Maybe I'm just a little cynical here, but it seems the FDA would have better things to do with their time. That in mind, I wonder what spurred this...
http://www.fda.gov/iceci/enforcementactions/warningletters/u...
If you want to market your product like a drug, you should go through the regular inspection to make sure all your claims are satisfied, just like any other drug.
Anyone can make false statements and there should be safeguards to protect consumers, especially the sick and vulnerable.
Saying carrots are healthy is one thing, but that doesn't mean I should be allowed to market them as a cure for some illness because "vitamins".
But the cagey behavior from 23AM has been going on for longer.
yes, i am implying the gov is corrupt. it is.
and this the reason everyone pays hundreds of dollars for catheters and such, and any company that tries to improve the design and price of those items are all in legislation or royalties limbo.
Please cite a drug in the U.S. that has been approved by the FDA and has killed millions of people because it was defective. Overdoses don't count.
http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/505/u...
http://blogs.fda.gov/fdavoice/index.php/2012/02/50-years-aft...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paracetamol
> While generally safe for use at recommended doses (1,000 mg per single dose and up to 4,000 mg per day for adults), even small overdoses can be fatal. The ratio between fatal doses and therapeutic doses (the therapeutic index) is much smaller than for other over-the-counter painkillers. According to the US Food and Drug Administration as little as 25 percent above the maximum daily dose can cause liver damage when taken over several days
> In the United States, over 150 people die each year from overdoses, with up to 78,000 emergency room visits
Seriously? If they can't even be bothered to read the instructions on medicine (or anything they put in their body) then they have problems and need more help. Or need to learn to read.
This is just a bald-faced non-sequitur.
Should a company should be able to bury a clause in their ToS such as "by accepting this contract, you agree to forfeit to The Company your first born and every cent you ever make henceforth"? Of course not.
People should be able to knowingly enter into whatever contract they want. The problem is that (as I cited elsewhere) information/effort/payoff asymmetries makes such a scenario ripe for exploitation. Therefore it follows that regulations should constrain what can reasonably appear in a contract. One should not have to parse 100 pages of legalese just to make sure they're not tacitly agreeing to indentured servitude for the rest of their lives. If this were not the case, it would be painfully easy for unscrupulous business to bury unsavory claims under mountains of incomprehensible legalese. What regulation does is balance the scales in favor of consumers.
This does in fact follow from the fact that 99.9% of the public does not read and/or cannot comprehend every instance from the set of possible legal contracts.
Glad you agree.
Should a company should be able to...
Contract theory is far more rich a subject than you realize. In your example, a rational theory of contract wouldn't be enforced based on mere promise, but would allow contracts to be broken so long as it puts both parties more or less back to where they were before. E.g., if you promise to paint my home for $100, but then you don't paint my home, I can't then enslave you and force you to paint the home, rather, I get my $100 back.
This is of course an approximate explanation.
It would be helpful if you tied in statements like that to the main discussion thread so that I could respond in a meaningful way. As is stands you're not really making an argument so I can't respond to anything without guessing at the logical connection.
> ... Make sure to discuss your Genetic Information ... before you act upon the Genetic Information
The problems are not about what someone might do with their "Genetic Information", but with the accuracy of the "Genetic Information" in the first place. The false positives/false negatives mentioned in the FDA's warning letter[1] are not referring to misdiagnoses based on the 23AndMe's results, but to misidentification of genes in those results (as the letter describes it, "false genotype results")
In a nutshell: 23AndMe claim that the genetic variants in their results are (to some degree of accuracy) genetic variants that you actually have; the FDA says that 23AndMe have not provided enough evidence for these claims.
[1] http://www.fda.gov/ICECI/EnforcementActions/WarningLetters/2...
Really this goes for any company building medical services. Consulting someone on HIPAA compliance, as well as, FDA standards and practices is a must.
Is this fair in this case? Who knows. It is irrelevant. Resistance is futile.
"You should not change your health behaviors solely on the basis of information from 23andMe. Make sure to discuss your Genetic Information with a physician or other health care provider before you act upon the Genetic Information resulting from 23andMe Services. For most common diseases, the genes we know about are only responsible for a small fraction of the risk. There may be unknown genes, environmental factors, or lifestyle choices that are far more important predictors. If your data indicate that you are not at elevated genetic risk for a particular disease or condition, you should not feel that you are protected. The opposite is also true; if your data indicate you are at an elevated genetic risk for a particular disease or condition, it does not mean you will definitively develop the disease or condition. In either case, if you have concerns or questions about what you learn through 23andMe, you should contact your physician or other health care provider."
https://www.23andme.com/about/tos/