News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Leonardo Da Vinci's piano heard for the first time after ... by tshaddox on Thursday November 21, 2013 @02:47AM (#6773543)
I think you're looking at this the wrong way. I don't think anyone involved in this thing, from da Vinci, to the modern builders, to the performer, to the audience, thinks for one iota that the purpose or destiny of this machine is to replace or diminish string musicians to any extent.

I see this as an exercise in technology and history, and a celebration of what was certainly an innovative idea in da Vinci's time. Really, it makes more sense to think of the viola organista as a synthesizer or a sampler, invented centuries before the modern electric and electronic incarnations.

On the more practical side, before synthesizers and samplers, this would probably have been a ground-breaking tool for composers. To be able to play and hear rough arrangements of string pieces (again, not to replace string musicians, but rather to easily hear a much closer approximation than any contemporary keyboard instrument could produce) would no doubt have been amazing for composers in that period.

Re:Leonardo Da Vinci's piano heard for the first time after ... by fragsworth on Thursday November 21, 2013 @03:04AM (#6773581)
It has plenty of room to be perfected and I see no reason to discard the possibility that it could become a legitimate instrument in a concert hall.

There are plenty of possible variables in how you play it - the sharpness, speed and strength of hitting keys... the rate at which you spin the bow... and damping. It might be considered more complex than a piano.

Re:Leonardo Da Vinci's piano heard for the first time after ... by marquis on Thursday November 21, 2013 @08:27AM (#6774540)
It's a beautiful instrument for what it is, but absolutely not as much diversity or complexity as a piano. You can hear the entire music is at almost a single volume, more like a pump organ. The reverb you hear is from the room. I think it's an interesting and new way to hear Marais (which for me was the most successful of the pieces) but it's a period piece, the same way the harpsichord never made much past the 18th century.

note: Actually interesting to read the Youtube comments on this.

Re:Leonardo Da Vinci's piano heard for the first time after ... by reneherse on Thursday November 21, 2013 @04:08AM (#6773755)
>think of the viola organista as a synthesizer or a sampler

Definitely. Or even as a kind of crude sequencer, as demonstrated (I believe unintentionally) by this test clip of a similar instrument: [1]

The instrument is called a geigenwerk, which I gather is approximately just a smaller viola organista. The builder's page [2] has excellent documentation of the inner mechanism, which sadly was absent from the video of the OP.

[1]http://obuchi.music.coocan.jp/Geigenwerk/Geigenwerk3/Image/M...

[2]http://obuchi.music.coocan.jp/Geigenwerk/index-e.htm