News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by VexXtreme on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @07:05PM (#6805242)
A lot of companies out there are run by total morons or psychopaths, this doesn't surprise me at all. This sounds like a combination of both.

I was recently introduced to a job by a recruiter and they wanted me to do a "programming assignment" which would take at least 20 hours, before I could even talk to them and see who they were. I was like, "Cool story bro".

The reason why I bring that up is because I noticed the same pattern here; this job ad is screening for desperate people lacking a spine. I can't imagine any decent developer with a good job applying for this. Only someone desperately looking for work and having relatively low skills would willingly take this job, assuming he's not an idiot.

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by kmfrk on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @07:14PM (#6805276)
The irony (hypocrisy) is palpable: http://www.penny-arcade.com/comic/2010/01/25.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by lsc on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @10:37PM (#6806154)
>The reason why I bring that up is because I noticed the same pattern here; this job ad is screening for desperate people lacking a spine. I can't imagine any decent developer with a good job applying for this. Only someone desperately looking for work and having relatively low skills would willingly take this job, assuming he's not an idiot.

Hey, 17 year old kids, and people who have been out of work for years need jobs too, you know. (actual skill correlates... much less than it ought with employment desperation, in my opinion.)

And it looks to me (and apparently, to you) like the penny-arcade folks are being pretty clear about what they want. And that's fine. Some people (usually very inexperienced people) really like the "hero ninja rockstar" rhetoric, and that's fine. I think many intern level folks respond better to thinking of themselves as rockstar ninjas than as interns. And as we're all clear on what that actually means, hey, if it makes them feel good, who am I to complain?

The other thing you need to understand is that most of the rhetoric about 'heroic work schedules' is empty. My experience has been that the people I know who actually work the most, I mean, once you take out all the time on hacker news and facebook? they don't talk about how much they work. In fact, they usually worry that they aren't working enough.

When I hear people crow about a ridiculous work schedule? I hear "I put in 45 hours a week at the office, but half that time is on facebook or chatting with co-workers" People who actually work a lot are constantly concerned that they aren't working enough.

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by joe_the_user on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @10:45PM (#6806198)
Hey, 17 year old kids, and people who have been out of work for years need jobs too, you know.

Yeah, they and similarly desperate people may indeed fall pray to this kind of thing. See below.

And it looks to me (and apparently, to you) like the penny-arcade folks are being pretty clear about what they want.

In this economy, ads saying "we're looking for someone to suck dry till we leave their bleached bones on the beach somewhere" can pull people in because ... desperation. See, your above.

But I don't care, such vampires need to be called on their antics regardless of this free choice.

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by lsc on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @10:56PM (#6806244)
>In this economy, ads saying "we're looking for someone to suck dry till we leave their bleached bones on the beach somewhere" can pull people in because ... desperation. See, your above.

Yeah... but like I said, I don't believe people who claim heroic hours. I don't believe companies who say that '50-60 hours' is normal. they mean that /claiming/ 50 hours a week is normal.

Yes, some people do actually work brutal hours, but they don't brag about it. They worry that they aren't working enough. Some employers really pressure people to work brutal hours, but they brag about that even less.

In fact, the places that claim heroic hours more often have beer Fridays and unfiltered internet access (and a culture that makes it okay to hang out on facebook and HN on work hours.) Generally, they also let you come in when you want, meaning that you can show up before your boss (It doesn't matter how much before your boss) /or/ show up after your boss (it doesn't matter how much after your boss) and plausibly claim crazy hours.

There is /extreme/ resistance to any sort of actual time tracking for this reason.

It's like the coaches who say "give 110%" yeah, they are irritating, and the rest of us look down on them, but there is a group of people who eat that shit up.

I'm sorry, but even if you are spending 45 or even 50 hours a week in the office (and the number of folks who go beyond that, ninja rockstar or not, is vanishingly small[1]) if half of that time is spent socializing or screwing off on the internet? it's not really that brutal. It's basically the same thing as being at home, except you have to wear pants.

Edit: dug up the source for the article:

[1]https://web.archive.org/web/20130309155432/http://bls.gov/op...

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by joe_the_user on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @11:12PM (#6806320)
Uh, the question of exploitation isn't really about how many hours about productive but about how many hours are taken from you.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by lsc on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @03:49AM (#6807159)
>Uh, the question of exploitation isn't really about how many hours about productive but about how many hours are taken from you.

Also, I am not sure I agree with this taken as a context-free statement. I mean, certainly, I think that the 'mandatory fun times' that are so popular are even more bullshit than "you can read reddit, but you have to be in this chair" - but not really because it's "exploitation" - it's not, except in the sense that every profitable exchange of money for labor is exploitation.

Comparing folks who make more than $60K/year and only have to sit in front of computers to people who work at McDonalds or Wall-mart or worse for 1/3rd that is... kinda insulting, I think.

