News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by dragontamer on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @10:43AM (#6808644)
On the contrary. Higher price means more hoarding.

Anyone who purchased _anything_ using BTC is kicking themselves right now. The current market conditions discourage spending of any kind.

Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by tlrobinson on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @11:49AM (#6809224)
Or they immediately bough more bitcoin to replace the bitcoins they used. Or they had so many bitcoins that they're happy with the price rise and the purchases were insignificant.

Unless all of your wealth is already in Bitcoin then buying something with bitcoin isn't really any different than not buy butcoins with your other currency.

Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by dragontamer on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @12:12PM (#6809436)
Tell me. Was the 10,000 BTC Pizza worth it?

https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=137.0

When the price of BTC goes up by orders of magnitude over the course of a couple of years, people are discouraged from making purchases of any kind.

Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by nkuttler on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @12:17PM (#6809488)
Really not sure why I can't reply to dragontamer, but yes, the 10000 BTC was worth it. It's one of the reasons why one BTC is worth $1000 today. Without this transaction we probably wouldn't be talking about it.
Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by dragontamer on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @12:24PM (#6809536)
FYI: Click on "link" and it is always possible to reply to someone. Usually, you are locked out of responding directly to someone for a few minutes. (The Hacker News way of talking is... bothersome. It is very difficult to hold quality conversations here).

So clearly, YOU value the fact that someone paid BTC for pizza two years ago. And you continue to value the fact that people are spending BTCs as a currency.

But can you not see that this dramatic rise in prices discourages future spending? Will you buy a pizza today for 1 BTC? For 0.01 BTCs? Or are you going to continue to hoard BTCs and hope the bubble goes even higher?

People spending BTCs is the true value of Bitcoin, and the promise of the future. I'm worried what will happen when people stop spending BTCs because they've all turned into speculators.

Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by runeks on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @02:49PM (#6810624)
> Anyone who purchased _anything_ using BTC is kicking themselves right now.

No. I have purchased several things with BTC and I'm not kicking myself.

I have purchased:

Caramels for 8.211 BTC 1½ years ago Caramels for 0.2977 BTC two weeks ago A DAC two months ago A VPS two weeks ago

Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by JamisonM on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @11:04AM (#6808822)
Yes, I find it fascinating that a large number of people appear to want to live in a deflationary world when all instances of such that I am aware of have been economic basket-cases.
Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by dragontamer on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @11:11AM (#6808876)
Its because they're speculators, not enthusiasts.

As soon as BTC crashes, they'll all be gone. But the BTC Enthusiasts will carry forward, and hopefully learn that encouraging this kind of speculation is harmful to the "currency" that they wish to create.

I do think cryptocurrency has a future. However, the current price bubble is a _failure_ of BTC, not a success story. The only ones happy are speculators.

Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by JamisonM on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @11:17AM (#6808913)
I think the apparent alternative cryptocurrency is one that does NOT have a fixed supply and thus has stable inflation built into it, the puzzle of course is solving the problem of creating the math that can act in that way that can not be disrupted by an unexpected advance in computing power.
Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by dragontamer on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @11:22AM (#6808964)
Or you know, when people simply recognize that BTC miners are the "governing body" of BTC rules and regulations, and realize that to solve this issue is as simple as changing the rules of BTC so that the rate of inflation is more sane.

But as long as BTCs are touted as a anarcho-capalistic wet-dream, no one will wish to see the truth. BTC Miners are the government. They can change the "law of BTC" extremely easily.

Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by fat0wl on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @11:43AM (#6809164)
Can they? (This is an actual technical question...)

I was under the impression that they couldn't. But yeah, it's shocking that people idolize the core devs even though they set up a failing system. My best idea I think was to set up a cryptocurrency that is 1:1 with the dollar, therefore if you need to print more you do it by well... putting some $$ in the vault and dumping the equivalent amount of units into the ecosystem.

Bitcoiners seem to hate the idea of using the dollar for stabilization though. It's an affront to the power of imagination and the aforementioned "anarcho-capalistic wet-dream".

Incidentally, Ripple seems to be an implementation of what I'm interested in. Yet for SOME GODDAM REASON I DO NOT UNDERSTAND, their internal cryptocurrency (XRP) has some dumbass dispersement scheme too.

Whyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyyy

Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by wmf on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @11:54AM (#6809269)
It's not exactly easy for miners to change the rules of Bitcoin because those rules are also verified by non-miners. The software would have to be updated.

Nobody has figured out a decentralized way to peg a cryptocurrency against some external price. You can't really measure the price that other people are paying in trades; you basically have to take their word for it, which means they would lie if it was in their interest.

Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by dragontamer on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @12:05PM (#6809382)
Non-miners follow one rule and one rule only: Follow the longest blockchain.

That is it. Miners build the block chain. The most powerful computers working together build longer-blockchains (on the average). If a blockchain fork were to happen (again, like back in March: http://bitcoin.org/en/alert/2013-03-11-chain-fork), the miners can simply "vote" on which blockchain they want to keep.

Non-miners have no say in the matter. The BTC protocol says to trust the longest blockchain, and that is going to stay for the rest of BTC.

Thats why I consider the miners to be the governing body of BTC. If Miners wish to build blacklists and stop stolen BTC from going through the network, they can do so. If Miners wish to change the rules of BTC, they can do so (once more than 50% of miners agree... their blockchain will ultimately grow faster than the rest of the miners, which forces the network to conform to their rules).

Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by wmf on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @02:21PM (#6810417)
I think non-miners also verify things like the coinbase transaction creating the right number of BTC (25). So if miners all decided to give themselves a raise, non-miners would treat those blocks as invalid. Crucially, the exchanges are non-mining full nodes.
Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by eitland on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @12:05PM (#6809377)
I saw something called freicoin a while ago where unused coins would be subject to inflation. (As far as I understood. I have no freicoins. )
Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by lukifer on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @03:08PM (#6810767)
It seems to me that the incentive to hoard is counter-balanced by the seller's incentive to lower prices and invest themselves, causing the two to meet in the middle.

Can you cite a real-world example of a deflationary "economic basket case"?

Re:Bitcoin Reaches 1000 USD by crististm on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @05:16PM (#6811535)
This means that the market is not liquid and the value is not real.