The people pushing for more sophisticated radiation shielding than tanks of water are hoping to get funded to build that stuff. It's unnecessary.
Again, the lethality rate for Mars transit is about the same as picking up a bad smoking habit. Acceptable for early explorers and initial colonists, and actually an argument for settling Mars as soon as possible. (Many people already know these risks, and they still want to go! Once you have a native workforce living up there with a local infrastructure, the risks are minimized because the resources for shielding form radiation are also more available.)
We are not going to mars anytime soon. Even a colony on the moon is not possible right now. We would either need to send people on once only short term construction trips, or some sort of robotic construction to make a shield first. Or a biological protectant of some kind.
Again nonsense. You can build bricks and masonry arches out of local Martian materials. Ship a "vault-laying" robot up there, and you can create lots of living space quickly. Bury it in soil, and you get the physical support to pressurize those environments as well as radiation shielding.
(You can't do the same trick on the Moon, because you need lots of water to make bricks. Far less of it on the Moon, and easily extracted concentrations of it are probably only at the poles. To build weight-pressurized compressive structures on the Moon, you're going to have to make silica blocks. A lot more energy intensive and expensive, with high temperature handling of materials. Smelting aluminum? Fuggedaboudit!)
Also, the radiation question is actually an argument for Mars over the Moon. Mars has an atmosphere that reduces the radiation load of humans walking outside. In fact, this is another reason why lunar industry should be established from Mars with teleoperated robots controlled form Earth.
The reason the high energy particles are more of a problem is because it's harder to shield from them. Especially without the shielding becoming a problem in and off itself. Which is more or less what you said. So you agree that hiding during solar storms is not enough.
I have no arguments about water working just fine as shielding. I think it will. It's the amount of water that is the problem. There is no practical way to launch the amount that is needed. And even once you launch it, it's so massive that you'll have a really hard time getting to mars fast enough.
I haven't run the numbers myself, but I've read works from people who have, and they say that it's not practical. Water is just too heavy.
PS. For the moon, there is little reason to build up - dig under instead, and line the inside with weak, but airtight material.
You're spreading pop-science FUD designed to create the exact misconceptions you are spreading. Read the other side in Zubrin's books and articles. No big conspiracies, just people using fear of radiation to sensationalize articles and get more money out of our federal government.
The reason the high energy particles are more of a problem is because it's harder to shield from them
There's less need to shield from them.
Especially without the shielding becoming a problem in and off itself. Which is more or less what you said. So you agree that hiding during solar storms is not enough.
By not shielding the entire vessel, you can create a small booth with enough shielding to also absorb the secondaries. Again, this is well trodden territory. Most public libraries have Zubrin's books. Read the other side, and you will find that you have been fed incomplete pictures. Shielding the whole craft is a straw man. Trying to give complete protection for initial explorers and colonists is overkill and FUD for selling expensive and unnecessary R&D to bureaucrats who want to cover their asses.
If you protect the astronauts from just the promptly lethal solar flares, you wind up with lethality something like a bad smoking habit.
I would gladly accept a 1% or even a 4% mortality rate if I could have the chance to be one of the founders of the Mars colony. My children won't have that problem, shielded by the Martian atmosphere and the soil used for radiation shielding.
I don't think you looked at a single one of the links I posted. You are very caught up in what Zubrin says, but you are not looking at what anyone else says. So how do you know he's right, and they are wrong?
You are wrong. The radiation is lethal. What you wrote only applies near earth.
And it's not solar particles that are the main problem. It's cosmic particles, which have much much higher energies, and do not come in bursts.
See here: http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=magnet-forc... and here: http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=shielding-s... and here: http://blogs.chron.com/sciguy/archives/2009/05/the_real_reas... and here: http://marsjournal.org/contents/2006/0004/files/rapp_mars_20... (pdf) and here: http://www.space.com/missionlaunches/080331-radiation-shield...
Is that enough? We are not going to mars anytime soon. Even a colony on the moon is not possible right now. We would either need to send people on once only short term construction trips, or some sort of robotic construction to make a shield first. Or a biological protectant of some kind.