News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by toomuchtodo on Saturday November 23, 2013 @01:33PM (#6786893)
Unions.

EDIT: If you want to downvote, please prove me wrong. I'm happy to provide citations where law enforcement is responsible for criminal conduct, up to and including theft and shooting people's dogs for no reason, and where they're defended by their unions.

Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by mjn on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:56PM (#6787217)
The mere existence of a union shouldn't prevent dismissal cases from prevailing, though, unless something else is seriously wrong with the adversarial process. I'm represented by a union [1], and as a result I could ask my union for advice and/or support, if my job was terminated or if I were otherwise disciplined. Their lawyers would look into it and determine: 1) what advice to give me; and 2) whether there is a violation of rights serious enough to threaten the collective interest of the union members, thereby justifying the union themselves lodging an objection.

But the union would not defend me if their lawyers thought the dismissal was according to procedures and with sufficient evidence; it's not considered in the union's interest to defend clearly bad employees, and in practice they object in only a minority of dismissals. Even when they do lodge an objection in a given case, there is hardly any guarantee they will prevail. Why don't police unions work like that? My guess is a mixture of factors, relating to both cultural aspects (the "no snitching" culture) and ineffective oversight or even outright collusion from people who are supposed to be their adversaries in such procedures, such as judges.

[1] http://www.dm.dk/da/OmDM/Organisationen/English

Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by philwelch on Saturday November 23, 2013 @03:15PM (#6787271)
And who exactly determines the procedures? Isn't this something public sector unions routinely negotiate? American public sector unions (teachers as well as police) routinely convince the public that they represent the public interest rather than the private interests of their members so there is no one left to lobby against them, giving them a blank check to make it impossible to dismiss a union member for misconduct.
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by mjn on Saturday November 23, 2013 @03:24PM (#6787295)
Yes, the procedures are negotiated between the unions and the employers. In the case of public-sector unions, the elected government is responsible for representing the public interest in the negotiations. The legislature can also pass laws directly mandating certain procedures, if they wish, since ultimately the whole union system operates within parameters specified by the labor laws.

Imo public opinion has to align against police misconduct for it to be dealt with. If the public is offended by misconduct not being punished, this provides both an incentive for elective officials to make sure that can be done, and to police unions to be pragmatic about which kinds of interests they wish to defend; it may not be in the members' collective interest to defend a few bad apples, especially if doing so greatly angers the public. Of course, it might be in their interest if the whole lot of them are bad apples...

My impression, though, is that the majority of Americans are hardly concerned about police misconduct, and generally support the police against complaints, which doesn't provide very fertile ground for anyone interested in pushing reforms. You can win an election by being tough on crime, but can you win an election by being tough on police misconduct?

Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by philwelch on Saturday November 23, 2013 @05:42PM (#6787737)
But unions can effectively lobby the government, making it extremely difficult for the government to negotiate with public sector unions. Usually the union owns both sides of the negotiating table and gets a blank check. Just look at what happened to Scott Walker, and not even he crossed the police.
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by mjn on Saturday November 23, 2013 @06:03PM (#6787834)
Can't unions' opponents also lobby the government? The Fraternal Order of Police does lobby the government on criminal-justice issues, but so do large organizations like the ACLU, NAACP, National Lawyers' Guild, etc. on the other side. The difference seems to be that more voters and politicians side with the FOP's policy recommendations, than with those that their opponents propose.

In a democratic system, whether a major crackdown on police abuses happens depends to a large extent on whether there is actually public support for such a crackdown. Is the current situation that there is strong public support for a crackdown, but FOP lobbying is keeping it from happening? I don't think that's the case; my read is that the majority of people actually think the police are basically good guys who shouldn't be hassled more. The dissenters are a mixture of left-wing/minority-activist groups who are suspicious of racial profiling and police abuse directed mainly at minorities, plus some libertarian groups wary of increasingly militarized policing. But afaict by far the majority opinion thinks those concerns are overblown and supports the cops.

Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by philwelch on Sunday November 24, 2013 @12:26PM (#6790221)
That makes sense, but teachers unions have similar power and people actually do want good education for their children. I guess that the teachers unions fool people into thinking they want good education as well, but their real interest is the private interests of their members.
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by whyenot on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:53PM (#6787203)
> EDIT: If you want to downvote, please prove me wrong.

Your original post was a single word with no explanation and did not contribute in any meaningful way to the discussion. It's not a question of whether I agree or disagree with you, it was a crappy post and not the level of content I expect to find on HN. I gave your post, not you, not your ideas, a thumbs down.

Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by toomuchtodo on Monday November 25, 2013 @11:57AM (#6795209)
Entirely fair. In hindsight, I regret not including citations and expounding more on how I came to that conclusion. I try to contribute to the discourse of this forum in a meaningful and positive way, and reflexive, emotional posts don't forward that agenda. Your downvote was warranted.
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by SkyMarshal on Saturday November 23, 2013 @04:39PM (#6787562)
>please prove me wrong.

The onus is not on anyone else to prove a 1-word assertion wrong, it's on you to prove it right. More generally, every assertion is wrong by default, the asserter has to prove it true.

Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by crdoconnor on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:02PM (#6787002)
This is kind of like saying that defense lawyers are the reason why some violent criminals walk free.
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by philwelch on Saturday November 23, 2013 @05:44PM (#6787743)
If defense lawyers formed a cartel, got people loyal to the cartel elected prosecutor, and colluded with the prosecutor, you'd be goddamn right.
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by mayanksinghal on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:06PM (#6787028)
Since you are qualifying the statement with "some", a lot of people (including me) will have no qualms about agreeing to it.
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by moocowduckquack on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:24PM (#6787098)
I'd need a lot more qualification than that. If defense lawyers have only just been invented then perhaps you can say that someone walked free because of defense lawyers, otherwise it is just the actions of a particular defense lawyer and in that case if those actions are a primary cause, then a different defense lawyer could have had a different outcome, so it is not the existence of defence lawyers per se, that caused that person to walk free.
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by moocowduckquack on Saturday November 23, 2013 @01:53PM (#6786959)
reply to the edit - the existence of collective legal representation via a union does not by itself explain why these people feel they can act with impunity. I agree that having access to good lawyers does help a lot in employment cases, however I would say that either the police union is almost superhumanly competent in its legal defense of its members, or it is not the primary reason for police being allowed to behave like this.
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by hga on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:38PM (#6787157)
I am very, very anti-union (among other things, came of political age when Joseph Yablonski, his wife and daughter, and close to home, the driver of an explosives cargo truck were murdered by union thugs) and perhaps even more so anti-public union (a worse principle, but they kill fewer people), but they aren't sufficient to explain the Blue Line of Silence https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blue_Code_of_Silence that tells us that outside of a few, generally very small and rural departments, there are NO "good cops".
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by Zigurd on Saturday November 23, 2013 @07:38PM (#6788105)
> * aren't sufficient to explain the Blue Line of Silence*

That's very true in this case. Cop unions are just one aspect of the problem, and if you look at this particular case, no cop has been disciplined. The union, which comes into play late in the game, really cannot be a factor except very indirectly. There are dozens of problems upstream of the union that need to be attended to first.

Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by neurotech1 on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:12PM (#6787055)
A similar issue happens in medicine where to discipline or reprimand a doctor becomes a question of "Why is this doctor exceptionally bad" to warrant action. It can take a lot to get actual board sanctions against a marginally proficient doctor.

Most major Hospitals have peer review processes known as a Morbidity and Mortality conference where doctors behind closed doors can speak freely about poor outcomes and ways to avoid future occurrences.

The lack of major reprimands for marginal doctors is sometimes why people rush to lawsuits because standard review processes are usually avoid a doctor apologizing or admitting any blame.

In aviation, near misses in airline or transport category flights are sometimes investigated as "serious incidents" even if no damage to the aircraft or injuries occurred.

It seems if police adopted a similar review process where problems and potential misconduct are addressed in a non-adversarial way (M&M conference style) then attitudes and community relationship will benefit.

Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by toomuchtodo on Saturday November 23, 2013 @01:56PM (#6786975)
My argument is you believe you can act with impunity if you don't believe there will be any repercussions for your actions. So if it isn't police/LEO unions protecting officers from dismissal due to gross misconduct, who is it?
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by moocowduckquack on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:08PM (#6787036)
Other than union lawyers, the other folk involved could be other officers, heads of department, members of internal review boards, judges, magistrates, lab workers, district attorneys, politicians, etc. I agree that lawyers can help, but the lawyers are a mere formality if the process is corrupt in the first place. Unions are not normally some kind of magic shield, they are collective bargaining and pooled legal fees and have not provided the same level of protection that the police enjoy, in the other areas in which they exist.
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by moocowduckquack on Saturday November 23, 2013 @01:35PM (#6786899)
Other groups have unions as well and you can fire them all day long for criminal gross misconduct.
Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by jlanter on Saturday November 23, 2013 @03:34PM (#6787319)
"and where they're defended by their unions."

It's worth pointing out that unions are legally compelled to defend all of their members regardless if that person is in the wrong or not.

Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by saraid216 on Saturday November 23, 2013 @01:51PM (#6786949)
> I'm happy to provide citations

I don't believe you. I think you'd be sad to do it. Otherwise you would have already. And having lied about one small thing, why should I believe that you haven't lied about other, bigger things?

Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by toomuchtodo on Saturday November 23, 2013 @01:54PM (#6786968)
I know you're sarcastic, but what the hell.

http://www.policemisconduct.net/

http://www.policemisconduct.net/maps/searchable-map-2009-201...

There are plenty of incidents in Seattle you might be interested in.

Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by kafkaesque on Saturday November 23, 2013 @02:26PM (#6787108)
Does anyone know why Oregon has a higher misconduct rate than California and Washington? It goes against my admittedly stereotype of Portland, which I know may not be representative of the entire state. Plus, I understand big/major cities tend to be more progressive and cosmopolitan.

I'm just wondering what is at play in this state.

Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by raintrees on Saturday November 23, 2013 @03:17PM (#6787275)
I live next to the Oregon border in California (along the coast) and our local papers carry stories at least once per month about drastic budget problems north of us.

Our local Sheriff gave a Neighborhood Watch talk and mentioned the drastic down-sizing of law enforcement officers in the Oregon counties adjacent to us as a major concern and a potential source of problems for us.

Far more South than Portland...

Re:Store owner installs surveillance cameras to spy on police by erichocean on Saturday November 23, 2013 @01:36PM (#6786900)
Government Unions.