A modern valley company is trying to be a social club. And, if you are the sort who goes in for that sort of thing? they do pretty okay at it. Not great, but pretty okay. For a "cultural fit" it's really not work, it's social time. I know I usually enjoy that sort of thing.

But, that's the problem. It is rough on those who are not a "cultural fit" - and I think that's a very bad thing, I think that a business is at a severe disadvantage if they can only hire from the group of people they want to party with. but most people disagree with me on that.

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by lsc on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @11:14PM (#6806330)
The study I cited measured actual hours in the office, not productive hours, so I stand by my point that most claims of hanging out in the office significantly more than 45 hours a week are bullshit.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by kamaal on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @03:14AM (#6807071)
>>It's like the coaches who say "give 110%" yeah, they are irritating

Honestly speaking I don't mind "giving 110%" provided I'm "paid 110%".

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by mcv on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @04:56AM (#6807337)
Are people really that desperate? I don't know how the job market is in the US, but yesterday I saw an article explaining that the US was still the best place for programmers. In Netherland, I don't know any programmer who is unemployed. The job market is very good here. There's no reason to accept a crappy, rotten, underpaid job, unless you suck.

So what is it, US? Is it great over there, or does it suck so badly that PA might actually find someone?

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by vellum on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @05:42AM (#6807452)
According to this study, there's an 8.7% unemployment rate for recent CS grads. For experienced CS grads, it's 4.7%.

http://www9.georgetown.edu/grad/gppi/hpi/cew/pdfs/HardTimes....

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by coldtea on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @03:03AM (#6807045)
>Hey, 17 year old kids, and people who have been out of work for years need jobs too, you know.

Yes, so let's take advantage of them... And if the market comes to that point that we can expect them to work for food, let's do that too... (while we're making tons of money from our business).

>And it looks to me (and apparently, to you) like the penny-arcade folks are being pretty clear about what they want.

Transparency is not a virtue in itself. Charles Manson was pretty clear about what he wanted too.

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by lsc on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @03:32AM (#6807111)
read the rest of my comment, please.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by seiji on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @07:11PM (#6805263)
Recruiting for a company that has fans (actual, fanatic fans) can be tricky. Sometimes you can play the candidate's enthusiasm against them. Sometimes they come in with unrealistic expectations and burn out in six months. Sometimes you do the sane thing and just hire somebody who has never heard of you.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by hobbes on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @05:00AM (#6807349)
I applied for a job a few years ago, which had two interviews.

The first interview was to determine my technical ability and character.

The second interview was for them to gauge my reaction to all the crap parts of the job. They told me about the level of social life, the tedious tasks I will have to do, and so on.

They said that, previously, they had talked-up the position to attract someone only for them to leave once they realized the reality wasn't quite so great. So, if I took the job, I would not be shocked once I got to my desk.

In the end I didn't get the job, but this is the only interview I have been in that didn't try to hide the bad bits or to over-hype the good bits.

So, yeah, unrealistic expectations are an issue. But, I mostly blame the hiring company for talking out of their backsides in order to recruit.

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by Tloewald on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @09:11PM (#6805769)
The big problem is going to be too many applicants. Suggesting the job will be shitty and low paid seems to be a great way to filter out competent applicants.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by trothoun on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @09:53PM (#6805984)
Maybe they are building a blacklist from the applicants and will post the real job description later.

If this were true I would be more at peace with the world than I presently am.

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by prawn on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @12:21AM (#6806586)
This seems to happen with (especially female) journalists writing for fashion magazines. Salaries are low but number of applicants is high.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by pyrocat on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @07:21PM (#6805317)
Before resorting to ad hominem attacks you may want to do some research on who you're attacking. Robert Khoo is neither a moron nor a psychopath. I disagree with his job posting, but it helps no one to attack the person behind it (with false insults) instead of attacking the posting itself and what it represents.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by singular on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @08:39PM (#6805641)
Ad hominem is attacking the person rather than their position on the topic at hand. This guy has played his hand and shown us his position.

Now what you want is us to take your personal view of this person as read and ignore his clearly laid out position. So really you're the one being ad hominem, though unusually being supportive (I prefer 'enabling') rather than attacking.

Let's forget who this is and discuss this person's job ad.

EDIT: A pre-emptive clarification: The fact that one could do research on this person makes no difference. The ad is the ad, the details of the person who wrote it are actually irrelevant here.

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by jsmthrowaway on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @09:03PM (#6805733)
To be more clear, ad hominem is attacking the person making an argument as an illogical response to said argument. It's attacking the argument by attacking the person making it.

Merely attacking someone does not an ad hominem make; since ad hominem is based in the study of logic, calling a personal attack such as the comment up-thread "ad hominem" makes no sense. The person posting the job is not entering into an argument.

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by singular on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @09:13PM (#6805778)
Yes, you're right, other than the idea that the job posting isn't entering into an argument - I'd say that it is, the person is taking a position that they feel this is a reasonable and justifiable job to advertise.

