News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by WalterBright on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:22PM (#6842904)
I've always wondered about the reputed benefit of learning to think critically from a liberal arts education.

For example, with engineering, an airplane built from your design flies or does not. There's no pretending it flies when it doesn't. Reality cannot be fooled, so one is forced to learn to think critically.

But with liberal arts, the same person can argue both points of view with equal facility - how does one tell which is correct? What good is being able to criticize without a mechanism for determining the correct way? Or even a better way?

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by streptomycin on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:50PM (#6843092)
Most engineers don't work on projects with as straightforward outcomes as "flies" or "doesn't fly", even in college. Even if they did, not everything that falls in the "flies" category is equally good. Deciding which is the most good for a given application can often be as qualitative as you perceive liberal arts. Furthermore, there are many engineers who have made careers out of doing little more than "criticizing without a mechanism for determining the correct way".

To argue from the other side, the point of liberal arts isn't to make you argue both sides of an issue equally. And telling a good essay from a bad essay can often be easier than telling a good airplane design from a bad one.

(Full disclosure: I'm an engineer and I only took 2 semesters of humanities classes in college.)

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by arebop on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:45PM (#6843063)
The liberal arts mechanism for ordering arguments is democracy!

The idea of liberal arts is that their study enables one to participate as a full-fledged member of society. Thinking critically about arguments that concern society requires not just checking the validity but also the soundness of an argument. I suppose you really need some understanding of culture and history to make up your mind about many issues of importance to the society in which you live.

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by WalterBright on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @04:18PM (#6843256)
Re: validity of the argument.

In engineering, you learn to discern logical fallacies rather quickly. Insulting your computer (ad hom) won't fix bugs in your programs. Insults in issues of importance to society are the norm, even going to the highest levels.

As a lawyer friend told me once:

1. if justice is on your side, argue justice

2. if the law is on your side, argue the law

3. if neither the law nor justice is on your side, insult the other side

Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by alexeisadeski3 on Wednesday December 04, 2013 @04:48AM (#6845943)
"When the facts are with you, pound the facts. When the law is with you, pound the law. When neither are with you, pound the table and scream like hell."
Re:The college-for-all model isn't working by sliverstorm on Tuesday December 03, 2013 @03:34PM (#6842991)
Learning the engineering variety of critical thinking does not automatically translate to politics, social policy, or fiscal policy.