News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Libertarian Case for a Basic Income by dllthomas on Thursday December 05, 2013 @03:51PM (#6857125)
The real purchasing power of those just above the break-even point will decline (as will that of everyone else above the break-even point). If the break-even point is chosen to be the poverty line, then we have pushed everyone toward the poverty line, be it up or down, as a first-order effect of the policy. Second order effects might move things up (increased demand from those below the poverty line leads to increased opportunity to meet that demand and "lifts all boats") or down (inflation makes comparable quality of life less affordable)...

The poverty line has been suggested as a break-even point in some BI proposals, but certainly not all.

Re:The Libertarian Case for a Basic Income by dragonwriter on Thursday December 05, 2013 @06:13PM (#6858100)
> The poverty line has been suggested as a break-even point in some BI proposals

I haven't seen any proposals that have explicitly targetted a particular break-even point -- most BI proposals I've seen have targetted near-poverty-line levels of BI, which suggests a substantially higher break-even point.

(I've seen a few discussions of targetting a no-nominal-income-effect point considering BI and any necessary revenue measures, typically around the median pre-BI income, but that's not exactly the same as targetting a break-even point as you've described it, as break even is no real income effect, after considering inflation effects.)

Re:The Libertarian Case for a Basic Income by dllthomas on Thursday December 05, 2013 @08:04PM (#6858651)
By break-even I had meant nominally. I don't recall where I saw them, but I do recall having seen it (BI has been on my radar for some while).