News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Hope My Father Dies Soon by ygmelnikova on Sunday November 24, 2013 @12:21PM (#6790198)
Most folk would choose everything medically possible to be performed to keep them going for another 24 hours. Why question medicine and ethics when you can kick a Christian instead?
Re:I Hope My Father Dies Soon by rodgerd on Sunday November 24, 2013 @01:48PM (#6790547)
Please feel free to demonstrate that the majority of opposition to voluntary euthanasia in the United States is driven by groups other than Christian ones.
Re:I Hope My Father Dies Soon by ygmelnikova on Sunday November 24, 2013 @07:51PM (#6791913)
1. Hippocrates 2..
Re:I Hope My Father Dies Soon by FireBeyond on Monday November 25, 2013 @06:15PM (#6797782)
?

You may, or may not be aware, that the very vast majority of physicians practicing in the US today have never sworn an oath, let alone the Hippocratic Oath (which amongst other things, forbids surgery)?

As an EMS provider, my anecdotal evidence in the Pacific Northwest has providers overwhelmingly in support of "Death With Dignity" legislation.

Re:I Hope My Father Dies Soon by bzbarsky on Sunday November 24, 2013 @07:31PM (#6791849)
There's a difference between "going for another 24 hours, lucid and able to wrap up lose ends" and "going for another 24 hours, unconscious" and "going for another 24 hours in constant debilitating pain".

Most people would choose the first of those three. For the other ones, I'm not sure. And if you replace "24 hours" with "a few months" I certainly wouldn't choose either of the latter two options. And neither would most people I've actually talked to about the issue in person. Would you?

Re:I Hope My Father Dies Soon by smtddr on Sunday November 24, 2013 @12:27PM (#6790224)
>>Most folk would choose everything medically possible to be performed to keep them going for another 24 hours

And by "most" you mean people who would have a _quality_ 24 hours. Because the person of subject in this article certainly wouldn't have made that choice. He couldn't; his mind was gone.

Re:I Hope My Father Dies Soon by ygmelnikova on Sunday November 24, 2013 @12:34PM (#6790247)
And there's the rub.. you can't be certain.
Re:I Hope My Father Dies Soon by PavlovsCat on Sunday November 24, 2013 @12:59PM (#6790356)
But why disallow physician assisted suicide in cases where one is certain (as in, the patient is of sound mind, but in constant pain, and makes that decision), because of cases where you can't be 100.0000000% certain?

Have you ever seen someone suffer horribly for no reason and without hope? I swore myself that if I ever have a terminal illness with a bad prognosis, I would rather kill myself before it's too late, instead of risking ending up in a situation where I can't; where I beg medical staff to kill me and they have to say "sorry, but I'm just doing my job".

Yes, dementia is tricky, and so is suicide in general. It's a deeper issue than just being for or against it. How would we weigh the risk of people dying needlessly ("easier access to suicide and getting rid of the uncared for elderly"), versus the risk of people existing (I wouldn't call it living) in extreme pain, without hope, needlessly? I don't know, but I do agree that something has to change. Medicine is supposed to make life better, usually it does; but sometimes it makes it hell, and the ones suffering in that hell should have a say in wether they want out or not.