We can reasonably consider this implicit position and draw conclusions, and yes absolutely, because something happens to be a personal attack, it isn't necessarily ad hominem. Saying 'ignore what this person has done and listen to me telling you he's a great guy' very much is.

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by santoshalper on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @08:51PM (#6805684)
Man, that was exactly an ad-hominem attack. Exactly.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by singular on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @09:07PM (#6805754)
Discussing an accusation of ad hominem inevitably involves you discussing that person's ad hominem-ism, which is ironically meta-ad hominem. Unavoidable I think... though strangely comical I must say!
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by jsmthrowaway on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @08:58PM (#6805714)
"Ad hominem" is not a synonym for "personal." Just say "personal." Seriously, "ad hominem" is my new favorite HN drinking game.

Ad hominem: "Higher taxes are bad because you're the one suggesting them."

Personal: "You are an idiot for suggesting higher taxes."

See the difference?

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by ryguytilidie on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @08:27PM (#6805597)
I don't really get critiques like this. Because this guy was once a respected guy, he is totally allowed to hire workers to work under terrible conditions and exploit people and if you call him any names while he does so it is YOU that has the problem? Seems like a reasonable standard...
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by na85 on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @07:24PM (#6805332)
I think someone who so blatantly values his developers so little deserves to be insulted.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by eridius on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @08:22PM (#6805578)
What about someone who values honesty enough to actually list the accurate job posting, which honestly doesn't sound that different than a lot of jobs in this industry. The biggest difference is those jobs didn't actually list the bad conditions in the job posting.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by singular on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @08:41PM (#6805652)
So it's ok to be an abusive arsehole as long as you're honest about it? The only crime is to be a dishonest arsehole?

How about being a decent reasonable human being/employer? Or is that just off the table altogether in this discussion?

With limbo-like justifications like this I'm not surprised these kind of diseased company cultures exist.

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by nightski on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @09:41PM (#6805935)
Yes. You are acting like this job is not voluntary.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by VexXtreme on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @02:18AM (#6806937)
So a job that advertises terrible working conditions is suddenly morally upstanding and ethical just because you know what you're in for? What if you need money to feed your family and the job ad says that as a precondition to getting hired you need to give them one of your kidneys?

This is exactly why labor law exists and why libertarian/extreme capitalist societies could never function. The argument "it's a free market" doesn't hold water. Without a system of checks and balances exploitation will always take place because there are always people desperate enough to do anything to make a living. No matter what you say about "free markets" and "voluntary agreements", you can't convince me that it's right and ethical and a good idea in any capacity.

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by eridius on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @01:12PM (#6809926)
Labor laws? Holy crap, you are deluded. We're talking about a cushy white-collar job here. Yes, the expectations sound pretty bad, relatively speaking. But it's a far cry from exploitative labor.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by VexXtreme on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @11:24PM (#6813003)
Calm down, go back and re-read the sub-thread. We are talking about general principles behind the practice, not necessarily about this concrete example.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by eridius on Thursday November 28, 2013 @12:05AM (#6813108)
How very patronizing of you.

In the entire category of white-collar jobs the idea of requiring labor laws is ludicrous.

Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by tesseractive on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @11:23PM (#6806372)
Just because accepting a job is voluntary doors not give license to employers to exploit their employees. 100 years ago, that same argument was advanced by people opposed to worker safety laws and child labor laws. People use that argument to justify jobs where you have to sleep with the boss to get the job. The fact that some people are desperate doesn't give an employer endless license.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by wpietri on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @09:59PM (#6806008)
That some naive person "volunteers" to be exploited and abused doesn't make it any less exploitative or abusive.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by na85 on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @01:29AM (#6806783)
Unemployment is really high right now. A lot of folks might feel compelled to take any job.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by ryguytilidie on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @08:58PM (#6805715)
So the dude who writes the exploitative job description is fine, while the average business owner is an asshole because you assume their job sucks and they're lying. Totally reasonable logic.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by pyrocat on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @07:35PM (#6805385)
Well at least do some research before you insult him then? Here are some options: enabler, workaholic, calculating
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by vdaniuk on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @04:14AM (#6807217)
I am sure some people would find many things about you that make you deserve to be insulted, too. Empathy is not optional even for people you disagree with.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by rrich on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @07:19PM (#6805309)
I think it brings up the issue of considering at what time is it better to compete against them rather than join them.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by InclinedPlane on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @11:07PM (#6806294)
PA isn't a software company though. "Competing" against PA means having a web comic (or other artistic content) of your own, it doesn't mean doing software somewhere else.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by dllthomas on Wednesday November 27, 2013 @03:21AM (#6807086)
You could do software that meets their needs, and offer to sell it to them and others. Not competing with their actual business, but competing with their would-be internal development processes.
Re:Penny Arcade’s Insultingly Horrible Job by eru on Tuesday November 26, 2013 @08:42PM (#6805654)
Either compete or go into a different business. Don't take a bad job.