Now IQ. Let's look at the test. What you see is many different kind of questions. Pattern matching for language, geometry and numbers generally. What does it mean that you answer those questions correctly? It means you are good at matching patterns in words, shapes and you know math a little. That's it. It doesn't show anything more than that. Those skills does not even directly transfer to other areas.
Your exclusion of hyper-specialized people like professional chess player is actually hitting the spot on the point here - high IQ people are just hyper-specialized on IQ tests (I bet many of them practiced to solve them multiple times) and generally tasks that require pattern matching. It doesn't mean you can do math, that you know chemistry, politics, that you know how to communicate with people or what to do with money. Those are all learned.
If you can make analogy of brain as car, and the "life achievement" as distance traveled, then IQ would just be the speed, or power of the car. What flows from this is that you don't magically appear from NY to LA when you get a faster car (you are of higher IQ) than other people. It just means that if you go to LA with it, you might come there a little faster. This also means that anyone with lower IQ can achieve same things, it just takes a little more time.
Now, same as driving further even with slower car, or running faster (if you are more skilled runner) than stronger runner, people can also be more intelligent even while having lower IQ just by knowing more, having more experience and having more skill. Because they have spent much more time excelling these skills. That's why I don't even think it should be called IQ, I think it should be changed to PMC (Pattern Matching Coefficient), because it doesn't measure intelligence at all. Besides, when talking about intelligence, one must specify what narrow area you are talking about, otherwise it doesn't even make sense on it's own.
> This also means that anyone with lower IQ can achieve same things, it just takes a little more time.
One thing that is interesting is that a person with a low-IQ and one with a high-IQ seem to actually have different capabilities, not just speeds. A person with an 80 IQ, for example, would likely not be able to understand advanced philosophy or mathematics or some such at all -- even given infinite time. There's some ability to hold complex models, and weave, wind and connect through them that requires a certain level of intelligence that simply doesn't exist at lower levels.
Yes, I wanted to write similar thing too, but felt that post was too big already. Besides, I am not completely convinced by the idea itself - having enough memory, you can actually slowly link the most complicated concepts even when you can link only relatively "similar ideas" (brain of higher IQ has a tendency of creating longer physical neuron links, which some relate to the ability to understand seemingly unrelated concepts). The impossible part probably comes from the fact that the time and effort required would be inadequate.
Kind of? I mean at the cognitive level rather than the neurological one.
Are you sure? Who's to say the super-smart couldn't help us with other more mundane problems like understanding each other better, being more productive, thinking more rationally, etc.? I've had useful insights on these three topics that seemed very clever to me and I know of friends who have also had such useful, clever insights.
At the top of any HN comment thread, you're likely to see some clever, apt insight on a topic unrelated to science & math.
Regarding your examples, Marilyn vos Savant's IQ seems pretty sketchy: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marilyn_vos_Savant#Rise_to_fam... I don't know what evidence you have that Scott Adams is supersmart; he's a Mensa member, but I suspect many HN users could become Mensa members if they wanted to (an acquaintance reports that the intellectual caliber of a Mensa meetup is around that of a science fiction convention; the top 2% of the population is simply not that high of a bar).
I do agree that after you reach a certain IQ, determination, habits, ambition, rationality, etc. become larger determining factors in your level of success. But if you are smart enough you can optimize those manually for yourself ;)
Anecdotally, I grew up in a poor rural area, and of my gifted class (of kids with 130+ IQ), 15% didn't even finish high school. And, I'll estimate that 50% didn't go to college. In fact, of my immediate family (6), all have been gauged as having high IQ. However, I'm the only one that had finished college without help (by 90% luck). And, a couple of my other siblings have now finished college with my financial help. In my experience, location and family are much more important to potential achievement.
EDIT: As a non-biologist, but someone who can't read enough about science, I recommend the writings of either Richard Dawkins or Stephen Jay Gould. Both, actually, since they disagree on a number of points.
That said, I want to clarify something. When I speak of evolutionary fitness it is not a judgement of the individual regarding their actual value to the species or society. Evolutionary fitness is, really, a cold thing. It only matters whether the individual/species reproduces/survives. The dodo was an evolutionary dead end, even though the cause of extinction was humans, a pressure was applied that the species could not overcome. An individual that does not reproduce is another dead end. We, as a society, may look upon a Harrison Bergeron as the epitome of fitness (mental, physical), but if he's shot down before he can reproduce evolution doesn't care about him, his fitness is nil.
Is there any reason to believe that genetic issues obey a distribution where they are either very extreme, or have no effect at all? i.e. if everyone not classifiable as having a really extreme disease is equal? I don't think so.
I think it's much more likely that there is a normal distribution of breakdowns in fitness - a few very severe problems which manage to survive to birth, then many, many more variants with negative fitness, or ones which are good but very picky, and which may be left over from environments where they were +fitness. Then there are probably variants which are all-around good.
So the idea that we're all born with the same fitness level is a pretty extreme example of invalid "blank slate" type thinking.
But I thought it was interesting that the same list wasn't an intersection of notable AND did something you'd expect smart people to be doing. A list of Stephen Hawkings for example.
Or another way to put it is that IQ isn't a measure of intelligence but rather a measure of indicators that could indicate intelligence.
In other words, having high cheek bones and big lips doesn't mean you're beautiful but simply that you have high marks on the indicators of beauty that we currently use.
