News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by downandout on Thursday November 28, 2013 @09:21AM (#6814589)
Progressives seem to have lost all understanding of the concept of money. It is a means of trade. The spending power of the basic income will ultimately reflect the value its recipients produced in order to obtain it - zero in this case.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by tokenizer on Thursday November 28, 2013 @09:38AM (#6814667)
> The spending power of the basic income will ultimately reflect the value its recipients produced in order to obtain it - zero in this case.

What do you think the purchasing power of welfare money is? Furthermore, can you really separate the purchasing power of the money utilized in the minimum income and the income from working?

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by downandout on Thursday November 28, 2013 @09:46AM (#6814699)
I am not separating anything. I am saying that inflation will rise, because that's what happens when a country isn't producing anything more, but the country increases the amount of its currency in circulation. It's like a stock split - absent a rise in the actual value of the company, doubling the number of shares makes each share half as valuable.

In this case, over time inflation will adjust to the point that the spending power of the basic income will approach zero. It won't actually hit zero, because markets are not 100% efficient. But it will be close.

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by brazzy on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:21AM (#6814854)
> over time inflation will adjust to the point that the spending power of the basic income will approach zero.

Through what mechanism exactly? Please also explain why this hasn't happened with other, existing forms of social subsidies.

It seems like it is your understanding of money that is laughably over-simplified.

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by downandout on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:24AM (#6814872)
They will have to print this money, because there is nowhere else to get it. What happens when you print money but there is no additional demand for it? You guessed it...the value drops. Markets are surprisingly efficient at pricing things like this in.

Are you seriously trying to make the argument that their economy will absorb this with no effect on the value of their currency?

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by brazzy on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:53AM (#6815008)
> because there is nowhere else to get it.

Why that? Nobody's talking about abolishing taxes. Note also that the basic income would replace many other forms of social subsidies that already exist and have harmful side effects.

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by downandout on Thursday November 28, 2013 @11:00AM (#6815062)
Why that? Because you can't tax enough to fund a basic income for every single person.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by brazzy on Thursday November 28, 2013 @11:46AM (#6815256)
That depends entirely on how high it is, doesn't it?

Ultimately, it's not about money but about productivity. If the economy is productive enough to give everyone a minimal standard of living as well as comforts and luxuries for those who earn them, it doesn't really matter how said minimal standard of living is "funded".

And there is little doubt that the economies of developed countries are that productive for a reasonable minimal standard.

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by randallsquared on Thursday November 28, 2013 @12:37PM (#6815549)
You can free up ~4500 per adult in the US "just" by redirecting the "mandatory" portion of the Social Security Administration and the Department of Agriculture (which I believe is largely food subsidies, but I could be wrong about that). Drop Medica.. and tell people to spend some of their BI on insurance if they need it and you can just about double it, with no tax increases at all.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2013_United_States_federal_budg...

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by vilhelm_s on Thursday November 28, 2013 @02:17PM (#6815992)
Apparently the total income in the US is $13,401,868,693,000 (according to http://bber.unm.edu/econ/us-tpi.htm), which is about $43k per person.

So funding a $20k/person basic income would correspond to about 50% tax? Actually I think this is an overestimate, since the declared incomes do not cover social security and corporate taxes.

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by desas on Thursday November 28, 2013 @11:47AM (#6815259)
You can't tax enough to fund the current government spending either....
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by rycho on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:34AM (#6814913)
basic income doesn't increase the amount of currency in circulation...
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by downandout on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:38AM (#6814930)
How do you propose they get this money to give to people then?
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by rycho on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:39AM (#6814938)
Taxes? I'm not proposing anything by the way, just explaining that mincome isn't a proposal to print a bunch of new money. I think the idea is that it replaces current welfare programs.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by downandout on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:40AM (#6814944)
Whom would you tax? It isn't possible that taxes would cover all of it.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by jonknee on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:44AM (#6814963)
That's absurd, of course people will work. Why does anyone work right now when there are already welfare programs?

By your logic there would be no sense in companies paying bonuses--if you already have a guaranteed salary why would you do anything more than the minimum?

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by downandout on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:48AM (#6814983)
This is not welfare. This is giving money to every single person, and you cannot do that without negatively impacting the value of the currency. Reality sucks, but we still have to live in it.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by jonknee on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:54AM (#6815019)
How is it not welfare in your estimations? It's nearly the dictionary definition of welfare.

