Re:Why are there so many crazy bums on San Francisco streets?
by andrewpi on Sunday December 01, 2013 @10:03PM
(#6831216)
My understanding is that the story of deinstitutionalization is a bit more complex: there was a movement in the 70s and 80s to have the mentally-ill returned to the community, instead of being treated in state institutions. However, many of the local facilities that the mentally ill were to receive treatment in were never actually established. At the same time, commitment laws were changed in many states, as part of a civil rights movement, to make it almost impossible to commit someone against their own will unless they were a physical danger to themselves or others.
Additionally, Reagan was never a legislator, but only served in an executive capacity, as Governor of California and as President of the US.
Re:Why are there so many crazy bums on San Francisco streets?
by jonnathanson on Sunday December 01, 2013 @10:09PM
(#6831241)
Fair points, especially about the commitment laws. And point noted about the use of the term "legislator" w/r/t Reagan. Good catch.
Re:Why are there so many crazy bums on San Francisco streets?
by clarkm on Sunday December 01, 2013 @10:52PM
(#6831435)
Considering that veterans make up 8.9% of all US adults [1] and that both veterans and homeless people are overwhelmingly male, 14% doesn't sound very high. In fact, I wouldn't be surprised if veterans were actually underrepresented in the homeless population as compared to the general population with similar demographics.
[1] http://factfinder2.census.gov/faces/tableservices/jsf/pages/...
Re:Why are there so many crazy bums on San Francisco streets?
by baddox on Sunday December 01, 2013 @10:55PM
(#6831451)
> California accounts for nearly a quarter of the entire homeless population in the United States
And, just for reference, 12% of the US population lives in California.
Re:Why are there so many crazy bums on San Francisco streets?
by collyw on Sunday December 01, 2013 @11:06PM
(#6831499)
So around double what you would expect.
Re:Why are there so many crazy bums on San Francisco streets?
by VladRussian2 on Sunday December 01, 2013 @11:15PM
(#6831545)
don't forget "export" from other states:
http://seattletimes.com/html/nationworld/2021804212_mentally...
"The state of Nevada and its primary psychiatric hospital “intentionally and wrongfully” foisted the cost of caring for indigent mentally ill people onto California cities and counties by issuing patients bus tickets out of town without making proper arrangements for their care, a lawsuit filed Tuesday in San Francisco charges."
Re:Why are there so many crazy bums on San Francisco streets?
by cafard on Monday December 02, 2013 @11:13AM
(#6834508)
"Greyhound therapy" has been around for many, many yesrs. I heard of it ca. 1980 and it wasn't new then--somebody was talking about it adding to the troubled population of Washington, DC.
Perhaps homelessness is inevitable to some degree. Perhaps some proportion of the population in a laissez-faire, competitive country like the modern US is always going to fall through the cracks. Perhaps we lack the will or the budget to solve the problem completely or permanently. Perhaps some people just can't be saved. I'm not going to launch into an armchair, pollyannaish prescription for solving this problem when I don't have a fantastic solution. (That said, I suspect the best long-term solution is at least as preventive as it is rehabilitative.)
Regardless, there's one thing we can control on an individual level: the way we view and treat the mentally ill and the homeless. Let's not further the stigma, or wax poetic about the homeless in SF as some sort of quirky, fun landmark. I suspect that's not the author's intention -- he's setting out to celebrate the homeless, not to denigrate them -- but some of his language lends itself to misinterpretation. As someone with a close friend who's been homeless, and other friends who've been institutionalized, I don't find the "crazy bums" characterization very constructive.
[1] https://www.onecpd.info/resources/documents/pit-hic_suppleme...