Other vaccines have as low as 67% immunity (or even worse) - so, out of a class of 30 kids, with 1 kid not vaccinated, there would still be 10 possible "suspects".
And you would automatically charge the unvax'ed - turning many of the foundational concepts of law upside down in your hysterical crusade.
Your kid is unvaccinated, should have been, and transmits something to somebody else who is then injured? You should have some degree of liability.
Your kid is unvaccinated, could not be vaccinated *(too young, or had an existing medical condition that made it impossible) , and transmits something to somebody else who is then injured? Well, that's a shit situation, but there is not much that should be done in that situation.
Your kid is vaccinated, catches something anyway, and transmits something to somebody else who is then injured? Well, that's a shit situation, but there is not much that should be done in that situation.
These complexities are not intractable.
Given that you cannot necessarily determine the exact day of exposure in many cases, and that the kid who gets sick could have gone to e.g. McDonald's (exposure to another 100-200 visitors during busy times) or the mall (how many 1000s)... what sane person could be convinced?
We are actually quite good at tracing infections back to their source, but that is not my specialty.
Edit: As to why it's important, not vaccinating your children risks their heath, but the larger risks are to society and not you. So, much as vehicular manslaughter is far more serious than a simple speeding ticket if you take the risks and someone dies then it's your fault. Because, despite the fact thousands of people may do the same thing without issue, if you do it and someone dies then your responsible and they where unreasonably risking others lives end of story.
PS: Personal responsibility anyone?
That is not true for the casual meaning of "sick"; Typhoid Mary is the classic example of an asymptomatic carrier.
Of course she is also an example of how responsibility can be traced even when asymptomatic carriers are involved, and an example of how negligence and refusal to take measures to prevent the spread of disease is antisocial behavior that can (or even must) be dealt with harshly.
edit: I'm biased because yesterday my daughter had a mild reaction to a vaccine that was not listed on any of the information materials our doctor had given us. But believe me that's a bias I'll take to my grave. I'm not going to refuse all vaccines over that - but it's never your decision to make for us.
At least where I live, education is compulsory and vaccination is not, so it's illegal to refuse entry to a school based on vaccination status - I think this is wrong. I would like to be able to choose to send my children to a school where I feel like parents are taking responsible steps to not just protect their own children but those around them as well.
I'm also biased because I live near a town with a large hippie population and very low rates of vaccination for things like whooping cough. For the last two years there has been an outbreak of whooping cough, our doctor was pleased that they hadn't had a new case in two weeks. The child of a friend of my parents died age 1 1/2 from whooping cough. For young children the vaccination takes 3 injections over a course of months as they build up immunity - it's a dangerous thing, and I know people who think twice about taking newborn children outside here. If my child died of whooping cough (or something similar) because people around me didn't feel like being responsible members of society, you'd better believe I'd feel like pressing manslaughter charges. Whether I actually could or not is another matter, but it would feel massively unjust if I couldn't.
Sure, if by getting a flu shot you can reliably prevent infection. That's nowhere near as true for flu as it is, say, for polio.
Why are we even suggesting removing an individuals right to make their own decision based on their own research?
You're assuming there that most people make their decisions based on research - they don't. People's irrational fears affect their ability to accurately estimate statistical risk tremendously.
Plus we already do this - education is mandatory. What if I decide that my child would be happier not being educated? Should I have the right to make that decision?
That's not many steps away from mandatory abortions for undesirable genetic traits.
Of course it is - one is performed purely for the benefit of the individual (and perhaps their family) whereas the other is performed to try to eradicate communicable diseases which cause untold misery across the world for the benefit of everyone.
Why wouldn't you abort a fetus if you knew it was going to be a fiscally bad decision as it would need help to breath it's entire life. We don't need loafers that can't function on their own.
Anyone can be charged with murder even if there isn't a specific vehicular manslaughter statue.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vehicular_homicide
Oh yeah, and if you don't believe me:
http://abclocal.go.com/wabc/story?section=news/local/new_jer...
http://www.cnn.com/2012/06/06/justice/massachusetts-texting-...
http://host.madison.com/news/local/crime_and_courts/sun-prai...
http://www.fox11online.com/news/local/fox-cities/little-chut...
http://www.wbaltv.com/news/maryland/anne-arundel-county/woma...
http://www.ktvu.com/news/news/woman-who-killed-toddler-in-te...
http://www.nbc4i.com/story/20746093/1st-vehicular-homicide-w...
http://www.mygeorgiadefenselawyer.com/2010/02/12/vehicular-h...
Besides, what does vehicular manslaughter have anything to do with this?
That is already the case. It (shaming others) may feel good to some people but it doesn't appear to be effective.
“It is not a failure of the vaccine,” Frieden said. “It’s a failure to vaccinate. Around 90 percent of the people who have had measles in this country were not vaccinated either because they refused, or were not vaccinated on time.”
The reason the vast majority of those 175 cases exist is due to the lack of vaccination. That's exactly the point the article makes, and that's exactly the point I've made.
Europe has had a measles problem for a while. It's hitting America now precisely due to the reduction in vaccination rates.
I'd also support eliminating all public welfare programs for people that refuse core vaccinations. If you want to be a voluntary threat to society, you shouldn't get to piggy back on it.
It's beyond an absurdity that America should be drifting backwards on something like this, given the progress we've made in the last century toward understanding why/how vaccines work. Gates will help eliminate polio in India, just as we're reacquiring it here.