News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by ignostic on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @02:27PM (#6842509)
It's a joke among engineers that you need to graduate from college so that you can start learning. My college experience (non-technical bachelors) was just a joke, period - high school 2.0. Still, I wouldn't have the good job I do now if I hadn't completed my degree.

We keep running into this problem where employers think college degrees are more valuable than they probably are. Part of that is impressed culturally, but more than anything we lack better methods of certification in most jobs. We need certification that matters, is widely accepted, and that employers actually trust. It has to be marketed well, and it has to actually produce graduates with up-to-date skills. It's not easy, especially in fields where curriculum must change yearly.

Underlying all of this is a larger, unavoidable change taking place: the disappearance of unskilled work. Computers and machines are slowly taking over every unskilled job, starting at the least skilled and moving upwards to things we used to think of as skilled labor. Taxi drivers and factory workers will hardly exist in 10 years. Construction workers will only supervise machines in our lifetimes. Unless you want to work in a low-paying retail job for the rest of your life, you need to get a degree so you can work your way up some corporate ladder - or so the thinking goes.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by mortenjorck on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @02:56PM (#6842726)
A major benefit of college is a baseline of domain knowledge that will serve you in your professional career, but indeed, that’s also a major benefit of a technical program. The real disconnect is that college is also (or at least is supposed to be, or has traditionally been) a schooling in the liberal arts. Four years spent learning to think critically about society and culture as well as one's area of specialization, and to express oneself in the marketplace of ideas.

Which is just something many people don’t really care to do. And that’s fine. The problem is trying to get everyone interested in it, denying the fact that many lack interest and aptitude, and then diluting the experience for everyone while saddling the next generation with decades’ worth of debt.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by WalterBright on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:22PM (#6842904)
I've always wondered about the reputed benefit of learning to think critically from a liberal arts education.

For example, with engineering, an airplane built from your design flies or does not. There's no pretending it flies when it doesn't. Reality cannot be fooled, so one is forced to learn to think critically.

But with liberal arts, the same person can argue both points of view with equal facility - how does one tell which is correct? What good is being able to criticize without a mechanism for determining the correct way? Or even a better way?

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by streptomycin on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:50PM (#6843092)
Most engineers don't work on projects with as straightforward outcomes as "flies" or "doesn't fly", even in college. Even if they did, not everything that falls in the "flies" category is equally good. Deciding which is the most good for a given application can often be as qualitative as you perceive liberal arts. Furthermore, there are many engineers who have made careers out of doing little more than "criticizing without a mechanism for determining the correct way".

To argue from the other side, the point of liberal arts isn't to make you argue both sides of an issue equally. And telling a good essay from a bad essay can often be easier than telling a good airplane design from a bad one.

(Full disclosure: I'm an engineer and I only took 2 semesters of humanities classes in college.)

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by arebop on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:45PM (#6843063)
The liberal arts mechanism for ordering arguments is democracy!

The idea of liberal arts is that their study enables one to participate as a full-fledged member of society. Thinking critically about arguments that concern society requires not just checking the validity but also the soundness of an argument. I suppose you really need some understanding of culture and history to make up your mind about many issues of importance to the society in which you live.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by WalterBright on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @04:18PM (#6843256)
Re: validity of the argument.

In engineering, you learn to discern logical fallacies rather quickly. Insulting your computer (ad hom) won't fix bugs in your programs. Insults in issues of importance to society are the norm, even going to the highest levels.

As a lawyer friend told me once:

1. if justice is on your side, argue justice

2. if the law is on your side, argue the law

3. if neither the law nor justice is on your side, insult the other side

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by alexeisadeski3 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @04:48AM (#6845943)
"When the facts are with you, pound the facts. When the law is with you, pound the law. When neither are with you, pound the table and scream like hell."
Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by sliverstorm on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:34PM (#6842991)
Learning the engineering variety of critical thinking does not automatically translate to politics, social policy, or fiscal policy.
Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by sounds on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:15PM (#6842861)
Yup.

