Re:Absurdly High Valuations
by bsirkia on Monday December 09, 2013 @11:34AM
(#6875020)
Sorry can someone explain a bit more about the Small Win Scenario and how you still get all your money back? Say Snapchat IPO's for $1B and you invested $100M at a $3B valuation, wouldn't you only get $33M of your money back? Or is that the caveat in "assuming Iām the most senior investor"?. Everyone investing at these valuation can't all be the most senior investor right?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Absurdly High Valuations
by james_alonso on Monday December 09, 2013 @12:46PM
(#6875489)
This depends on how the liquidation preference is structured. Sometimes each new Series is made more senior than the prior series, so the last money in gets paid first - in that case if the last investor put in $100m they would get it all out before any of the other investors got paid. In other cases, the different series of preferred stock have a "pari passu" preference, meaning they all have equal priority - so in that case, you'd calculate each investor's liquidation preference as a percentage of the total liquidation preference owed to all investors, and they'd split the available proceeds according to that percentage.
Re:Absurdly High Valuations
by hncommenter13 on Monday December 09, 2013 @02:37PM
(#6876300)
This is correct in an M&A scenario, but usually not in an IPO. In an IPO, the most common treatment of preferred is to force-convert everyone who holds it to the equivalent amount of common stock, and such a term typically appears in later-round VC term sheets.
Not only do public investors dislike having a junior series of common stock out of the gate (Google-style two-class shares notwithstanding), but the special rights that come with VC-type preferred stock (series votes, class votes, rights to appoint directors, anti-dilution, blocking M&A, etc.) are eliminated once there are public shareholders.
[Speaking as a former VC now public investor who builds and sells VC cap table modeling software.]
Yeah, I had the same question. If there are 2 investors each investing 50M, and they're equally senior, they both get half of the sale value if it's < 100M. They get 50M + 8%/y if it's sold for 100M-3B. And they get 1/60 each if it's sold for >= 3B.
That sounds like a good deal even if you think SnapChat is only worth 200M...
Ok, so the main thing I missed is the preferential terms that investors get in the event of a sale, namely that they will be the first money out.
I think he's saying the total investment is $100m. So if it sells for $100m, each individual investor gets his money back.
Hmmm, he does say "If I put a hundred million dollars into Snapchat today at a 3 billion dollar valuation, three things can happen:". Doesn't that roughly mean he owns 3.3% of the company, so would be entitled to only 3.3% of the return? Or in an IPO would he be one of the only ones selling his stock so he would get his cash out?