Sure, you'd expect some price increase -- anytime a group of people get more income, the maket-clearing price of things they have a non-zero propensity to consume can be expected to increase by basic supply-demand analysis. At the same time, except with completely inelastic demand, the increase in price will not be so much that the amount they are able to afford decreases, by the same analysis.
> would likely hurt those just above that poverty barrier the most as they would no longer be able to afford basic shelter even though they are gainfully employed.
I'd really like to see an argument for this. Since the people "just above the poverty barrier" are going to see the same increase in income as everyone else (basic income goes to everyone in equal amounts -- it isn't a minimum guarantee that is reduced 1:1 with outside income), what is the basis for concluding that the real purchasing power of those just above the poverty line would decline?
The poverty line has been suggested as a break-even point in some BI proposals, but certainly not all.
I haven't seen any proposals that have explicitly targetted a particular break-even point -- most BI proposals I've seen have targetted near-poverty-line levels of BI, which suggests a substantially higher break-even point.
(I've seen a few discussions of targetting a no-nominal-income-effect point considering BI and any necessary revenue measures, typically around the median pre-BI income, but that's not exactly the same as targetting a break-even point as you've described it, as break even is no real income effect, after considering inflation effects.)
What libertarianism is about has been a subject of debate between libertarians for decades. There are others who see it as an idealistic belief.
At it's core, libertarianism makes no statement about outcomes, but simply demands that people be free to make their own choices without being subject to force or fraud, and are then responsible for the outcome of their actions. Nobody is making any Pollyanna'ish guarantee that such a system will result in the most possible desirable outcome for everybody involved. The claim is that it's just the right thing to do, that most people will be better off (economically) than under other systems, and that you accept that every system - this one included - has its pathologies. You can't get much less naive than that.
There it is, that is the idealistic part.
But, again, none of this is really the point. Every system is flawed in its own ways, and the libertarian approach simply acknowledges that, rather than trying to distort reality and pretend that a "perfect" system is even theoretically possible.
Redistributing income can be expected to cause market-specific price increases in goods that the people benefiting from the redistribution have a greater propensity to purchase than those from whom income is redistributed. (And decreases in other goods.)
Adopting Basic Income is pretty clearly going to affect a redistribution of income.
So, the increase in prices for basic goods conclusion is sound (the idea that this will end up harming those just above the poverty line by giving them less purchasing power seems, however, far less sound.)
Its not like marginal propensity to consume of people in different income levels is a completely opaque mystery about which we have no information.
Not to determine short-term demand effects of redistribution of income there isn't.
> And I'm not sure if this degree of raise in income practically changes marginal propensity to consume that much.
Probably not, but since marginal propensity to consume is the amount of the next dollar of income that will go to consumption, that means that the consumption effects are fairly straightforward if you have an idea of marginal propensity to consume.
This is wrong. Libertarianism is about pragmatism, and a basic income would simply drive up costs of all basic things needed to survive especially if any of those are scarce. This would likely hurt those just above that poverty barrier the most as they would no longer be able to afford basic shelter even though they are gainfully employed. Because of this, those people will find it better to move out to land no one cares about and just 'do nothing' as decreasing costs is the only way for them to live decently. These people will not provide value to society, resulting in net loss of value (read: happiness, whatever you want to call it) for all.