Where the grandparent said "employers think college degrees are more valuable than they probably are," you've highlighted the disconnect between what employers think they're getting from a college grad (certain skills) and what colleges actually do (teach students to think, to learn, to read).

That's not High School 2.0. In fact, High School seems to be the right place for vocational training. It's the pinnacle of state-mandated schooling, and in fact includes vocational requirements. Some schools implement that as wood shop. Others focus so completely on teaching computer skills they become a "magnet school" for that one thing only.

Unskilled work is disappearing and simultaneously employers are demanding more unskilled laborers. The work is disappearing because it's cheaper to have a machine do it flawlessly. The employers don't want skilled labor...labor versus capital all over again.

For a while yet, it may be possible to become really skilled in computing and successfully straddle the divide: make enough money to be comfortable as a skilled laborer. But I think it would be wise for _colleges_ to cross-train all their Science/Engineering students in business.

Colleges (traditionally) focus on the whole person. A person with business skills, connections, and potential funding becomes the new bar for entry. I'm always thankful my professors took the time to do that last part: take us (a team of students) into the real world.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by ahomescu1 on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @04:06PM (#6843195)
> Where the grandparent said "employers think college degrees are more valuable than they probably are," you've highlighted the disconnect between what employers think they're getting from a college grad (certain skills) and what colleges actually do (teach students to think, to learn, to read). That's not High School 2.0. In fact, High School seems to be the right place for vocational training. It's the pinnacle of state-mandated schooling, and in fact includes vocational requirements. Some schools implement that as wood shop. Others focus so completely on teaching computer skills they become a "magnet school" for that one thing only.

I'd like to argue for the opposite. Since everyone goes to high school, it should be a place to teach people to think, learn and read (that's how it used to be in some European countries). This is where students could explore and find out what they like, as well as read as many books as they can.

After that, college should be for white-collar training. You really do need several years of focused learning on certain topics before jumping in (I don't think you can ever jump straight into medicine, building bridges or designing microprocessors without a few years of reading in advance).

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by WalterBright on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:25PM (#6842924)
While I took mostly STEM classes in college, I did also take a couple accounting classes. If you don't know the basics of double entry bookkeeping and the jargon that goes with it, you're a bit crippled when working in any sort of business.
Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by digitalzombie on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:11PM (#6842836)
I've seen, heard stories of, and worked with the self taught programmers out there with out the degree.

This is base on my experience, but most of them are bad. They lack vocabularies and such that when they try to convey what they're doing or what they want other people to do or hell just to communicate with the team it takes a fucking long time and in the end might not even get anything done. They also want to get shit done without thinking about any other possible solutions or the consequences of their chosen solution.

I've worked under one. From my imperfect memory, he basically ask to make the API to be as good as their competitor.

When I ask more questions to clarify it. The said programmer got frustrated and threw a tantrum. Eventually, I found out the asshole, who lack soft skills, just wanted a async call methods in the api from client to the server.

edit: added most, because I'm sure there are a few exceptions out there.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by 67726e on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:32PM (#6842972)
That's the funny thing about anecdotes. You get to cherry-pick examples and make broad allegations from those cherry-picked examples. I'm a self-taught developer, and I've worked with plenty of "credentialed" developers that were either lazy as hell, having only gotten into software for the money, or were flat-out incompetent, again having only gotten into the industry for the money. That doesn't mean most folks with degrees are shit developers, it just means those ones were.

I think the real difference between the good developers and the bad is more a result of "passion" for the field. If your only care is about getting the job and the salary that comes with it, you may very well spend a lot of time and effort getting to that point, but you probably won't go beyond that. On the other hand, the guys on my team, myself included, are all passionate. Now that doesn't mean "slaves away for ungodly hours" or even that they spend their time working on side-projects. The common-denominator is that we very much enjoy the line of work. We try to be "craftsmen" and not just a desk-bound office rats. Some jobs allow you to get to a point where you just don't have to put forth much effort unless you actively try to be the best. Software development/engineering/<term du jour> is not one of those fields.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by digitalzombie on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @06:36PM (#6844004)
Passion is abstract and it's harder to show.

