AM (#6887051)
The exact same thing can be said for alcohol. A substance which I can go and buy from the corner store.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by tomp on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @06:25AM (#6887066)
So throwing them in jail is your solution?
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by icebraining on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @11:41AM (#6888580)
As someone who has lived with an (heroine) addict, I can tell you that decriminalization was essential in getting him to treatment, but he did stop consuming (after a few restarts, and after hurting a lot of people around him). The months he spent in jail didn't help at all.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by kristiandupont on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @04:26AM (#6886731)
Ideologically I agree with you, I don't like the idea of the state deciding what I can and cannot do to myself.

However, I think you are trivializing it. The fact that some people do something that is illegal doesn't mean that the law has no effect. Alcohol is practically the only recreational drug I use and the same applies to a large group of my friends. I am sure that if other categories had been legal, they would have been more common as well. My parents would have had a harder time convincing me not to take something if you could buy it in a safe location with knowledge that the production was controlled etc. Now I'm not necessarily saying that this would have been worse, but you're suggesting that the only thing that would happen from legalizing everything would be that people would keep consuming like they do today (because people who want something can get it anyway), and drug lords would be replaced by taxable corporations. Which I think is hardly the case.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by Shamanmuni on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @07:31AM (#6887280)
Well, history teaches us that it probably is the case. During the alcohol prohibition in the USA, the situation was more or less equal than before it.

There aren't hard numbers of consumption during the prohibition (obviously) but statistics of alcohol related deaths and arrests seem to show that there was a serious decrease just before the prohibition, and after a few years it returns to its previous state, and was worse in some aspects.

http://www.druglibrary.org/prohibitionresults.htm

Also, in the Netherlands the marijuana consumption rate is less than in the USA, despite it being almost legal.

So, don't worry, things won't change much, except for those people who won't have to be worried about being arrested for smoking a plant.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by vasilipupkin on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @07:58AM (#6887391)
Cross country comparisons are difficult. Just because Dutch consume less marijuana than U.S. it doesn't mean that U.S. will not consume more when it's legalized.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by Shamanmuni on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @09:29AM (#6887754)
That's true, but the statistics tend to show that consumption rate is unrelated to its legal status.

As far as I know, there aren't any records of a boom in consumption just because a drug was legalized. And I'm not talking about marijuana only, but drugs in general, alcohol included.

Considering that, we can say that the fear of people going mad about a drug just because it was legalized is another myth of the "war on drugs".

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by paulhauggis on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @02:18AM (#6886372)
"I don't want or need your approval for what I put in my body."

I agree. However, I shouldn't have to clean up the mess. IE: rocketing health care costs and social programs that come out of my tax dollars.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by Nursie on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @03:55AM (#6886645)
So you'd rather spend your money on prisons, militarised drug police, DARE propaganda etc?

You could fund some pretty sweet social programs and healthcare if you took back the DEA budget...

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by mseebach on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @05:52AM (#6886947)
The DEA budget is less that $10 per US citizen. I'm all for saving that money, but it won't even buy the stationary for a "sweet social program".
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by Nursie on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @06:03AM (#6886977)
$10 per US citizen is over 3 billion dollars. I'm pretty sure you could do something useful with 3 billion dollars.

Hell, there are 10,000 employees at the DEA, in the most simplistic case you could replace them with drug rehab folks and that's a couple of hundred extra per state. That's enough to have an impact.

(-edit-- yeah ok, I may have overestimated the budget of the DEA, but 3 billion is not to be sniffed at, and the DEA is really only the tip of the iceberg)

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by diydsp on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @11:43AM (#6888592)
Your estimate is not far off at all. [1] Interestingly, 2013 was the first year EVER in which its budget and staffing were REDUCED.

[1]http://www.justice.gov/dea/about/history/staffing.shtml

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by auntienomen on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @07:48AM (#6887359)
As others have pointed out, $3B is not a small amount of money.

Also, most of the money spent in the drug war doesn't go through the DEA.

For example, DEA doesn"t run prisons. It costs about $50000 to keep someone in prison. We have about 3 million prisoners in the US. Suppose only 10% of them are in prison for drug offenses. That's about $15 billion/year. Pencils out to $50/year for each US citizen. So about $200/year per taxpayer.

Think a little and you won't have trouble finding other sources of waste. Wasted police time. Lost productivity of the imprisoned. Truancy among children with missing fathers.

Personally, I'd rather give the $200 to a harm reduction program.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by pantalaimon on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @10:40AM (#6888113)
> Suppose only 10% of them are in prison for drug offenses.

actually it's 50%.

http://www.bop.gov/news/quick.jsp

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by deelowe on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @07:37AM (#6887308)
What's the total cost though? I read somewhere that the cost to keep an inmate in prison is like $40k a year and a good majority of the inmate population is in there due to drug related offenses. And what about the intangibles like the impact the drug war has had on minority and low income populations? I'm with everyone else here. This really is a lesser of two evils situation and letting a few people get high and possibly ruin their lives is much better than the situation we have today with the US having the highest incarceration rate in the world.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by mseebach on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @07:43AM (#6887348)
> I'm with everyone else here.

Because I'm not? Or are you just knee-jerk assuming that because I dare to raise any comment at all, I'm opposed to the general idea?

Don't assume that ending the war on drugs will free up some large, discrete sum of money that you can go and promise away on "sweet social programs". The money saved (of which there will be plenty) is in hundreds, even thousands, of small pools across all levels of government, all of which are perpetually money-starved, and it will be gone like dew on a summer morning before you'll get anywhere near it.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by deelowe on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @11:11AM (#6888332)
> Because I'm not? Or are you just knee-jerk assuming that because I dare to raise any comment at all, I'm opposed to the general idea?

