Followup questions:
How does Microsoft avoid hiring people below the 2nd percentile in computer literacy? They have way more than 50 developers.
Should the police force screen applicants in any way?
Is using a computer part of a police officer's job?
Are the police even able to compel randomly-chosen people to work for them? If not, the premise of your numbers is fatally flawed.
Is it more or less likely? The police don't hire on technical skill, presumably people of high skill in this area end up in different careers?
The accuracy of the numbers is, frankly, unimportant. What I was illustrating was the multiplicative effect, which remains relevant. I freely admit the numbers themselves were made up.
Now, it's definitely not true that you have to be below the second percentile to get phished: http://www.locusmag.com/Perspectives/2010/05/cory-doctorow-p...
But if it were true, phishing would be largely a nonissue for workforces (other than the police, who often do set ultra-low thresholds for their screening).
I think you and I are on the same page.
I am curious on why you think I'm off the mark, even if people under the 2nd percentile are less likely to get hired, it doesn't really change the math, it's the same as saying: "but it's only people under the first percentile!"
Side note: I feel that 150 million people are employable in professions that don't require a competency with computers. At the very least I'm grateful that same property doesn't apply to carpentry or construction. As I'm easily in the first percentile for these trades, I'd NEVER get a job. I can't even hang a picture! Why does it always go wrong? T.T
The ones I've seen are pretty good, all the lingo is correct. They're pushing all the right buttons in the email which would immediately get an accountant or business owner to open it immediately to find out what was wrong.
The only obvious warning sign is the zip attachment.