Why would it negatively impact the value of the currency and how is that any different than the current state of welfare (where only some people receive it)?

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by downandout on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:56AM (#6815031)
Because welfare, being given to only a small percentage of the population, can be funded out of taxes from the much larger pool of people not receiving welfare. But if everyone were suddenly on welfare, the system would quickly run out of money. We would then have to print more money.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by brazzy on Thursday November 28, 2013 @11:41AM (#6815235)
Your argument seems to rest on the false assumption that (like welfare) anyyone who receives the basic income is not paying taxes.

In fact, a lot of people would pay considerably more taxes than the basic income they're getting. Yes, that's not perfectly efficient, but still more efficient than the bad-incentive-riddled beaurocracies that exist to ensure that welfare goes only to the "deserving poor".

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by chongli on Thursday November 28, 2013 @01:58PM (#6815921)
We would then have to print more money.

You seem to be under the impression that this is not being done already. That impression would be wrong. The treasury creates trillions of new dollars every year.

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by bausson on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:58AM (#6815049)
Because people will get bored?

People won't accept full-time low-wage shitty-manager jobs, because they won't accept their lives being poisoned by shitty managers, and they will have the choice.

But most shitty managers are shitty because they have power over their low-education personal (which can be easily replaced, and job market is not good these day). Those workers will take part-time ok-manager jobs, mostly because they want to contribute to society, also because they might get bored.

Also, in most of Europe, University cost is quite low (like, less than 1k€ / year, instead a life-long debt like 'some' country can pull out), so universal income could bring interesting trends in education. Not everyone would go back to school, maybe almost no one at first, but I would expect views to change rather quickly on that subject.

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by d4nt on Thursday November 28, 2013 @09:41AM (#6814675)
We're already giving money to people with no job, this would effectively take money off people who administer welfare systems and give it to low paid workers who would then get benefits and wages.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by driverdan on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:52AM (#6815004)
Not at all. It gives money to everyone regardless of income. Welfare makes up a small percentage of GDP (unless you include all entitlement programs which this wouldn't). A basic income would be a huge percentage of GDP. IIRC in Switzerland's case this is about 25% of GDP. That's a massive increase in government spending.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by d4nt on Thursday November 28, 2013 @11:49AM (#6815270)
You missed my (admittedly subtle) point. Yes, on the face of it, it gives a basic income to everyone. But you haven't magically made more wealth so your average tax payer has to pay somehow. Either through higher taxes, a devalued currency, or fewer schools/hospitals. The people who do stand to benefit are those who would have been earning just enough to stop receiving welfare before. They now get to keep the benefits and the transition up the income scale is smoother. Meanwhile, those people who had a job administering welfare are out of work.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by nabla9 on Thursday November 28, 2013 @09:55AM (#6814723)
Progressives?

Did you know that Friedrich Hayek and Milton Friedman supported the idea?

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by clarky07 on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:19AM (#6814840)
Friedman supported a negative income tax. While somewhat similar, it is not the same thing.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by nabla9 on Thursday November 28, 2013 @12:34PM (#6815534)
Negative income tax is one way to implement basic income. There are others.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by summerdown2 on Thursday November 28, 2013 @02:48PM (#6816100)
> he spending power of the basic income will ultimately reflect the value its recipients produced in order to obtain it - zero in this case.

I'm always interested in these sorts of arguments and how certain some people are about how it will all end up. Could I ask how you have managed to be so certain about this?

Personally, I don't think economics is enough of a settled science to guarantee very much. The real world tests people have done so far have been intriguing, but I think a basic income requires a lot more empirical testing to know for sure.

Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by nano_o on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:00AM (#6814747)
But, to be pedantic, 1000 times zero is still zero, so you are saying that any income will be worth zero.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by downandout on Thursday November 28, 2013 @10:09AM (#6814780)
Yes, that is a pedantic statement :). The number will never actually hit zero, largely because the brief statement I wrote here is a drastic oversimplication of how currencies are valued. But it doesn't change the underlying statement - the basic income will be pretty useless after a relatively short amount of time.
Re:A universal income is not such a silly idea by nano_o on Thursday November 28, 2013 @11:04AM (#6815075)
Not really, if the total amount of money does not change, then the worth of the basic income would not converge to zero. Am I missing something obvious?