Re:Discoveries of Data Scientist Who Spent a Year at the New...
by mattlutze on Monday December 09, 2013 @06:38AM
(#6873846)
That (the article linked to the scientists actual blog) was an interesting read. Doesn't need to be revolutionary to be meaningful, and after maybe a bit too much introducing, I found the explanation of his work clear and the visualizations both meaningful and engaging.
Re:Discoveries of Data Scientist Who Spent a Year at the New...
by mcphilip on Sunday December 08, 2013 @10:34PM
(#6872714)
The "wildly speculative" Felix Salmon piece [1] referenced in the contently post takes a look at some of the actual data that Abelson collected. Of note is the chart showing how relatively accurate predictions can be made about how many page views a given article will have based on a few simple variables (e.g. did the main NYT Twitter account tweet a link to the article, etc).
However, I'm not sure I grok Salmon's angle of it being a bad thing that the NYT almost exclusively promotes proprietary content over stories off the AP/Reuters news wires.
Re:Discoveries of Data Scientist Who Spent a Year at the New...
by nl on Monday December 09, 2013 @12:54AM
(#6873001)
I'm not sure I grok Salmon's angle of it being a bad thing that the NYT almost exclusively promotes proprietary content over stories off the AP/Reuters news wires.
"Felix Salmon is the finance blogger at Reuters"[1]. There's his angle.
Re:Discoveries of Data Scientist Who Spent a Year at the New...
by petulla on Sunday December 08, 2013 @10:33PM
(#6872713)
The interview is meant to be for an industry news, journalism and marketing audience. Brian's blog is a place to find more in-depth reading. As these things go, this is on the light side of jargon.
Re:Discoveries of Data Scientist Who Spent a Year at the New...
by normloman on Monday December 09, 2013 @11:27AM
(#6874975)
This guy thinks news outlets aren't using data to make editorial decisions as often as they could. Maybe there's a reason his colleagues at the Times don't defer to his data. If the new york times made every editorial decision based on its effect on metrics like pageviews and social shares, you'd have the Huffington Post. The online equivalent of a tabloid. Newspapers have a responsibility to the public that transcends profits and popularity.
That said, we data could improve news consumption if used properly, especially in terms of testing user interfaces. Data should be used to design how people consume news. It shouldn't be used to chose what news to report.
Re:Discoveries of Data Scientist Who Spent a Year at the New...
by danso on Sunday December 08, 2013 @09:57PM
(#6872643)
The amount of A/B or other systematic testing in the news industry is...well, a bit behind par compared to the tech industry. So Brian's work is probably one of the most methodological studies done within a news organization.
Yes, it is true that media companies have long been obsessed with ratings and circulation figures, but these numbers have been, IMO, pretty "fuzzy." Before the Internet, there were also audience surveys and tests that purportedly tracked how readers progressed through headlines and stories...but how could such measurements be precise without computers?
Even on a news website, the testing is not so straightforward. Does one story get more eyeballs than the other because of a great headline, placement, wording of a tweet, use of a graphic? Or did it get more eyeballs because it was of a particularly salacious or notorious event? Since the number of stories that a news site can produce in day is relatively small...around 100 to 1000...and the number of variances between topic, length, media assets, time of day, is so large...I think Brian's analytical strategy was pretty keen.
Anyway, here are the original links from his blog. I think there as thorough of analyses as you'll find in other domains:
Great bit of work the data scientist did.
However, I'm not sure I grok Salmon's angle of it being a bad thing that the NYT almost exclusively promotes proprietary content over stories off the AP/Reuters news wires.
[1]http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2013/11/15/how-the-nyt...
"Felix Salmon is the finance blogger at Reuters"[1]. There's his angle.
[1] http://blogs.reuters.com/felix-salmon/2013/11/15/how-the-nyt...
That said, we data could improve news consumption if used properly, especially in terms of testing user interfaces. Data should be used to design how people consume news. It shouldn't be used to chose what news to report.
Yes, it is true that media companies have long been obsessed with ratings and circulation figures, but these numbers have been, IMO, pretty "fuzzy." Before the Internet, there were also audience surveys and tests that purportedly tracked how readers progressed through headlines and stories...but how could such measurements be precise without computers?
Even on a news website, the testing is not so straightforward. Does one story get more eyeballs than the other because of a great headline, placement, wording of a tweet, use of a graphic? Or did it get more eyeballs because it was of a particularly salacious or notorious event? Since the number of stories that a news site can produce in day is relatively small...around 100 to 1000...and the number of variances between topic, length, media assets, time of day, is so large...I think Brian's analytical strategy was pretty keen.
Anyway, here are the original links from his blog. I think there as thorough of analyses as you'll find in other domains:
http://brianabelson.com/open-news/2013/03/18/A-Metric-For-Ne...
http://brianabelson.com/open-news/2013/11/14/Pageviews-above...