Re:Scientist who faked data in his thesis will keep his Ph.D.
by Xdes on Monday December 02, 2013 @10:44AM
(#6834304)
I think his dishonestly will end up helping him. Companies these days are looking for employees that will go the extra mile especially if they can produce fraudulent results and keep them covered up.
Re:Scientist who faked data in his thesis will keep his Ph.D.
by checker659 on Monday December 02, 2013 @12:26PM
(#6834988)
I was just talking about empathy. I thought stripping one of his degree for made up data is a bit too harsh. I'm not for dishonesty, just for some empathy.
A PhD is awarded for the contributions made to scientific discovery, whether the data is negative or positive (to the hypothesis). Doctoral training in the US has requirements for ethics training. This student demonstrated either a lack of understanding or a blatant disregard for scientific ethics. He also falsified his data, so he made no real contribution to scientific discovery. He has failed to meet two of the most basic requirements for a doctoral degree.
As someone who recently finished her own PhD, this is utterly disgusting. There is enough incorrect information in scientific literature as is from well conducted, controlled research because of the human error of data analysis and the fact that we simply don't know everything yet. We don't need it to be intentionally polluted by individuals who cannot or will not bear the rigors of research.