Re:33 Questions
by ebiester on Monday November 25, 2013 @01:38AM
(#6792826)
I'd suggest, "Do you self-identify as female?" There are slightly more women than men, so your bifercation is "female" and male/intersex/genderqueer. I'd suggest that currently intersex and genderqueer people are currently a small enough population that it would be close to 51/49 other to self-identified woman ratio.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
The question should be about biology, not stuff like gender.
Biology solves this problem (most of the time)
Not really. The stats have not been thoroughly calculated (to my knowledge) but here is an attempt: http://www.isna.org/faq/frequency
Not XX and not XY: one in 1,666 births
Klinefelter XXY: one in 1,000 births
There are other relevant cases, not necessarily measured here, like mosaicisms and chimerism.
"Do you self-identify as female?" is a more answerable question.
but doesn't 1:1666 mean the success rate is more than 99%?
Asking about the posession of an XX chromosome should separate the people almost 50:50, the rest is something else.
On the other hand, maybe there are just <1% people who don't identify them self with being male or female, so the questions would make no difference...
| On the other hand, maybe there are just <1% people who don't identify them self with being male or female.
Huzzah for logic. But note that the question was, "Do you have 1 apple" and not, "Choose a statement: 'I have 1 apple', 'I have 2 apples'"
True story, but "Do you have XX-Chromosomes?" would do the trick and cut the mass of people at around 50%.