The degree is the best effort so far in our society that shows that someone is competance in their field.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by nogbit on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @01:24AM (#6845349)
"is competance" or "has competence"? While it may be the best effort it surely is misguided. It's given people too much faith over the years in a system that is old and tired, dated and not meeting market demands (but aka opportunity for those working on a solution, yay!).

I never finished my degree but instead I finished a ton of other projects, businesses and employment that has made me a ton of $$. And I would do it all over again for a fraction of that money because I go to bed at night (reluctantly) thinking about all the cool shit I get to build and program the next day.

Passion is abstract, excitement is visible. If one day you are looking to hire someone and they don't have the academia creds but do have the experience and are pumped up about your company, team, product or project then give them a shot, you wont be disappointed!

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by encoderer on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:34PM (#6842989)
I'll take gross generalizations and stereotypes for $1000, alex.

Here's a thought: knowing and understanding concepts is more difficult than learning the lingo. Why not just, very respectfully and casually, insert the correct word into the discussion and help the guy pick this stuff up? It's called "teamwork" and it's really quite good at making work (and life) better.

I've worked with too many guys with EE and CE and CS degrees that just totally fall down on the job to believe that a degree is the silver bullet of ignorance that you're suggesting. I think in reality it's about individual drive and intellectual appetite. But that's just my own observation.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by digitalzombie on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @06:31PM (#6843980)
>> knowing and understanding concepts is more difficult than learning the lingo.

I don't believe knowing and understand goes hand in hand.

Computer Science have tons of vocab. If you get rid of all of them then you mind as well spend the whole day doing nothing but describing all the absract concepts.

The reason why we invent vocabulary is so we can ignore the lower nitty gritty details and talk on a higher level and focus on the problems we're trying to solve. I don't need to spend more than sentence or so to describe a singleton. I can just say hey I'm thinking that we should implementing a singleton because it's resource intensive.

Instead hey, let's ensure that there is only one instance of this class because we don't need more than one instance. Even in that sentence, Instance is also a vocab of CS.

>> to believe that a degree is the silver bullet of ignorance that you're suggesting.

I'm not suggesting that this is the silver bullet. But this is an indication that a person have some competent to at least get a degree.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by cortesoft on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:00PM (#6842757)
As a computer programmer, this really hasn't been my experience. I did not get a degree in a computer related field (have a BA in Philosophy), but have had no problems getting a job. I just showed the work I did for personal projects, and landed a job in weeks. I have since hired many developers, and I only look at education experience if there is nothing else that shows they can do the work. I have hired many people who never went to college at all.
Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by fnordfnordfnord on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:22PM (#6842910)
My gut tells me that there are a lot of well-regarded programmers with an education in Philosophy.
Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by cheesylard on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:08PM (#6842818)
As a 19 year old programmer who just dropped out, this eases my anxiety. A lot.
Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by MrFoof on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:15PM (#6842863)
I was you 12 years ago.

The odds are still against you. You will lose opportunities due to credentialism. The best bet is to become better than your peers and be in the top 5% of the talent pool. When you work with someone who really knows their shit, shadow them.

The better bet is to eventually go independent once you know you're more towards the top of the heap. Years ago, a McKinsey subsidiary ultimately ruled me out due to a lack of degree. Nowadays they're a customer and have no problem subcontracting me out, because "I run my own business" and a proven track record is just as sufficient as the degree they otherwise look for.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by sliverstorm on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:35PM (#6842999)
I was you 12 years ago.

And it's even worse now.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by cheesylard on Thursday December 05, 2013 @07:25AM (#6854035)
Wait, really? I was under the impression that a college degree for programmers is less important nowadays.
Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by danudey on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:17PM (#6842867)
As a 31-year-old systems architect and software developer who dropped out of university: I realized that I had to choose between a degree I would enjoy that would be useless in getting me a job, and a degree that I would hate that would be useless in getting me a job. I wasn't cut out for EE or CS, and I didn't have the math marks to get in (and I didn't realize at the time that a lot of my problem was ADD-related). So… I left.

