News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Buy Bitcoin by grey-area on Friday November 29, 2013 @03:31AM (#6818429)
That's really not a big deal. If it was truly popular and highly priced relative to everyday purchases, we'd just invent names for fractions thereof, and use those for pricing, as we do in reverse for currencies like dollars or pounds. They already have satoshis etc.

Far more important limitations:

Built in deflation - that it is seen as a one-way bet with ever-increasing value and an ever more limited supply would cause problems if used as a currency (though not obviously as a store of value). The problem for it as a store of value is that the value is entirely predicated on it being a successful currency.

Volatility - if prices change rapidly, that would make use in retail almost impossible, and as a store of value dangerous. Many of the places which say they take Bitcoin right now simply move the money immediately to another currency to avoid this issue - that's not going to work if it is actually used as a currency and to store value long-term. Imagine it replacing the USD for example and remaining volatile...

Time to process transactions - takings minutes to verify a transaction is not going to work -it'd need to be on the order of seconds, and for a digital currency it really should be as fast as the network.

Lack of regulation - again retailers/consumers should be nervous if their financial institutions have no regulations or guarantees that the money they say they hold actually exists at all. Some exchanges have reported a massive theft and walked away with no liability, others impose arbitrary limits on withdrawals etc - this really is wild-west finance and in a crash or bubble you can expect extreme fraud to go on undetected because there are no independent auditors, regulations or laws which govern these activities.

Lack of ties to identity - without verified accounts it's far too easy to commit fraud or theft - very like paper money which everyone is moving away from.

Lack of reversibility - it doesn't let you roll back transactions, though one could work around this by keeping a ledger and rolling the ledger positions back by transferring coins back and forth. If you're going to do that though and trust the bank/exchange to regulate transactions, why bother with the cryptocurrency bit at all?

Lack of transparency in the management process - who decides on the rules of the game here? If the official clients suddenly change rules in concert - existing bitcoin holders would have to just go along with this if the majority voted with it - when large amounts of money are involved, this sort of thing becomes very important. e.g. we hit the existing 21m limit, and those controlling the software decide to up the limit to 30m - suddenly lots of assumptions about value would be questioned. I'd be very nervous about the lack of regulated control.

Lack of backing by a government, corporation or trading bloc - when the market attacks government currencies, governments are able to expend extreme resources to mitigate outright panic and collapse. When the market sharks get interested in Bitcoin and attack it in the same way as they attack say the Euro, there will be no such backup, just a freely floating rate which is open to manipulation and depends entirely on public confidence.

I do think it has some interesting properties and is a useful experiment, but have extreme reservations about this being the actual digital currency which makes it into use as a global exchange mechanism.

Re:How to Buy Bitcoin by celticninja on Friday November 29, 2013 @07:18AM (#6819097)
i wont respond to every point but transactions can take between 10 and 60 inutes to verify, however you can accept a 0 confirmation transaction relatively safely if you were selling a coffee. The resources required to double spend against a sale of $5 is just not worth it. When it comes to larger items such as buying a car or a house then waiting 1 hour is not a problem as the whole process takes longer than an hour anyway so waitng for 6 confirmations is not too much of a burden.

"Lack of transparency in the management process" the official client is open source, any changes would have to be agreed by the development team but they would only come into effect if all miners (or at least 51%) agreed to the change.

It seems your points show you dont really understand what bitcoin is. Requiring it to be backed by a corportation or a government is exactly the oppositte of what bitcoin set out to be.

You should read more on it before making suggestions such as these.

Re:How to Buy Bitcoin by grey-area on Friday November 29, 2013 @12:06PM (#6820136)
however you can accept a 0 confirmation transaction relatively safely if you were selling a coffee.

What does relatively safely mean? I'd prefer transactions to be guaranteed and accounts to have a verifiable amount of funds in them - the currencies/banks we have now do this in seconds for small transactions.

the official client is open source, any changes would have to be agreed by the development team but they would only come into effect if all miners (or at least 51%) agreed to the change.

There's definitely space for conflict there. If the official client and/or lots of the miners decide something, it's going to be hard to get momentum in another direction, and as a small holder you will have no say at all. Given the huge vested interest of developers and miners, that seems ripe for abuse.

It seems your points show you dont really understand what bitcoin is.

If that's the case, it should be easy to rebut them. That you have replied with non-rebuttal rebuttals on two points and snide remarks for the rest doesn't give me much confidence.

Re:How to Buy Bitcoin by dllthomas on Friday November 29, 2013 @01:19PM (#6820395)
Relatively safely means probably less likely than someone handing you a counterfeit $5 bill. It's just not worth the expense to try and print it.
Re:How to Buy Bitcoin by grey-area on Saturday November 30, 2013 @06:22AM (#6822876)
What verification would be performed?
Re:How to Buy Bitcoin by dllthomas on Saturday November 30, 2013 @02:46PM (#6824325)
I guess if it's actually zero, it's like a accepting a check with a proof that the account ever had the requisite funds.
Re:How to Buy Bitcoin by Jd on Friday November 29, 2013 @08:26AM (#6819297)
What additional properties do you think are necessary to have a "digital currency which makes it into use as a global exchange mechanism." ? (full disclosure: I work on such a project)
Re:How to Buy Bitcoin by grey-area on Friday November 29, 2013 @10:21AM (#6819673)
Personally I think it requires identity verification and secure reversible transactions, and probably some central point of control rather than a distributed network (so that confirmation can be almost instant). That's what I get with current fiat currencies and I wouldn't want to give it up.

I also find the deflation built into Bitcoin worrying, esp. accompanied by the unquestioning cheerleading from many proponents of it.

I had a look at your website, and it looked really interesting - http://evr.gr/.

Re:How to Buy Bitcoin by Jd on Friday November 29, 2013 @12:55PM (#6820316)
That's basically what passed through my mind a year ago when I started working on my own project. It seems crossing the channel from "good idea" to secure, trusted payment mechanism is more difficult than I thought, but I'm still convinced it's the right way forward. Feel free to email me for more details if interested.
Re:How to Buy Bitcoin by dllthomas on Friday November 29, 2013 @10:27AM (#6819703)
"Personally I think it requires identity verification and secure reversible transactions"

Aren't those two just a layer on top of bitcoin?

Re:How to Buy Bitcoin by grey-area on Friday November 29, 2013 @10:42AM (#6819774)
If they are built separately, as I said in the OP, there isn't much point in the cryptographic nature of bitcoin. If you require people to trust those holding the ledgers of transactions you could just use any unit of account, as we do with national currencies.
Re:How to Buy Bitcoin by dllthomas on Friday November 29, 2013 @12:43PM (#6820271)
Bitcoin would permit bridging of trust networks.