No where in my comment did I offer any judgement against you or your character. You're the one making assumptions.

> Don't assume that ending the war on drugs will free up some large, discrete sum of money that you can go and promise away on "sweet social programs". The money saved (of which there will be plenty) is in hundreds, even thousands, of small pools across all levels of government, all of which are perpetually money-starved, and it will be gone like dew on a summer morning before you'll get anywhere near it.

I assume nothing beyond the fact that the current system is massively expensive and demonstrably a net negative on society. My opinion is simply that the current system is worse than doing nothing at all and my philosophy is always for there to be less government intervention in people's lives than more. Therefore, my preference is that we end the war on drugs as I believe this is a better situation than we are in today.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by Nursie on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @07:49AM (#6887363)
>> The money saved (of which there will be plenty) is in hundreds, even thousands, of small pools across all levels of government, all of which are perpetually money-starved, and it will be gone like dew on a summer morning before you'll get anywhere near it.

Naive response - well excellent, by the sounds of it we've just freed up a whole bunch of funds in all sorts of areas for all sorts of other important stuff.

More cynical response - government waste and perpetual hunger for more cash is a constant and something else we should be fighting anyway.

Either way, I'm of the opinion that even if all the money disappeared off into a vacuum, the WoD is counterproductive. Even if we kept paying the DEA to just hang around and scratch its collective butt all day, we'd be making a positive change to society by stopping all action in the pointless 'war'.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by daveid on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @03:01AM (#6886484)
Well, would you rather those same tax dollars are spent on something that doesn't work with people not getting treatment, or on treatment for those same people that is likely to work?
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by slavak on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @04:06AM (#6886668)
The costs already come out of your tax dollars. Or did you think the massive anti-drug enforcement efforts and booming prison population are free?
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by Crito on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:48PM (#6885784)
That would solve most of the problems with meth. Quality control issues would be wiped out (and with them, many of the health and 'zoning' concerns). Stabilized price and availability would reduce many of the social concerns. The money formerly spent on pointless enforcement (lets face it, anybody who actually wants meth, has meth...) could instead be spent on actually helping people. With destigmatization, and eliminated potential consequences for not keeping a low profile, people who need help would be more inclined to seek help.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by Nursie on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @03:44AM (#6886614)
The current system is counterproductive in and of itself. It would be a positive step just to scrap it.

Yes, rehab centres, education and healthcare initiatives would be great and I totally think that we should have those and fund them from taxes. But even if we don't, even if we say "fuck it, legalise everything and to hell with the rest" we'd be far better off as a society. Innocents would no longer die in drug-raids gone wrong. Taxes that fund the war could be cut, suppliers could compete on quality and price, removing major reasons addicts die and steal. Criminals would no longer have an easy source of income. Lives already ruined by addiction would no longer be further destroyed by criminal records and prison time.

So yeah, legalise it. All of it. Now. We can talk about the other stuff later.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by berrypicker on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @05:15AM (#6886855)
Yes. Prohibition does two things: 1. Pushes drugs to a black market, which increases violence and cutting drugs with even more harmful chemicals and 2. Wastes money on a useless 'war'.

Notice I didn't say it decreases use, because it doesn't (evidence: see Portugal case study, they decriminalised drugs and use went down).

If that war money had been spent towards educating people how to use drugs safely, health care and rehabilitation, instead of putting people in jail for a victimless crime, well, you tell me if that's a good idea.

The benefits of drug prohibition (if any) are far outweighed by the problems it causes.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by rosser on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:50PM (#6885792)
Drug abuse and addiction is a medical problem, not a criminal one. Let's try treating it like that, and see what happens.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by rhizome on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @10:48PM (#6885786)
Mine is. It's a medical problem, so allow it to be treated that way instead of throwing people in prison to rot over and over.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by MichaelGG on Tuesday December 10, 2013 @11:10PM (#6885865)
Methamphetamine is already legal, it's a Schedule II substance. Ask your doctor about Desoxyn. Compared to pot, which is Schedule I and actually "illegal", not just highly controlled.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by celticninja on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @03:52AM (#6886634)
legalise it, regulate it, tax it.

that way you can afford to improve healthcare and education whlst simultaneously reducing harm by ensuring a cleaner product is made available to users.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by andyhmltn on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @06:16AM (#6887028)
It will probably make it harder to get if it's regulated. Plus you can open clinics that allow people to get 'weened' off of the drug instead of throwing them in a jail cell and watching them rot away.
Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by smrtinsert on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @12:52AM (#6886124)
That's right, lets throw drugs at the under educated and already disadvantaged that will help social inequality in our country greatly.

Why bother when mental illness has been linked to cannabis use in adolescents? It's so logical to just legalize everything and call it a day.

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by nate_meurer on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @01:37AM (#6886265)
Wow.

> "lets throw drugs at the under educated and already disadvantaged that will help social inequality in our country greatly."

They already have the drugs aplenty. But we do them one better by giving them criminal records on top of their addictions. Isn't that helpful! Plus, as an added bonus, prohibition ensures that the profits from those drugs go to actual criminal organizations.

> " Why bother when mental illness has been linked to cannabis use in adolescents"

First, unless I'm missing something, no one here has proposed legalizing drugs for children. Second, tobacco has been linked to a bible-full of hellish ailments for everybody. Perhaps you'd like to illegalize that and call it a day yourself?

Re:Uruguay legalises production and sale of cannabis by meerita on Wednesday December 11, 2013 @09:10AM (#6887679)
You think people will consume more, I think right now people is consuming with or without goverment approval. You don't need a law to consume, you just need a dealer, wich is really easy to find nowadays.

By making a good law about this kind of drugs, you just taking out lot of problems and saving lots of $$$$$ in survelliance and law enforcement wich, clearly by long proved stats, they don't work at all.