"What was your most recent valuation?", "What is the size of my grant relative to the full dilution of the company as of today?", etc, get you more signal with less social awkwardness. I mean, at a minimum, it's more of an imposition than "Give me the salary details for everyone at this company", which is for better or worse radioactive almost everywhere, and in addition to similarly being against the corporate interest also tends to disclose privileged information about folks who wouldn't even be listed in salaries.csv.
P.S. In my n=2 experience as a very small angel investor I am struggling to remember ever seeing the full cap table. I'd have to check my docs to see if I'm allowed to ask for it, but my limited social radar for the Valley suggests that's the sort of thing that would be socially contentious. Founders I invested in were very circumspect about getting explicit permission to be able to quote the fact of the investment publicly, to say nothing of the amount.
P.P.S. Disregard the above if somebody who does this on a more regular basis suggests that you're more in touch with reality than I am. It's possible.
Cap table transparency would go a long way in making VC-istan honest because the equities in salary tend to be small while those in equity are massive. If engineers in a typical VC-istan startup found out that the non-tech VPs and "product people" working 10-to-4 were making $140k while they make $110k, nothing would happen. That's not enough of a difference to set most people off. If they found out that those people had 1% while they had 0.05%, it'd be epic. (That's why VC-istan hides cap tables. It doesn't want to have to admit that engineers are commodities to it.)
If you don't want to work at a company where a pencil-pushing meeting-dwelling financier is going to earn an outsized reward compared to your efforts as a software developer, don't work for VC-funded startups. On the other hand, VC-funded startups tend to work on fun speculative problems, because they're powered by other people's money.
What a "non-tech VP" makes has nothing to do with an engineer's outcome. Obsessing about what other people in the company make is unhealthy.
I've asked that at every non-public company where I've had "options" and they've never complied. Just have to treat the options as confetti from then on.
But your final sentence is the best advice: treat the options as a potential windfall, but don't otherwise factor them into your decision.
Agree. (1) Don't ever take a salary drop for options w/out cap table, and (2) don't make sacrifices that would hurt your career or home life because of them either.
Most people in the startup world have evolved enough to get (1) but (2) is where startup culture tends to go off the rails-- people start working 80-hour weeks on career-incoherent grunt work for their options, blissfully unaware of the 10-100x larger grants given to all of the nontechnical VPs who go home at 3:30.
The cap table is, to this whole conversation, a MacGuffin.
Also, does it really matter if I know? A later round could have wildly different liquidation preferences that wipe out my gains, right? Though I guess that's true of dilution as well...
Most engineers who join startups think that the 0.03% allocated when they join will be increased later on, and that the initial grant is just a "teaser". I mean, it has to improve, just because it's so ridiculously low, right? (Well, no. In fact, it usually won't.)
Perhaps 5 percent of the engineers who join VC-funded startups would still join if they knew that (a) their equity allotments wouldn't improve, and (b) the founders wouldn't take a personal interest in furnishing them with the connections/credibility to be founders in their next gig. That number becomes closer to 1-2 percent when you're talking about good engineers.
Having the cap table --- which you won't get anyways --- does not actually help you here. A feeling of entitlement isn't what gets you improved compensation. An understanding of your value on the market and a willingness to stand up for yourself is what does that.
Put differently: so what if the cap table suggests you're unlikely to get an improved allocation? If you're worth an improved allocation, you'll get one or the company will lose you.
Could you point me in the direction of some sources that back up the "90% [in the typical case]" claim? I'm genuinely interested in learning more.
1. OP says: Once you’ve cliffed, you have the right to buy shares in the company.
"Cliffing", when used as a verb, refers to firing someone just before the cliff-- not an employee achieving it. It's something you'd rather avoid.
2. If the company isn't publicly traded, you should ask to see the cap table. If you're employee #30 and your share is 0.05%, that might be fair if it's a biotech that has already taken a $100M infusion from the venture capitalists (who'll typically take 90%, in that case). For a web startup, it's terrible. You need to know how much equity the investors, executives, and employees at various levels have, so you can evaluate your likelihood of getting an improvement if you perform well. Without the cap table, you don't know enough about the startup to decide whether to take a job there.