In the end, I lucked my way through a succession of jobs, due in part to the fact that my chosen career, systems admin, doesn't really have a university career path leading to it, so my personal experience was worth as much as anyone else's.

My recommendation: do lots of projects, contribute to open-source, put a bunch of personal projects up on github (and do them right; document them well and write good code), and apply to forward-thinking companies (startups, etc.). Show that you can do the work and no company worth their salt will care too much about how you learned it.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by gwright on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @12:15AM (#6845167)
> due in part to the fact that my chosen career, systems admin, doesn't really have a university career path leading to it

I need to put a plug in for my alma mater: http://www.rit.edu/programs/networking-and-systems-administr...

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by voidlogic on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:28PM (#6842940)
Beware, if you are outside of the Bay Area getting a degree is comparatively more important to employers... At least until you have oodles of XP.
Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by cheesylard on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @04:15PM (#6843238)
I grew up in Sunnyvale.

A lot of my friends from high school have part-time jobs / intern over the summer at the startups/companies from where around I used to live...

But I don't live there anymore. And I'm kind of hesitant to move back to Sunnyvale (It is the most boring, soul-sucking place on earth) so I guess that doesn't really count for anything.

Meh.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by aantix on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @02:36PM (#6842570)
I'm not sure why companies ever got away from the idea that they could avoid training employees? In Silicon Valley you see the same pool of startups competing for the same pool of Rails/Backbone.js developers all because they'd rather perceive to get a complete package up front.

The apprenticeship model should be re-embraced.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by fleitz on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @02:45PM (#6842642)
Fixed costs, overhead, etc, etc. Training people is super expensive when you don't even know if your company will exist in 5 years.

Generally, you don't want your DBA discovering the 3rd normal form halfway through a project.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by jonjanzen on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @02:53PM (#6842700)
With the apprenticeship model you have a junior DBA working with a senior DBA who knows 3rd normal.
Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by darkstar999 on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:31PM (#6842961)
This assumes that you can afford a senior DBA and have time to deal with a junior. And the senior has teaching skills. And so on. I'm not sure apprenticeship works in some industries.
Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by encoderer on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:12PM (#6842841)
Because that model worked well when a person worked for a company for 10+ years -- and often an entire career. But now? It's a poor investment.

Of course, this, like many factors, is both a cause and an effect of this more fluid labor market.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by wil421 on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @02:30PM (#6842530)
> It's a joke among engineers that you need to graduate from college so that you can start learning. My college experience (non-technical bachelors) was just a joke, period - high school 2.0. Still, I wouldn't have the good job I do now if I hadn't completed my degree.

Yes and yes I wasted the first two years in college learning High School 2.0 and the last 2 learning technical concepts that people used 5-10 years ago. XHTML, CGI and using tables for layouts to name a few.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by WalterBright on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:17PM (#6842871)
> My college experience (non-technical bachelors) was just a joke

I'm sorry for you. My college experience was very valuable to me (not for the diploma, nobody cares about my diploma, least of all me). I learned a great deal about how to solve problems, how to figure out what was important, how to separate truth from crap, how to learn, and the confidence that I can do it.

Caltech's honor system has also been very formative for me and I've applied it since then with considerable success.

The more I hear about other peoples' college experiences, the more I appreciate how lucky I was to wind up at Caltech.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by Houshalter on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @02:56PM (#6842717)
I wonder if algorithmic hiring would improve this. That is companies using statistics to sort job applicants instead of just a human. Even on HN there has been discussion against this and people are scared of it but I think it would be an improvement over human biases.

The statistics would quickly show that people with minimal or no education do almost as good, and are willing to work for less, and so they just hire them instead. Or maybe see that people from "lesser" universities are just as good as those from more prestigious ones. Maybe certification agencies would compete on the basis of how well their certification actually correlates with employee performance. Schools or training agencies could compete on a similar basis.