Any definition of great intelligence or genius would have to include its output, its product. (If you're the only person in the world, are you beautiful? If you have the greatest mind but you only use it to take IQ tests, are you smart?)
You can be a genius in any endeavor, in any field, but never on paper.
> There's very, painfully, few people who occupied their time with something that really moved humanity up a notch and even most of those are debatable.
You'd expect/hope it to be filled with scientists and great thinkers, wouldn't you? You'd expect Einsteins and Hawkings or something. But a lot of scientists don't actually have excessively high IQs. Above average, sure, but not super high. Turns out IQ and science are corelating skills, but not the same thing.
IQ corelates with lots of other intelligence-related skills, but in the end, it's just a skill like any other.
Incidentally, this is my gripe with 'intelligence' based selection systems in universities or companies. We conveniently forgo assessing people (and weighing) people's scores on categories other than intelligence.
Honestly, that does actually sound like the cleverest answer to me. Get people to pay you for things you'd enjoy doing anyway. It's at least as smart as those "follow your passion!" speeches we give to encourage people into tech-start-ups.
>There's very, painfully, few people who occupied their time with something that really moved humanity up a notch and even most of those are debatable.
Just because you're not in the Conspiracy doesn't mean there isn't a Conspiracy ;-). huehuehuehuehuehuehue
Also, correlate: there's an abnormally low number of people trying to "really move humanity up a notch" because, frankly, it doesn't pay very well.
>These folks aren't curing cancer, or stopping Fascism, or ending poverty, or worse, even trying to take over a moderate sized piece of real-estate and become Emperor of the Bronx or something.
Like I said, the incentives simply aren't there for the level of effort required to actually cure cancer, stop fascism, or conquer and run a functioning city-state.
Personally, I'm not so good on IQ, just a mere 130, but my superpower is determination. At least, I'm determined to make it so. That said, with my mere 130 intelligence, it's not like I can see so much better than everyone else where the workable paths forward are, the ones that are both rewarding and feasible.
We decided that a person capable of at least 10% above human maximum (or human average, I can't really remember) in at least two or three areas or 25% in one would count as "Super human". This excludes most hyper-specializers like Olympic Sprinters, or professional chess players.
Here's a fun video of the kind of deltas we were thinking of with professional American football players http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f8tYqT9GDd8
10% isn't all that much, but we felt like a person who could run an under 9 second 100 meter and had an Eidetic memory for example, would qualify as a classic super human.
But IQ, IQ was hard. We couldn't decide about IQ. IQ is normalized at 100, fussy to test, and has questionable meaning. But suspending all those questions for a bit, given an "average" IQ of 100, a 10% or even 25% delta isn't really all that impressive at 110 or 125, not even Mensa levels. But let's take the top .1% of IQ, around 145, a 10% increase there is about 160 and a 25% increase is just north of 180 and now we're talking. Kim Ung-yong definitely qualifies as a single ability super human.
Somebody with an IQ >160 should qualify for certain. After all a 60 point delta from mean the other way leaves you with an IQ of 40 and we're talking about pretty severe disability.
So somebody who could run a sub-9 second 100 meter and had an IQ of say...170 would be super human by this completely arbitrary thinking.
In the comics, people with these kinds of abilities, even as limited as this definition suggests, wear oddball costumes with the underwear on the outside and capes and either try to take over the world or try to save it.
But in the real world, what people with abilities even close to these kinds of metrics end up doing is decidedly banal and often somewhat narcissistic.
Fast runners just...run fast against other fast runners...they don't generally patrol cities and run down purse snatchers like the flash. Heavy lifters see who can lift the heaviest thing, they don't generally crack open burning buildings and fight thugs saving orphans like the Thing. People with both talents get organized into groups and end up seeing who can move a ball towards one end of a field over another. The really clever ones will parlay their fame into side businesses and open a burger restaurant or a theme bar or a line of sports oriented active wear.
These folks aren't curing cancer, or stopping Fascism, or ending poverty, or worse, even trying to take over a moderate sized piece of real-estate and become Emperor of the Bronx or something.
For the super smart, there's definitely work for them to do, but it's pretty limited stuff and you really have to like physics or math to do it. And let's be honest, Mensa and Mega aren't exactly wowing the world with a prolific output of revolutionary world changing ideas.
I think partially because it's hard to go off and do the kinds of fantastic exceptional things that the general populace thinks you could do if you were super powered. Running a little bit faster still doesn't absolve you vigilante laws, but it can get you a Gold medal and some cereal advertising deals. Being ultra-smart doesn't mean you don't have to deal with averagely smart people to get anything more complex than tinkering done. Nobody so far is so smart than they can hack their way through the rest of dim-witted humanity like Ozymandias from the Watchmen.
History has shown that people with exceptional intelligence (at least as measured by IQ) also go on to do rather hum-drum things.
- Marilyn vos Savant writes a 2 inch high weekly column where she gives advice and helps people solve Supermarket brain teasers and Freshman probability problems.
- Scott Adams created a mildly observant comic strip about working in a professional office environment
- Asia Carrera made a career of getting filmed while having sex and playing videogames
- and on and on, a look at some lists of known ultra-IQ folks shows a list of comedians, some more porn actresses and models, actors, some pro-wrestlers, a bunch of fiction writers etc.
There's very, painfully, few people who occupied their time with something that really moved humanity up a notch and even most of those are debatable.
Hell, HN is full of people who I'd guess are in the 90+ percentile and most of what we do here is pontificate and build chat apps so people can share pictures of their cats.